Post-Gazette

Anglers on Pymatuning Lake are currently limited to using motors of 9.9 horsepower or less on their boats.

Click photo for larger image.

The horsepower issue at Pymatuning Lake in Pymatuning State Park remains unresolved.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania lawmakers included Pymatuning when they agreed to a maximum of 20 horsepower outboard engines on several state park lakes more than two years ago, but Ohio wouldn't concur.

According to Ohio Department of Parks and Recreation business manager Ron Kus, that situation probably won't change anytime soon.

"We've invested a lot of staff hours on this, but it hasn't even been introduced into our legislature," he said.

In two public hearings Ohio has held on the horsepower issue, people who live along the lake voiced opposition to any increase.

"Local folks are concerned about speed boats and cigarette boats, about water skiiers and people being pulled on tubes," Kus said. "They're concerned about maintaining the character of the lake."

Advertise with us

Bill Blangger of Monongahela, a Pymatuning regular, said a horsepower increase is a matter of safety.

"We've had some close calls in our 9.9," said Blangger, who owns a 16- foot aluminum Starcraft. "It doesn't have the push to get you off the lake fast when the wind kicks up and the waves come up fast. It just doesn't have the power. Last week, we stopped at [Lake] Arthur on our way home and even with a 20 horsepower you could feel the difference. There's just no comparison."

Bass guide Darl Black of Cochranton agrees.

"Every angler I know that fishes state park lakes favors going to 25 horsepower, and that's because major American boat manufacturers don't make 20s and they want to buy American," he said. "Today's small fishing boats are longer, wider, deeper and heavier with equipment than the same type of boat 40 years ago, and need a 20 or a 25 horsepower engine to run safely on unlimited lakes, as opposed to plowing waves."

Thinking they were giving boaters more buying options, Pennsylvania lawmakers within the past three years approved first an 18 horsepower and then a 20 horsepower increase on Pymatuning, Lake Marburg (Codorus State Park), Lake Wilhelm (Goddard State Park), Lake Arthur (Moraine State Park), Lake Nockamixon (Nockamixon State Park), Glendale Lake (Prince Gallitzin State Park) and Yellow Creek Lake (Yellow Creek State Park). Except for Yellow Creek Lake, the lakes are all are more than 1,000 acres.

Advertise with us

Unlimited horsepower was approved for Beltzville State Park's 2,972 acre lake, Neshaminy State Park on the Delaware River, Elk State Park's dam on the east branch of the Clarion River, Presque Isle in Erie, Bald Eagle State Park's 1,730-acre lake, Susquehanna and Shikellamy state parks on the Susquehanna River.

But Pymatuning remains in limbo because Ohio, which shares ownership of the lake, has not agreed.

"Pennsylvania should be twisting Ohio's arm on this," Black said. "After all, we own most of the lake."

Correction/Clarification: (Published Oct. 20, 2004) The Pennsylvania Legislature has approved an increase in the boat engine horsepower allowed on Pymatuning Lake to a maximum of 20 horsepower, although it has not been implemented because Ohio, which shares ownership of the reservoir, has not agreed. An article on the Oct. 17, 2004 Outdoors page incorrectly reported that Pennsylvania had agreed to drop horsepower limits on Pymatuning. The article also omitted the first name of boater Bill Blangger. Also the word "not" was omitted from a caption accompanying a photo with the story, changing its meaning. The caption should have said that many boaters said motors of 9.9 horsepower are not enough to get them out of trouble on Pymatuning Lake.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.