The long debate over deer management in Pennsylvania took a bizarre turn two weeks ago when several newspapers reported that the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (DCNR) was considering introducing wolves and cougars on state forest lands to control deer populations. The report sparked quick opposition from hunters and letters of concern to the DCNR from state legislators.

Simultaneously, DCNR secretary Michael DiBerardinis announced a moratorium on DCNR grants to land conservancies intending to use the funds to buy land for transfer to the Pennsylvania Game Commission. The moratorium, according to DiBerardinis, was meant to convey DCNR's frustration with slow progress in reducing deer herds on Pennsylvania's two million acres of state forest land.

"I have very few ways of addressing this issue other than through rhetoric. I think I have to do this as secretary to fulfill our mission," DiBerardinis said. "We're not going to buy less land. We're just not going to buy land that's going to the Game Commission."

Amid that background, DiBerardinis appeared before the Game Commission's quarterly meeting Tuesday in State College to appeal for greater cooperation between the two agencies. "I am here today to open direct lines of communication with you so we can begin the open and honest dialogue needed to build the working relationship essential for meeting the challenges ahead," DiBerardinis told the commission.

Advertise with us

DiBerardinis began by announcing that his office and Gov. Edward Rendell were not pushing for a merger of the Game Commission and Fish and Boat Commission with DCNR.

"Within a few months of being appointed secretary, it became apparent that building any kind of meaningful relationship with the Game Commission, and this also applied to the Fish and Boat Commission, was going to be futile with the growing paranoia swirling around the possible merger of both commissions and the expected takeover of these agencies by DCNR," he said.

"Finding new ground defined the immediate task as addressing the merger head-on and taking the merger discussions off the table as the first step in creating the climate for cooperation and actualizing Gov. Rendell's natural resource priorities."

He then addressed the subject that commissioners and hunters in attendance wanted most to hear about -- deer.

DiBerardinis told commissioners that DCNR's state forest lands had suffered from heavy deer browsing for decades and that the problem of failed forest regeneration was so severe that new seedlings do not survive unless fences are erected to exclude deer.

Advertise with us

"On state forest lands, building exclosures to assure regeneration is a requirement for harvesting timber," DiBerardinis said. "The fencing costs alone total more than $2 million annually. Currently, we have over 800 miles of deer fencing on state forest lands. That is almost equivalent to having an eight foot fence run from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh, up to Erie, over to Scranton, and then back to Philadelphia."

DiBerardinis acknowledged that many hunters are seeing fewer deer on state forest lands but asked for their cooperation to bring the herds down even further.

"To our hunters in some areas of the state who are complaining that they are not seeing as many deer, I say that you are right," DiBerardinis said. "But the reason has more to do with the habitat having been devastated to such an extent that even smaller numbers of deer are capable of destroying virtually all forest regeneration."

Pennsylvania's state forests, DiBerardinis said, are in danger of losing their certification as sustainably managed woodlands. The independent certification provides Pennsylvania timber with a market advantage because some buyers prefer lumber from certified forests. Pennsylvania's is the only state forest system in the nation to achieve the certified rating.

As remedies, DiBerardinis asked commissioners to continue with concurrent seasons and higher allocations of antlerless licenses, but to make the Deer Management Assistance Program (DMAP) more convenient for landowners.

Advertise with us

"Our immediate goal is to fully utilize DMAP, and I hope to have half of all State Forest land in the program by next year's hunting season," he said. "However, we are finding the administration of this program by our own personnel is very staff intensive, and we need to explore ways to make it work more efficiently."

DMAP, DiBerardinis said, would be more effective if landowners, including DCNR, could give multiple DMAP permits to an individual hunter, instead of one per hunter as the rules now require.

DiBerardinis also called for "more radical tools beyond the DMAP reforms." But he disavowed any plans to introduce mountain lions and wolves.

"While the recent press coverage around these large predators undoubtedly caused a stir in the outdoor community, I will clearly state, as I did in my recent letter to Representative Godshall on this issue, that DCNR is neither advocating, nor do we have under consideration, the reintroduction of cougars or wolves to bring the deer herd under control," he testified.

Instead, DiBerardinis recommended an extended rifle season for antlerless deer and asked that biologists from DCNR and the Game Commission work together to formulate a recommendation for the extended season before the Commission's January meeting.

Advertise with us

Finally, DiBerardinis said he was lifting the moratorium on grants for game lands acquisitions. "With the moratorium behind us, I hope that we can again be full partners in the business of land conservation for the benefit of all Pennsylvanians."

Game Commission executive director Vern Ross later said the commission welcomed the lifting of the moratorium. "We were pleased to hear what Secretary DiBerardinis had to say. His announcement about lifting the moratorium was, I believe, the product of ongoing discussions between the Secretary and Commission President Russ Schleiden and other Board members," Ross said. "Those discussions fostered a better understanding for the Secretary about just how far the Game Commission has moved toward addressing DCNR's concerns about the deer population, as well as a better understanding by the Board about the ongoing challenges that DCNR faces."

In Western Pennsylvania the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy has conveyed thousands of acres to the state game lands system for public hunting and wildlife habitat. Western Pennsylvania Conservancy executive vice-president Cynthia Carrow said the moratorium did not affect any land acquisition projects the Conservancy had currently underway.

"Western Pennsylvania Conservancy has had a long partnership with both agencies in achieving mutual conservation goals and we look forward to continuing to partner in land projects in the future," Carrow said. "We are encouraged by the collaborative spirit of DCNR and the Game Commission to make progress on the problem of over abundant deer. Reduction of current deer densities is crucial to the stewardship of both public and private lands in the Commonwealth."