Salmon are sharing the spotlight on Lake Erie steelhead streams, giving anglers a final shot at catching a coho -- a species that is no longer being stocked -- and a chance at a rare pink salmon.

Jim Grassi of Masontown landed a near-state record pink salmon Sept. 11, when he caught a 4-pound, 7-ounce specimen above the Manchester Hole on Walnut Creek, fishing a white sucker spawn fly for steelhead.

"I didn't even know what it was until I saw its black tongue," said Grassi, who waited a few hours before taking it to be weighed at Poor Richard's Bait Shop. "I wish I'd gotten it there right away."

Since then, shop owner Gary Heubel has seen a couple of dozen pinks, mostly 2 pounders, from Walnut Creek. Ray Travis at Lake Erie Ultimate Angler weighed a customer's 4-pound pink salmon landed earlier this month at the mouth of one of the east side tributaries.

Advertise with us

Known as "humpies" for the odd-looking mass of muscle and fat on their backs, pinks spawn every two years, said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Roger Kenyon. They are not native to the Great Lakes and got into Lake Superior 50 years ago when a Pacific Northwest stock en route to a James Bay hatchery accidentally was dumped into the lake.

Since then, they have reproduced in limited numbers somewhere in Lake Erie, said Kenyon. They make their spawning runs earlier than steelhead because they tolerate warmer water.

The pink salmon's bigger and better fighting cousin, the coho salmon, has begun entering Erie streams. If there are thousands of fish scattered in Walnut, about 20 percent are coho, Heubel said. They average 6 pounds and look like steelhead, except for their dark or black tongues. A steelhead's tongue is white.

Coho run every year, peaking in October and dying off by December. What makes this year exceptional is that it is the last for coho. The Fish and Boat Commission ended its lengthy stocking program in the spring of 2003 with a final release of 69,000 smolt.

In the past, Kenyon has cited problems with Pacific Northwest coho stock, indicating it fails to thrive on Lake Erie's alewive and smelt forage and does better in its native saltwater environment. Heubel believes the bigger reason is that coho provide less "bang for the buck" than steelhead, a distantly related salmonid that return every year and have the potential to spawn several times. Salmon spawn once and die.

Advertise with us

"They felt it was poor returns and there was the question of cost," said Heubel, who is active in 3CU, the group that first stocked steelhead 30 years ago, when coho were the big draw. "I think that's a bunch of bull."

Steelhead guide and author John Nagy agrees.

"It was a mistake to terminate the cohos," he said. "They're tremendous fighters and catching one adds variety to your fishing. They don't put chinooks in Erie anymore and I think that was a mistake, too. Maybe 3CU should consider stocking cohos?"

The state record coho is 15 pounds, 5 ounces and was caught in Lake Erie. Last fall, William Hudec of Johnstown landed two coho -- a 10-pound, 2-ouncer and a 9-pound, 10-ouncer -- fly fishing Walnut Creek on different days. Walnut Creek also yielded a 9-pound, 12-ounce coho to George Hluhan of Pittsburgh last November. They were among the largest cohos reported to the Fish and Boat Commission last year.

"Pink salmon take flies well. They're not fighters. But cohos are tremendous fighters. They're exciting to catch," said Nagy, who includes salmon patterns in his book "Steelhead Guide: Fly Fishing Techniques and Strategies for Lake Erie Steelhead," though the same flies and lures that catch steelhead work fine on salmon, too. "In the 1970s, they used to talk about coho fever, then steelhead came along. The pool on Walnut above Route 5 is still called the Coho Pool. It would be just black with cohos."

Advertise with us

On rare occasions, a chinook (king) salmon also wanders into Erie streams. Fazle Buljubasic of Erie, who holds the state brown trout record, landed a 16-pound, 8-ounce chinook on a salmon egg in Cascade Creek in October 2001. It was the only chinook reported to the Fish and Boat Commission that year.

The state record chinook is 28 pounds, 15 ounces. The Fish and Boat Commission hasn't stocked chinooks in 10 years, said Kenyon, and New York's last stocking was in 1997.

"This species needed deep water and a lot of it to prosper, more than Lake Erie could provide," he said. "They were destined to be a big part of a trophy fishery because of their prodigious growth, but they never measured up. Smelt apparently could not provide the energy for the species' anticipated growth, and the longevity of five years or more required to attain trophy sizes could not be reached."

Some chinook have reproduced and are occasionally caught in eastern Lake Erie, said Kenyon. "Either these are chance recoveries of local isolated spawning or stray migrants from the upper lakes."