If "anticipation is half the fun" applies to deer hunting, Pennsylvania's 900,000 deer hunters are in for an enjoyable season. Gary Alt, supervisor of the Pennsylvania Game Commission's Deer Management Section, says research done over the past three years shows that controversial antler restrictions are working and that hunters can anticipate encountering more mature whitetail bucks with larger antlers this fall.

Speaking at the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy's members' day event at Bear Run Nature Reserve in Fayette County on Sept. 11, Alt said, "There is now no question that antler restrictions are doing what we designed them to do. We are nearing completion of the largest study of antlered buck survival ever conducted and our results show that more bucks are surviving the hunting seasons to reach more advanced age. The vast majority of those bucks that have lived to two-and-a-half years and older will have at least 8 points this season, and in good habitat they will have racks with 18-inch spreads or better."

Known to Game Commission biologists as "The Buck Study," the research Alt described involved the capture of 2,016 deer in Armstrong and Centre counties. Among those deer were 550 bucks that were fitted with radio transmitter collars or electronic ear tags, 260 of which are still "on air," broadcasting their movements and location to biologists with tracking equipment.

Bucks with collars or ear tags are fair game

Advertise with us

Biologists remind hunters in Armstrong and Centre counties that bucks (if they carry the minimum number of points) wearing radio collars or ear tags are legal game, and can be taken as any other legal deer.

"It's perfectly legal to shoot these bucks," Chris Rosenberry said. "Hunting season mortality is part of the study."

Rosenberry pointed out, however, that it is critically important for hunters to report the kill by calling the toll-free number on the tag or collar.

"There is no reason they should feel reluctant to call," said Gary Alt, supervisor of the Pennsylvania Game Commission's Deer Management Section.

-- By Ben Moyer

Advertise with us

"This study is awesome in its scope," Alt said. "Prior to this research, the largest published study involved around 75 animals. We're talking hundreds of bucks now from two different areas."

The Game Commission, Penn State University and Audubon Pennsylvania were partners in funding the research. Antler restrictions and increased harvests of female deer are twin components of a plan to establish a healthier deer herd and restored forest habitats.

Alt explained that the large study sample of bucks enabled researchers to gauge the rate of buck survival through the hunting seasons since the implementation of antler restrictions in 2001.

Contacted by phone, Game Commission wildlife biometrician Chris Rosenberry elaborated.

"We're seeing a huge spike in the number of adult bucks that survived the hunting season," he said. "In the past, less than 10 percent of the bucks in the harvest were adult bucks. But last winter about a third of the bucks we captured were adults. That is a good indication that there are now more adult bucks around after the hunting season than there were in the past [before antler restrictions].

Advertise with us

"There were a couple of nights we caught three or four adult bucks under one net. We never caught that many adults at one time before."

Objectives of the study were to determine the survival rate of bucks, study buck movement and dispersal, monitor changes in the age structure of bucks in the population, and evaluate hunter satisfaction with antler restrictions.

To capture deer, the research teams used nets propelled by solid-fuel rockets, drop nets, and "clover traps." Rosenberry said most deer were baited to the trap sites with corn placed during periods of deep snow.

Before antler restrictions 80-90 percent of the annual buck kill consisted of 18-month-old bucks wearing their first set of antlers. Whitetail bucks are known to grow larger racks each year as their age increases, with peak rack development occurring between ages 4 and 8.

Antler restrictions now protect bucks with less than three points to a side in most of the state, including the Centre County study area. A 4-point minimum is in place in Western Pennsylvania, including Armstrong County, where better habitat encourages larger antler development at younger ages, even among yearlings.

Advertise with us

"One of our goals was to protect somewhere between 50 percent and 75 percent of yearling bucks," Rosenberry said. "It appears we are now getting about 50 percent survival through the hunting season, which means we are hitting pretty close to that goal."

Penn State wildlife graduate student Eric Long did much of the field capture work. "Handling more than 2,000 deer over three years provided a great opportunity to view the impact of antler restrictions," Long wrote in a recent report. "The percent of adult bucks [more than 1 year of age] captured increased substantially over the course of this study. This field experience suggests that following implementation of antler restrictions, considerably more adult bucks are surviving the hunting seasons."

The study is also shedding new light on some myths and misconceptions about deer and deer hunters. One concern expressed vehemently by those opposed to antler restrictions was that hunters would disregard the rules and kill protected bucks anyway, leaving the deer in the woods to decay. But Alt told the Conservancy gathering that fear was unfounded.

"I feel very encouraged by hunters' behavior," Alt said. "The critics said hunters would ignore the restrictions but when you check the data from our study it does not document such bad behavior. They [hunters] are passing on the young bucks in both study areas, which suggests the same is happening statewide."

Rosenberry agrees. "Illegal shooting during the season does not appear to be impacting what we're trying to do," he said.

Advertise with us

Opponents of antler restrictions also claimed bucks passed up by hunters would die of other causes before the next season.

"That's the other encouraging thing about our data," Rosenberry said. "Our marked deer have proved that nine out of 10 bucks that survive the hunting season make it to the next hunting season alive. We're losing a few to road kills and one fell over the highwall of a strip mine in Armstrong County, but contrary to popular belief, chances are good that if we do get them through one hunting season, they'll be around for the next."

Data from the study also challenges the widely held belief that deer are scarce on public lands. The Centre County study area includes parcels of state game lands and state forests, as well as private lands.

"About half of the Centre County bucks spent time on public land," Long wrote. "All bucks in both areas were exposed to hunting pressure."

Rosenberry cited some insight into deer hunting that nobody expected.

Advertise with us

"We are finding it difficult to get a look at these deer this summer even though we know where they are from the transmitters," he said. "They are proving very difficult to observe to see the antlers."

Which is why they call it hunting.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.