On Labor Day last year, Bob Hornstrom of Meadville caught one of the biggest smallmouth he has known Conneaut Lake to produce in the past 50 years.

"There were torrential rains and we were the only idiots out here," he said. "We were live bait fishing for smallies, but I had a Husky Jerk rigged up for white bass. We were drifting across this hump, coming off the other side, when my buddy saw something break the surface. I thought it was a white bass, when all of a sudden this thing comes out of the water, three, four times.

"My buddy goes, 'Oh, my God,' and when I saw how big it was, I grabbed the rod and nailed it."

At a whopping 7 pounds, 11 ounces and 24 1/2 inches long, it outweighed last year's five biggest bass in the state, which were all caught in Lake Erie.

Advertise with us

Hornstrom is no stranger to trophy fish. In November 2002, he caught the state record white bass, a 3-pound, 15.7-ouncer, on a Kastmaster spoon on the same hump that yielded the previous state record.

Conneaut Lake has produced the four state-record white bass and Hornstrom believes his catch will soon be eclipsed.

At 925 acres, Conneaut Lake isn't large, but it is the largest natural inland lake in Pennsylvania. It is spring fed with no major tributaries to muddy the water and, owing to its glacial origins, has the sort of rocky humps and dropoffs that harbor big numbers of big fish, including a state-record muskie of 54 pounds, 3 ounces that remains unbroken after 75 years.

"I've fished this lake all my life and I'm still finding new places, that's how much structure there is," Hornstrom said.

Last Monday, we boated 2-pound white bass along with nice size crappie, spooning in 30 feet of water near the floating docks on the lake's east shore, where expensive new houses are springing up. That wasn't where Hornstrom caught his record-breaker, but it is one of the lake's more productive spots.

Advertise with us

Unfortunately, the docks there are privately owned, as is most of the lake shore, leaving just Fireman's Beach and the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission's west side launch for public access, and neither is good for shore angling. But the lake is open to boats of all horsepower, which gives fishermen plenty of options. And though jet-ski traffic may turn off some anglers, Hornstrom fishes all summer.

"The water skiers don't bother my fishing," he said, "because they don't bother the fish."

The biggest white bass come in fall, as the previous three state records verify. And all three came on some of the hard-bottomed, mid-lake humps that give Conneaut its abundance of structure. But the floating dock area with its 25- to 35-foot depths also draws fish to the kind of spooning that pays off for Hornstrom.

"This spoon does injured minnies better than injured minnies," he said. "Anything that takes a minnie will take this. Just drop it over the side 'till it hits bottom and give it a twitch, a quick little snap of the wrist. They'll take it on the upstroke."

Hornstrom replaces the spoon's treble hooks with bigger (size 4 or 6), sharper ones and seldom goes lighter than eight-pound (clear blue Stren) test when targeting white bass. He doesn't vary his jigging presentation much, even as water gets colder.

Advertise with us

Once the lake turns over, white bass go deep. He has caught them in November in 45 feet. The lake is 72 feet in its deepest spot. "They'll school up in deep water in fall and they tend to school by size," said Hornstrom who also tied the previous state record the same day he broke it and boated several of more than 3 pounds as well. "We were in the right place at the right time."

He will start targeting big white bass in another month. Right now, he's catching huge bluegill on ice ants tipped with maggots, and bass on flukes.

"I've been getting a lot of nice smallies on bluegill rigs, too," said Hornstrom, who had barely spoken those words Monday when a tackle-busting smallmouth came out of the water and proved it. "These cloudy days are just what smallies like."

Hornstrom brought the fish to boat in under five minutes by back-reeling when the fish put on pressure, and working his electric motor. "There's no way I'd have gotten him [on 4-pound test] with drag. Back-reeling let's you equalize the pressure. I just back reel and up, back reel and up, until I feel him slacking off." The fish weighed 4 1/2 pounds.

White base are a true (tmperate) bass and not related to the smallmouth or largemouth bass, which are types of sunfish, like bluegill.

Advertise with us

Conneaut Lake sunfish have remarkable color, owning to the cold, clear water. The lake also abounds with pike, as angler targeting bass in the weedlines can attest, plus crappie and muskie. And though walleye are few, Hornstrom has pulled seven-plus pounders from the lake.

"There aren't many but they're nice when you get them," he said.