Ronald M. Overdahl, Associated Press

A thin tag is attached by a researcher to a perch, giving a location and fish identification number, after being caught on Lake Michigan. Perch have become more abundant in Lake Erie in recent years.

Click photo for larger image.

Lake Erie's newest native superstar, the yellow perch, might spawn a business not seen since the days of the long-gone blue pike.

Advertise with us

Gary Heubel of Poor Richard's Bait and Tackle has purchased a 52-foot Erie-built steel Pausche, constructed in 1954 at about the time the blue pike, a walleye subspecies, was being fished to extinction. He plans to launch it in the spring as a 44-person party boat, running $28-a-person trips with tackle rentals and fish cleaning services. It will join the Victory, a day boat schoolteacher Rick Walsh began operating this year.

"I've been meaning to do this for three years," said Heubel, who is using the boat at night to net minnows for his shops. "That's how spectacular the perch fishing is and probably will be for 10 more years."

The boon began in 1996 when 20,000 perch were harvested and has been building ever since, according to Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Roger Kenyon. He added that last year's perch harvest topped 414,000.

"We've had a superior class about every other year, including last year. It creates a surplus of fish, a reserve, so, even if fishing keeps increasing and eight- to 10-year old animals disappear, there are still more fish out there."

That isn't to say that a sequence of poor year classes wouldn't raise red flags said Kenyon, who recalled that walleye, now subject to tighter creel limits because of declining numbers, had folks lining up for "six-pack charters" in the 1980s.

Advertise with us

"Controlling the harvest is all the leverage we have, but I'd say perch fishing looks rosy."

A cousin to the walleye, "perch are ideally suited to the lake," said Kenyon, though certain natural factors influence the hatch. It starts with a large brood fish population whose fry are helped along when spring rains or good winter runoff flush nutrients into the lake.

"That makes the plankton the young fish feed on, bloom. When fish go from a planktonic to a bottom stage, the critters of the mud need to be there for them. Mayfly larvae, for example, are perfect," Kenyon said.

Steadily increasing temperatures also are critical, since sudden changes, such as an influx of cold water, can be deadly.

"Once they get through the first year, perch do great," Kenyon said.

Advertise with us

Juveniles and adults are opportunistic enough that they can find food anywhere, top to bottom, and survive subtle and obvious changes in their environment to live for up to 10 years. Kenyon said, "They're vigorous survivalists. If the food web is perforated by gobies, they'll eat gobies. They can convert both plankton and fish to flesh. They're perfectly adaptable, not just in Lake Erie but in many Northeast waters, like Oneida Lake in New York and the Finger Lakes."

Some observers say the Fish and Boat Commission's ban on gill-netting -- putting all but one for-profit fisherman, who turned to trap nets, out of business -- is a factor in the perch explosion. But Kenyon called it minimal and though Ontario's commercial perch industry remains "a major force," he said, "it won't have an immediate effect on populations here. Perch aren't big roamers like walleye, though we don't know how much egg and fry make it to Pennsylvania from Canada. The real reason for today's perch are the perch."

It takes about two years for perch to reach the eight-inch minimum creel size, implemented in 1997 in an effort to grow larger fish. Those spawned then are today's jumbos. Poor Richard's weighed one last year that was three ounces shy of the 2-pound, 9-ounce state record.

The daily per angler limit is 20, but fishermen have gotten so spoiled by the quality of today's perch, a new problem is surfacing, said Heubel.

"There are so many fish, guys are throwing back nine and 10 inchers, figuring they'll just wait for the jumbos," he said. "And if they're out there fishing for five, six hours, they know they'll get their fill of 13- and 14-inch fish. In the meantime, they've wasted how many perfectly good 10 inch perch?"

Advertise with us

Fish brought up from deep water are likely to suffer the bends, an often-fatal decompression sickness. Perch are typically caught in 55 to 65 feet of water in summer and 35 to 45 feet in fall and in spring.

"The law should be changed about what you can throw back," said Heubel, who serves on the board of Save Our Native Species of Lake Erie. "People have to be educated or a species could go the way of the blue pike."

Angler ethics aside, differences between the species and better management make that very unlikely, said Kenyon.

For one thing, perch are everywhere and blue pike were endemic to the lake's eastern end, so, once that spot was "fished out," they never came back.

"People in the 1940s managing the resources didn't realize that," Kenyon said. "The other factor was smelts, an introduced species that appeared in the 1930s and had quite an impact on lake herring, white fish and blue pike."

Advertise with us

Still, rapid changes in Lake Erie, especially the invasion of exotic species, like the zebra mussel, have bologists "on the edge of our seats," said Kenyon. "I call the past 30 years the era of apprehension."

At present, though, perch are in their heyday. Where they once peaked in late summer and early fall, the great bite is beginning earlier than ever, even during the spring spawn, and lasting longer.

"It's almost a year-round fishery," Heubel said.

Aside from their appeal as table fare, yellow perch are relatively easy and inexpensive to catch. Unlike trying to catch walleye, there's no trolling or down-rigging involved.

"Just drift a minnow," said Heubel. "Some folks like emerald shiners but fathead minnows work just as well."

Advertise with us

Even "bucket anglers" who have no boat can reap the harvest, as perch move through the channel to the bay in fall. And perch provide steady ice-fishing action in the bay during the winter.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.