The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission bowed to pressure from fishermen last week when its executive board voted 8-0 to defeat proposal to allow bait angling on delayed harvest artificial lures only (DHALO) streams.
It was the most controversial piece of business on the quarterly meeting agenda, Action also was taken on a number of other items, including termination of the Selective Harvest and All Tackle Selective Harvest programs and re-designation of nine of the 10 streams currently under those programs.
The handful of bait anglers who comprise the Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania had pushed for new rules on the state's 57 DHALO waters, but the board received just 31 letters supporting a change and 1,167 letters opposing it. Delayed harvest artificial lures only is the most popular trout-fishing program in the state.
"The board made the right move," said Joe Pugach, Trout Unlimited's southwestern regional vice president. "We're talking about a small number of total trout stream miles. Half of them are on private property and the landowners would have shut them down if they were opened to bait. Even the state has statistics showing bait anglers leave more garbage on streams than anyone."
Delayed harvest artificial lures only allows for harvesting of trout from mid-June to Labor Day, when the cold-water species' mortality is highest. That was one of Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania's arguments in pushing its agenda. But many streams are spring-fed, giving trout refuge in warm weather, and cool, rainy summers such as this one enhance holdover prospects.
"These are fish for fun areas, not meat fishing areas. TU has put a lot of money into DHALO streams. That's what irks me about the bait guys. Where were they when we were spending half a million dollars on Buffalo Creek?" asked Pugach
The board expanded DHALO by two streams -- a 1.75 mile section of Honey Creek in Mifflin County, partly within the Bald Eagle State Forest, and a 2.5 mile section of Powell Creek in Dauphin County -- effective Jan. 1, 2005.
In ending the Selective Harvest and All Tackle Selective Harvest programs as of Jan. 1, the Fish and Boat Commission is getting rid of regulations that were only marginally effective, said fisheries management director Dick Snyder. The program, allowing for the taking of 14 inch or larger fish during the regular trout season, was most successful on Saucon Creek in Northampton County and Codorus Creek in York County. Those waters will be moved to the Trophy Trout program.
Others streams and creeks have been re-designated catch and release. But the board tabled action on Young Woman's Creek, which is caught in an anglers' tug of war. The Western Clinton County Sportsmen's Association is pushing the Fish and Boat Commission to stock Young Woman's Creek, a move Trout Unlimited opposes.
"It's an excellent wild trout stream," said Ken Undercoffer, Trout Unlimited's Pennsylvania secretary. "I was just up there and caught many wild brown trout up to a foot and brookies over 10 inches. Stocking would ruin the fishery."
The Fish and Boat Commission recently removed Young Woman's Creek's Class A wild trout status. Undercoffer said re-designating it to catch and release would restore it to that class. If the board doesn't act by January, the stream will fall under general regulations.
Comments may be sent to ra-pfbcregs@state.pa.us.
Douglass Oster, Post-Gazette
Fly fishermen in Neshannock Creek on the opening day of trout fishing season.
Click photo for larger image.
Related articles:
Paddlefish study project lands grant for $42,000
Fishing Notebook: Snakeheads discovered in state waters
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.