It was a catch most anglers only dream about.
Mark Smith of Jefferson landed not two huge flathead catfish on the Monongahela River in West Elizabeth on July 10. The catches were made just 300 yards apart.
"It was a crazy night," said Smith, who pulled a 40-pound catfish from the moonlit waters and then a 35 pounder, both on creek chubs he and his daughter, Alyssa, 6, had caught earlier that day in Peters Creek.
He was fishing with Stan Jasinski of Pleasant Hills, who landed a 41 pounder last year and a 42 pounder eight years ago that put him within 1 pound, 9 ounces of the state record set on the Allegheny River in 1985.
"When you get one that big, you know there's something even bigger lurking in those waters," said Danny Plants of Shad Lure Bait and Tackle, a Monongahela River institution.
Local legend has it that a West Elizabeth family used to catch flatheads in the Allegheny River and put them into the Mon all through the 1970s, seeding some of today's eye-popping specimens at the same time that water quality was beginning to improve.
"The record will be broken, maybe next year, maybe tomorrow," Plants said. "You got a lot more people fishing for them."
"We're like a little cult," said Mike Purcell of the North Hills, with a laugh. He has pulled monstrous flatheads from the midnight waters of the Allegheny on the North Shore, under the Fort Duquesne Bridge. "You have to fish a certain way for big catfish. You have to pick good locations and fish at night. You have to use certain bait." And you won't catch them on a bass rod and 12-pound test line, said Rich Whiteside of Franklin Park and Purcell's partner in the summer-long Chester Newell Ohio River catfish tournament.
"Those fish know the river bottom a lot better than you do, Whiteside said. "They'll take you around snags and everything else down there. If you don't have heavy tackle, you might catch them but you'll never get them to the boat."
While huge flatheads are native to Western Pennsylvania rivers, which are part of the Mississippi watershed, they have enjoyed a resurgence in the last quarter century as a direct result of cleaner water, said the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission warm-water biologist Bob Lorantas. Though he lives in Bellefonte, he grew up tight-lining for catfish in Elizabeth. "In the 1960s and early '70s, we fished for channel cats because flatheads on the Mon were unheard of."
Some anglers still target channel cats -- the next largest river catfish -- almost exclusively.
Shawn Balaschak of Whitehall landed the largest channel cat of 2003, a 21-pound, 32-inch specimen, while fishing in the Monongahela River off the South Side in October.
"I grew up in a steel mill town and that is what we fished for. Guys that come from industrial towns seem to stay loyal to catfishing. Even when I go to lakes, I still take a catfish rig to see if I can get any," said Balaschak, a father of three who fishes when he can make time and finds channel cats cooperative.
"They bite day or night, aren't finicky about bait and they're aggressive, just plain mean," he added. "People think you can only catch them on the bottom with stink baits. But they'll hit nearly any live bait, spinner baits, crank baits or jigs."
Channel cats are also indigenous to western Pennsylvania rivers, though they were stocked briefly in the 1970s and '80s. And while they are more pollution hardy than flatheads, better water has helped their numbers and size, too, especially in the Mon, the three rivers' biggest comeback story, said Lorantas.
Balaschak fishes for channel cats with a 6-foot-6 Zebco RT Big Cat series rod and reel and 20-pound test.
"Fishermen love to use the lightest tackle they can find, but they'll never land a big fish out of the river with light tackle. I have caught many a big channel cat with hooks attached to broken line stuck in its mouth," he said.
While channel cats are omnivorous and opportunistic, eating insects, crayfish and whatever comes their way, flatheads are almost totally piscivorous (fish-eating) and predatory.
Both species are scale-less and locate food through the many taste buds, or sensory cells, on their skin and barbels, said Lorantas. The absence of scales also makes it difficult to age flatheads, he said, though they grow to about 15 inches in eight years. That makes the 44-incher Smith landed more than 20 years old, Lorantas said.
And for those who believe catfish can live out of water for hours, Lorantas has this to say. "It's true that flatheads are tolerant to lower oxygen levels, but there's a limit to everything. It's a good idea to take care of those fish much as you would any other. A fish out of water is a fish that's stressed."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.