Area fisherman Gary Richard of Zelienople shows off the 50-inch muskie he landed from the Allegheny River north of Kittanning.
Click photo for larger image.
Related article:
Fishing Notebook: Good news; licenses up over a year ago
It seemed like a fluke, the spate of muskie catches in the urban pool of the Allegheny River the past couple of months.
Five good-sized muskie were landed in a six-week period from the Highland Park Dam to the mouth of Pine Creek, and then two -- including a 25-pounder -- were caught in the Lock Three Bait and Tackle tournament out of Cheswick two weekends ago. The latter caused shop owner and contest organizer Lee Murray to create a new category. "That's a first for the contest," said Murray. "We've never had a muskie brought in before."
The freshwater king has been stocked in the Allegheny, Monongahela and Ohio rivers for at least 30 years. But the bigger numbers reported this year on the Allegheny are an indication that increased muskie stockings on the Allegheny plus cleaner water are now paying off, said Bob Lorantas, the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission warm water unit leader.
Since 1995, average annual stockings of muskie and tiger muskie -- the pike-muskie hybrid -- have gone from 10,600 to 12,800 in the four pools of the Allegheny from Sharpsburg to Clinton. "The increase in stockings is modest, but it has a cumulative effect. And a lot depends on Mother Nature cooperating," he said.
These stockings parallel numbers planted in the Monongahela (about 9,000 a year) and the Ohio (8,000). There is unrestricted movement of most species, including muskie, through the three rivers pool that reaches from Braddock on the Mon to Emsworth on the Ohio to the Highland Park Dam.
All fingerlings come from the hatchery at Linesville and survival expectations are factored into the numbers, said PAFBC biologist Rick Lorson. Just 10 percent of planted muskie are expected to reach adulthood, with mortality rates diminishing each year. "Initially just 50 percent will survive," said Lorson. "Then it's 25 percent, then 10 percent."
Muskie are spring spawners, and while there is some evidence that muskie reproduce in the wild in the upper reaches of the Allegheny, Lorantas said there is no data suggesting that the same holds true in the three rivers pool, though samplings so far have been limited.
Plantings alternate true muskie with tigers in the same pools each year. And while there is a good bit of variation even among true muskie -- they can be unmarked, spotted or barred -- there are ways the average angler can tell a muskie from a tiger muskie and a tiger from a pike, he said. Tiger muskie are typically shorter than true muskie and have vivid bar-like markings on their sides. Even true muskie with bar-like markings won't be as intensely patterned. Pike are dark with lighter bean-like spots that tend to be horizontally arranged. Like pike, tigers have rounded tail fins, while true muskie has sharp-tipped tail fins. True muskie, tigers and pike also can be distinguished by the number of pores on the underside of the lower jaw, said Lorantas. True muskie have six to 10 pores on one side, while tigers have five to seven, and pike, four to five.
"We're seeing a few more each year of both the muskie and the tiger muskie," said Sam Stellitano of Memories Tackle in Sharpsburg, who reported a 42-incher released at Highland Park and a 39-incher from the mouth of Pine Creek in one week this spring. "If there were muskie fishermen down here actually targeting them, there [would] probably be even more."
Stellitano said he spotted a 60-inch specimen while fishing early one morning three years ago between the 13th Street docks and the barges downstream. "The head alone on this fish was 15, 16 inches," he said. "I've walked the shore area from Highland Park to Pine Creek in the early morning and you can see muskie in the weed edges. The mouth of Pine Creek has always been good."
"We thought there was habitat and a good food supply with the suckers, shad, quillback and juvenile carp," said Lorson of the decision to step up stockings. "We gave it a lot of thought and we wouldn't have done it if we had concerns that it would negatively impact the walleye, smallmouth or sauger populations -- they're the big three. But there's so much forage available. There was this niche and we decided to do it for the angler recreation value."
His target is to average 14,000 plantings a year.
Muskie guide Howard Wagner, a big proponent of river-angling for muskie, said he gets reports at his Fombell tackle shop about anglers losing muskie on walleye tackle at Highland Park. "There's plenty of rough fish in that area, catfish and carp and chubs and suckers, to keep muskie well-fed," he said.
When trolling close to the dam, said Wagner, look for upstream current areas and you'll find big predators.
"Muskie also will lay at the edge of the river channel and wait for prey that comes along on the current flowing overhead. Make S passes up and down the river channel lip," he said. "Go up one side and down the other. They will suspend three to five feet below the edge of the old river channel on the inside turns looking up for unsuspecting prey swimming by overhead. I prefer the 8- to 10-inch solid black minnow trolling baits because the color silhouettes against the sky. Combined with the large mass of the bait, it makes an easy target for the large muskies."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.