As one of Scrooge's business associates says in Dickens' A Christmas Carol: "Done and done." It's official. Gaming is coming to Pennsylvania. Governor Rendell signed legislation this past week that will legalize slot machines at horse tracks and a select few sites.
Regardless of how hunters feel about gambling in the state, its arrival presents a dilemma that cannot be avoided. To hunters the word "game" means hunted wildlife, revered species like deer, bear, turkeys and grouse. But to most people "game" and "gaming" refer to gambling and that word association will grow stronger in the years ahead as gaming assumes household-word status through advertising and news. As "game" becomes increasingly linked to state-sanctioned gambling in the public mind, the identity and effectiveness of Pennsylvania's state wildlife agency, the Game Commission, will be compromised. For the benefit of wildlife, hunting, and hunters, it is time to give serious thought to changing the Game Commission's name to Wildlife Commission.
Within a year we will have an agency called the Pennsylvania Gaming Board that will administer slot machine gambling in the state. Even today, 109 years after its establishment, there are large numbers of Pennsylvanians who do not recognize that the Pennsylvania Game Commission deals with wildlife and hunting. As the new Gaming Board grows in prominence, confusion about the role of the Game Commission will fester and spread. The two names are just too similar for the good of the Game Commission, especially when there is a perfectly appealing and appropriate alternative in Wildlife.
The confusion poses no small problem. The Game Commission acknowledges that its mission and programs are poorly understood beyond its core constituency of hunters. Research firms contracting with the Commission have advised the agency to work harder at marketing itself among urban populations, minorities, non-hunters, school children and other groups that don't readily come in contact with its work. And the Commission has tried to implement those recommendations. Through video productions, a public television show, billboards along urban highways and programs presented in schools, more people have a reason to equate the Game Commission with wild birds, mammals and their habitats. Unfortunately, that progress will be jeopardized when the public begins to constantly hear and read about game and gaming in the context of gambling.
Any marketing professional will agree that a clear message and easily recognized identity are critical to success. The title "Game Commission" no longer achieves those objectives.
Wildlife Commission is a title that would clearly describe the agency's mandated role of managing or protecting all wildlife, not just those species pursued by hunters. Wildlife is a word that is instantly recognized by everyone, it has a positive connotation, and it takes advantage of the wide support among all segments of society for conserving open space and endangered habitats. Even now, before gambling, the title Game Commission speaks clearly to less than 10 percent of the state's population. Wildlife Commission would speak clearly and instantly to everyone.
Such a change has been proposed before but has always been trumped by the irrational fear that it would turn the agency against its hunting base. But funding from hunters' license dollars, the hunting-friendly stipulations attached to federal Pittman-Robertson funds, and the powers of commissioners would remain unaltered. Only the name would change, plus an improved public perception of what the agency actually does. Most other states call their wildlife agency what it is -- a wildlife agency, yet hunting continues just as it does in Pennsylvania.
Hunting and hunters are more misunderstood in American society than ever before. As misunderstanding about hunting spreads, so does the potential for the restriction of hunters' privileges. How can the Game Commission possibly convey a positive image about hunting, hunters, wildlife and conservation, when most of the state's citizens will confuse it with gambling, whose image is undeniably shadowy and negative? We all face a tough uphill fight to keep hunting a respected part of mainstream modern life. Having it regulated by an agency whose name is coincidentally linked to gambling will only hurt that effort.
The image of hunting is in decline and wildlife habitats are endangered everywhere by competing uses of land and water. It is time to acknowledge that hunting cannot be isolated from society, that our wildlife agency serves all Pennsylvanians and that it is entrusted with responsibility for all wildlife. Our agency needs a new name that will not handicap it at the very time it needs to be recognized for the fine work it does.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.