Like the mail that has been flooding in to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission against a proposal to allow bait fishing on delayed harvest artificials only waters, testimony at Wednesday's hearing in Monroeville was overwhelmingly in favor of keeping the status quo.
"If it ain't broke why even talk about fixing it," said Adam Lynch, an all-tackle angler who opposes bait fishing on delayed harvest artificials only streams.
The Fish and Boat Commission is exploring the proposal at the behest of a four-year-old bait-angling advocacy group, the Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania, whose only representative to testify was Al Chislo of Tarentum.
So far, the Fish and Boat Commission has received 1,056 letters and e-mails, all but 30 of which strongly oppose allowing bait fishing on articifials only waters, said executive director Doug Austen, who attended the hearing with his key biologists and board chairman Sam Concilla of Erie. The board is expected to vote on the proposal in July.
Several anglers, some representing Trout Unlimited chapters in Western Pennsylvania, testified that fishing bait on delayed harvest artificials only streams would deplete resources, increase litter and postings, and lead to further changes -- issues also identified by the Fish and Boat Commission. Postings, often done by landowners disgusted with litter, have become a crisis on streams nationwide.
In Pennsylvania, 75 percent of stocked trout streams are on private land that owners could post at any time. There are 56 delayed harvest artificials only streams and 27 delayed harvest fly fishing only streams -- just two percent of total trout waters in the state -- as part of a program the Fish and Boat Commission implemented 20 years ago.
"It's our most successful program in terms of trips generated and sustained catch rates," said Rick Hoopes, director of the Fish and Boat Commission's bureau of fisheries. Parts of the Little Juniata in Blair County and Lycoming Creek in Lycoming County were made delayed harvest artificials only this year, and "two more are in the hopper for next year," he said. That prompted anglers Wednesday to question why any changes are being considered at all.
"It seems to me that catch and release and bait fishing are a contradiction in terms," said Lynch, who has been fishing for 64 years.
Mortality is higher among bait-fished trout since they tend to get more deeply hooked, according to the Fish and Boat Commission, and bait anglers are more likely to creel their catch.
Though the proposal would allow for harvesting only during summer months, when higher water temperatures can make trout survival marginal, Trout Unlimited southwest regional vice president Joe Pugach pointed out that that isn't always the case.
"About fish going belly up in summer?" he asked. "There's enough cold [spring] water coming in to some streams they do hold over trout and they're fun to fish."
When flow is good, streams can sustain trout and remain fishable into fall. But Pugach and others focused more on the time and money that rout Unlimited chapters have invested statewide in improving habitat, something bait anglers simply don't do, he said. "It's like wanting to come to a party and eat the food but not have to cook it."
Jerry Potochac of the Trout Unlimited Arrowhead chapter reminded the Fish and Boat Commission of what it would stand to lose by changing a popular program. "TU does a [heck of a] lot of work on streams and one of the reasons we do it is because of delayed harvest," said Potochac, whose group has adopted Buffalo Creek in Armstrong County, making habitat improvements and stocking fish there. "We have $500,000 tied up in that stream. I was a bait fisherman most of my life and I don't see bait fishermen doing these things."
"We've been carrying the water of the commission for as long as it's been around," said David Gallagher of the same Trout Unlimited chapter. "We've taught hundreds and hundreds of kids to fish. We're adding to the license holders of tomorrow."
Allowing bait, he said, "will lead to more private fishing streams and lakes because there will be no fish in the fall. They'll all be yanked and bagged." He read an e-mail from a West Virginia man who said he hasn't bought a license in his own state in five years because he prefers Pennsylvania's delayed harvest artificials only waters. That shot down the Fish and Boat Commission's reference to relaxed regulations in other states, including West Virginia.
Chislo, before the hearing, called delayed harvest artificial only anglers "elitists, snobs," and, in his testimony, accused the Fish and Boat Commission of "setting aside country club streams" for them. "If you want [to fish] private areas," he said, "buy your own property and don't feed off the system."
But privatization is exactly what delayed harvest artificials only anglers say they are trying to avoid by keeping bait off special regulations streams.
"Even losing an inch of public access on any stream is too much," said Concilla, who has made it clear he opposes any delayed harvest artificials only changes. "It's imperative we instigate programs so we don't."
Comments can be sent to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission until June 13 by e-mailing pfbcregs@state.pa.us or writing to Executive Director, PAFBC, PO Box 67000, Harrisburg, Pa., 17106-7000.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.