Almost as this year's spring gobbler season commenced, the Pennsylvania House of Representatives passed HB 2042 by a vote of 186-1. If subsequently approved by the Senate and signed by Gov. Edward Rendell, HB 2042 would establish a "special wild turkey license" and authorize the Pennsylvania Game Commission to sell the special license to hunters who wish to continue to hunt turkeys after they have killed a bird and used the conventional tag attached to the regular "back tag" license.

Pennsylvania hunters can take one turkey of either sex in the fall season and one bearded gobbler in the spring. The legislation does not specify how many special licenses could be sold, in what part of the state they would be valid or the sex of the additional legal bird. Nor should it. Wildlife biologists, who know the resource best, should work out those details.

The bill does set some daunting fees. It enables the Game Commission to collect $20 from each resident (the same price as the general hunting license with privileges to hunt deer, turkey and small game) who wants to continue hunting after killing a first turkey, and $40 from non-residents.

"I want to offer my thanks to Rep. Phillips for introducing this measure and to all the members who voted in favor of it," Game Commission executive director Vern Ross said.

Advertise with us

The wild turkey, through the work of the Game Commission and the local chapters of the National Wild Turkey Federation, has recovered impressively in Pennsylvania in recent years. There is certainly a consensus in the state that the flocks can withstand more hunting pressure. And many hunters would welcome the additional recreation. But in regard to this legislation, hunters can legitimately ask their state senators: Why should the General Assembly grant a financial windfall to an agency for doing what it was supposed to do in the first place?

Goal No. 1 of the Game Commission's own strategic plan is: "To manage and improve wildlife populations for consumptive and non-consumptive recreational use and their many public values." Mostly through trapping birds from established flocks and releasing them in suitable habitat, the Commission has helped the wild turkey reclaim its original status in Pennsylvania's forests. In essence, the Game Commission has simply done what it said it would do for the resource and for the public, and now the legislature wants to give it a bonus for doing so.

The Commission has the authority to raise or lower bag limits. It does it all the time. It could, within its existing authority, permit hunters to take a second turkey. Or, to accommodate hunter preference, it could set up a "hunter's choice" scenario permitting either two gobblers in spring, or a gobbler and a hen in the fall. The Commission can do a lot of things under its current mandate -- it just can't charge a fee for the second tag unless the Legislature and the Governor sanction it in law.

A special fee, even a $20 fee, would be understandable if it were earmarked in some way for turkey management, but it is not. A Game Commission news release announcing the approval of HB 2042 in the House said revenue from the special license "could" be used to implement and fund the Game Commission's turkey management plan and further educate turkey hunters, but the bill doesn't require that. As written, HB 2042 would allow the Commission to use the special turkey fee for anything it wished.

There is ample need for a dedicated wild turkey fund. Turkey hunter education alone merits an earmarked allocation if the Commission is to get new revenue from a special license. Turkey hunting still accounts for more accidents per 100,000 hunters than any other form of hunting. The Commission's general hunter education program has significantly cut the accident rate for deer, small game and waterfowl hunting in the past 30 years. An intensified turkey hunting safety program, funded by the special license, could reduce turkey accidents in similar fashion. But there is no such provision in HB 2042.

Advertise with us

That's an injustice to the thousands of dedicated turkey hunters and conservationists who have invested their time, sweat and money to restore the wild turkey in Pennsylvania. These people run fund-raiser banquets, plant trees, help buy game lands and work to make careless hunters aware of the need to hunt safe. HB 2042 asks precisely those people to pay even more to government for the resource they have helped restore. It would reward an agency for meeting its own standards and therefore is an example of why we have come to expect so little from government today.