Nabil K. Mark, Associated Press
Timrek Johnson of Virginia Beach, Va., fishes below a dam on Spring Creek outside of Bellefonte, Pa., in April 2003.
Click photo for larger image.
Fly anglers can thank the heavy rains of 2003 for some of the best hatches in decades on Pennsylvania streams.
"Incredible!" declared Glen McConnell of McConnell's Country Store and Fly Shop, and a guide on north-central Pennsylvania trout waters. "Pine Creek had the heaviest caddis hatch in 20 years. It looked like a snowstorm. And the mayfly hatch is exceeding expectations."
Locally, trout guide Dale Kotowski of Waynesburg reports the mayfly hatch on Laurel Hill Creek is "tremendous, prolific."
Dan Shields, a partner in Flyfisher's Paradise, also has been raving about the hatches this spring on streams around State College.
"The blue wing olive on Spring Creek was the best in memory, and there have been great tan caddis and cranes flies," said Shields, a former Sewickley resident who has lived in central Pennsylvania since 1974 when he graduated from Penn State University and went to work in the fly shop he now owns. "Others are coming off well, too. Penn's and Fishing Creek had good blue quill, hendrickson and grannom caddis hatches. The only problem is water has been high."
Last year's heavy rains set the stage for this spring by scouring streams of fine sediment, thus creating more room for immature aquatic insects to develop, said Greg Hoover, a Penn State entomologist and adviser to the Penn State Fly Fishing Club. His students reported a "remarkable" blue wing olive hatch on Spring Creek from late February until just a few weeks ago. The blue wing olive is an important one, with females producing two broods a year.
"If the number of females laying eggs is up, it could extend into the following season," Hoover said. "Living things go through population peaks and valleys. This happens to be a peak."
Renewed health of streams is a big factor. In the case of Pine Creek, limiting acid mine drainage on the Babbs Creek tributary has enhanced the entire watershed and helped generate more bugs. Spring Creek, one of the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission top three brown trout fisheries, has prevailed through a more complex history of assaults. Though it is rebounding from industrial pollution, thanks to the Clean Water Act and the efforts of conservationists, imminent threats remain storm water runoff and depletion of the water supply, both consequences of sprawl, said Shields.
Last year, Shields published a book, "Fly Fishing Pennsylvania's Spring Creek," so anglers who know the stream as a great place to catch trout will understand how precious it is.
"That it has taken 200 years of abuse and still remained at the top of the fish commission surveys makes it the most amazing fishery I've ever seen," he said. "For a stream to take that kind of pounding and still produce all those trout is really something."
Shields, who also wrote "Penn's Creek River Journal," chronicles the natural and angling history of Spring Creek, including the creation 70 years ago of the aptly named Fisherman's Paradise, the one-mile project water that "changed fly fishing forever," according to Shields. In the 1950s, the stretch of stream is said to have received 850 anglers a day.
He writes about how to fish Spring Creek, including habitat, tactics and hatches. But the book has an overriding focus.
"I have a conservation ax to grind and I hope I've ground it well," Shields said. "I wanted to get the stream story told. I wanted there to be some record of what Spring Creek is, so, if the day comes that someone says, 'What's that ditch down there,' people will know what a glorious stream it was. It won't happen in my lifetime, but 50, 60 years down the road, there's that potential."
What surprises readers, said Shields, is that Penn State University is historically one of the worst offenders of Spring Creek, beginning in 1956 when cyanide from a chemistry lab was dumped into the watershed, wiping out its food chain. "Huge numbers of wild and stocked trout were killed," he said, "and the grannom and green drake hatches have never returned."
In the 1980s, Shields took part in a five-year effort to replant those flies, by seining the stream for green drake nymphs and picking mature flies from bushes and trees. But the program failed because, by then, he said, industrial chemicals, effluent from state fish hatcheries and university-related development had taken their toll on water quality. Pollution was so bad that the stream, until four years ago, was catch and release not for sport fishing management purposes but as a precaution against consumption.
After that, it was changed to catch and release to protect the fishery. Brown trout natural reproduction remains high 25 years after a century of stockings were discontinued. And a 17-pound brown trout taken in 1946 remains the largest fish known to have been landed on the Paradise stretch.
What threatens Spring Creek today, said Shields, who lives on the stream's upper reaches, is non-point source pollution, namely storm water run-off and de-watering of the stream for human consumption. As a limestoner, Spring Creek has an abundant underground water table that keeps stream levels up even during dry periods. But that is changing as a consequence of sprawl.
"You've got more development sucking the water out of the ground. And as more ground gets paved, less water is available for ground water recharge," he said. "If they don't keep that in check or find solutions, parts of the stream could die."
Shields' hope is that anglers who fish the stream will work to ensure its future.
"You talk to old timers who remember when the bugs were so thick they couldn't see to the other side. Trains were stopped because of the bugs coming off Spring Creek," he said, and, though it's unlikely those days will return, this year's abundance of bugs is a heartening sign.
The sulphur mayfly hatch is the biggest one on Spring Creek through June. The blue wing olive will hatch again in August. If you're heading to Spring Creek or other streams, such as Penn's Creek, Bald Eagle Creek, Fishing Creek or the Little Juniata, you can contact Shields at 814-234-4189, or visit www.flyfishersparadise.com.
The Penn's Woods West Trout Unlimited is sponsoring a bus trip June 5 to Fisherman's Paradise on Spring Creek. The cost is $28 for members and non-members. For details, visit www.pwwtu.org.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.