Crossbows could be coming to a woodlot near you this October. When the Pennsylvania Game Commission meets at its Harrisburg headquarters at 8:30 a.m. tomorrow and Tuesday it will vote on final adoption of its proposal to liberalize the use of crossbows for deer hunting, a controversial issue that has pitted the Game Commissioners against groups of hunters.

Crossbows have been outlawed in Pennsylvania. In recent years, however, the Game Commission has permitted their use only during the regular firearms deer season. Physically handicapped hunters may use crossbows if a physician certifies they are incapable of drawing a conventional bow.

The proposal under consideration would permit crossbows to be used by any hunter during any firearm deer season and also during any deer season, including the regular archery season, in Wildlife Management Units 2B, 5C and 5D. Those units are the most densely urbanized regions in the state. Unit 2B includes nearly all of Allegheny County, plus neighboring sections of Butler, Beaver, Washington and Westmoreland counties.

If the proposal is approved, crossbows would be legal hunting tools for the first time during the state's traditional fall archery season, because one week of that season overlaps with the fall muzzleloader hunt.

Advertise with us

Many bowhunters have long opposed the use of crossbows during established archery seasons. Their opposition centers on their view that a crossbow is not a true bow because it can be mechanically cocked before a deer is sighted, making it unnecessary to draw the bow in the presence of game. They maintain that crossbows are more like a firearm in this regard, and that the use of a crossbow does not require as much commitment of time and practice to shoot effectively. These hunters say crossbows could attract a large number of participants who are not necessarily committed to ethical, responsible bowhunting.

Crossbow proponents, especially Game Commissioner Steve Mohr who has advocated more liberal crossbow regulations throughout his tenure on the commission, say crossbows are needed in the state's urbanized Wildlife Management Units to enable hunters to kill enough deer. Quoted in Pennsylvania Outdoor News, Mohr said, "They [bowhunters] want access for a few -- I want access for as many as I can get. I would rather have 10 hunters kill one deer, than one kill 10. Because then I still only have one satisfied hunter."

In the same article, Commissioner Greg Isabella was quoted as saying, "They need rules expanded to shoot more deer."

In a public statement at the January Commission meeting, Rep. David Levdanksy (Allegheny) expressed the opposing concern of many bowhunters. "I can tell you it takes five to 10 minutes to become confident with a crossbow," he said. "Is that what we want to encourage? Do we want to have more people, more guys who would rather be home watching football on a Saturday afternoon in October, who won't spend the time to develop the skill to kill a deer with a bow?"

The United Bowhunters of Pennsylvania, a consistent supporter of the Game Commission's recent deer management initiatives, has expressed concern for the biological impact of the proposed change. The organization's members fear that the availability of crossbows to thousands of sportsmen who have never been motivated to hunt with archery equipment could sharply increase the number of bucks taken in October before the autumn rut.

Advertise with us

"The UBP opposes the use of crossbows in any archery season except by truly disabled hunters," said UBP spokesperson Ed Wentzler. "It is our contention that the impacts this device will have on both the social and the biological aspects of wildlife management have not been fully evaluated by either the agency staff or the board of commissioners."

No major hunting or sportsmen's organizations in the state have gone on record in support of expanded crossbow hunting, and a survey of hunter opinion conducted for the Commission by Responsive Management, a search firm specializing in resource management issues, found that 52 percent of Pennsylvania hunters opposed the use of crossbows during archery season.

Elk will likely continue as a hot topic as well. The Game Commission will also vote on final approval of an early elk hunting season. Commissioners proposed in January to allocate a limited number of elk tags for a September season to be in effect only in the vicinity of agricultural areas around St. Mary's in Elk County. Farmers in that area often kill elk legally when they destroy crops or farm property. Sources close to the Governor's Sportsman Advisory Council, however, said that the early hunt could conflict with Gov. Ed Rendell's administration's plans to make elk a key feature of increased tourism promotion for north central Pennsylvania.

The Game Commission office is at 2001 Elmerton Ave. in Harrisburg.