HARRISBURG -- Growling bear-like, state Sen. Gerald LaValle yesterday accused officials from the Pennsylvania Game Commission of trying to submarine a proposed merger of the hunting agency and the state Fish and Boat Commission by spreading rumors about the consolidation.

Game commission representatives have been attending sportsmen's club meetings in LaValle's Beaver County district, the senator claimed, telling hunters and anglers that the state wants to fold the fishing and hunting enforcement agencies into another department so it can sell excess game land to casino investors.

"That's your people that are doing that," LaValle said. The "bizarre comments" make their way back to his office, LaValle said, and ultimately he and his staff have to snuff any rumors.

LaValle made the charges at a Budget and Finance Committee meeting, during which the possible merger was debated.

Advertise with us

Mike Schmit, deputy executive director of the game commission, said he doubted seriously that his employees would conduct such a misinformation campaign. Douglas Austen, the new director of the fish and boat commission, suggested that passions among sportsmen and agency employees are running high because "these issues are very dear to a lot of folks."

The accusations, accurate or not, underscored just how intense the political battle figures to be when and if a merger of the two agencies is ever put to a legislative vote. The agencies themselves, while acknowledging that a merger is technically feasible, wish to maintain their autonomy.

They worry that creating a new enforcement agency under the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources would give greater authority to the Legislature, and remove decision-making powers from the hunters, anglers and conservation officers.

The new report, issued yesterday, arose out of two House resolutions directing the Legislature to explore different merger approaches.

This latest merger investigation prompts questions of perhaps greater concern for sportsmen: Can the spiraling cost of managing hatcheries, game land and conservation enforcement continue to be paid for by the declining number of hunters and anglers?

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania is the last state in the country using separate agencies to regulate fishing and hunting, and over the years, merger recommendations haven't been well received. As early as 1942 and as recently as 1989, the Legislature has investigated combining the two agencies. Each time, the merger queries have been dropped after sportsmen flexed their collective political muscle.

Folding the hunting and fishing agencies, as well as conservation deputies, into one law group -- perhaps to be called the Bureau of Conservation Law Enforcement -- would create an agency with a first-year budget of $33.8 million, according to the new study. That's nearly $6 million more than what it now costs to enforce game, fish, boating and conservation regulations.

The initial enforcement expense would be higher, but the cost to Pennsylvania's hunters, anglers and boaters would in theory be reduced, because the expense of the new agency would be primarily borne by the state's general fund. Now, the agencies are financed mainly through hunting and fishing license fees.

That $17.4 million carrot -- $10.1 million in potential game commission savings and $7.3 million for fish and boat -- could be spent on new education and outreach programs. But that's not enough for Schmit, who told the legislative panel a merger is "the wrong direction to go."

State Rep. David Levdansky, a Democrat from Forward, chastised the game and fish commission officials for backward thinking. The agencies are "mired in the same old track of no change -- not today, not tomorrow, not ever," he said.

Advertise with us

Rep. Robert Godshall, D-Montgomery, has received hundreds of notes from hunters who oppose the merger. He claims he still hasn't made up his mind on the issue, but yesterday said the current, three-headed enforcement approach was "inherently inefficient," citing the report.

The report also calculated other methods of raising revenue for the fish and game agencies, including a tax on hunting and fishing equipment, similar to sales tax now in place in Virginia. A tax on equipment could raise $9 million a year initially, according to John Rowe, who guided the committee report.