Location, location, location...

Though the 20-pound, 10-ounce steelhead Bob Schoeller of Erie landed Wednesday is big enough to beat the existing state record, it may not qualify because it was caught on posted property, which makes it ineligible under Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission rules. However, Schoeller is hoping he found a loophole in the fact that anglers are sometimes permitted to fish where he made his big catch.

"There's some question about how publicly accessible that particular property is," said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission waterways conservation officer Brook Tolbert, who patrols Erie and saw Schoeller's trophy. "It'll be up to Harrisburg."

Schoeller landed the huge male with 21 1/4- inch girth and 35 1/4- inch length on a #12 triple hook Irish style salmon fly, at 12:30 p.m. on an undisclosed Lake Erie tributary he had been given permission to fish, he said. By the time he had it weighed an hour or so later at Poor Richard's Bait and Tackle, it was seven ounces over the state record steelie -- a 20-pound, 3-ounce male taken on Walnut Creek by Corey Brown of Osterburg, Pa, two years ago.

Advertise with us

"It's the biggest fish I ever caught on a fly rod," Schoeller said, "and I'm satisfied with that. I think a record should be a record no matter where it's caught. But the rules are the rules and I'll live with them."

Schoeller said the creek was high and muddy when he started fishing at 6 a,m. but had cleared some by noon, when he moved into his favorite spot. "I cast into a riffle and immediately something hit," he said. "It swam into a deeper pool but I knew I had a big one on. When it came to the surface and rolled, then I saw how big it was. I got excited, nervous.

"I had good tackle," he said, of the 11 pound (1X) fluorocarbon Frog Hair leader -- made by the Pittsburgh-based Gamma Technologies' Frog Hair Fishing Products -- he was using.

A "slugging match" ensued, he said, though it wasn't much of a fight and was finished in 10 minutes. "The big ones aren't spectacular fighters. They're the linebackers of the fish world. The little ones are much better fighters," he said.

The fish is being mounted and will hang in his nephew's tackle shop, the Lake Erie Ultimate Angler, Schoeller said.