According to figures released last week by the Pennsylvania Game Commission, deer hunters found plenty of whitetails last season throughout the state, despite dire predictions from some who claim the deer herd has been decimated by recent changes in hunting regulations.

Game Commission tallies, constructed from report cards mailed by successful hunters and random checks of butcher shops to determine the reporting rate, indicate that last season produced the fourth-highest deer kill in state history. It was also the second-highest take of antlerless deer.

Statewide, the Game Commission says hunters took 464,890 deer, including 322,620 antlerless and 142,270 antlered bucks during the sequence of seasons that began with archery hunting in early October and ran through the late archery and flintlock seasons in January.

Interestingly, the buck kill was 61,000 fewer than in 2001, the last year without antler restrictions. Commission deer biologist Gary Alt had predicted that antler restrictions would allow about 70,000 young bucks to survive the hunting seasons, growing larger antlers and competing to breed does the following fall.

Advertise with us

Antler restrictions were in place in Allegheny County for the first time in 2003. Restrictions were tightened over a large area of southwestern Pennsylvania from a 3-point minimum to 4 points, likely depressing the buck kill in the region.

The distribution of the deer kill throughout the season also confirmed some of Alt's observations. Report cards and butcher shop checks proved that a smaller percentage of deer were shot on opening day of the rifle season than in past years. Alt had predicted that high winds on that day would affect hunting success.

"What we saw when we broke down the rifle season deer harvest by day was a dramatic decline on opening day and the first Saturday -- down more than 20 percent from last year," Alt said. "However, the deer harvest during the second week--when weather conditions improved--was more than 20 percent higher."

"Given the challenges hunters faced from poor weather to spotty food sources they were able to fill their tags and move the overall deer program toward its goal of balancing the deer herd with its habitat and saving more bucks. Pennsylvania's deer management program is on the right track."

One statistic that is not so positive is the continuing high percentage of first-year "button" bucks killed as antlerless deer before they are old enough to grow antlers. More than 68,000 (about 21 percent) of the 322,620 antlerless deer shot by hunters were button bucks, despite an effort by Alt and the Commission's deer management section staff to help hunters learn to distinguish young deer from adult females. Button bucks are legal antlerless deer but biologists believe that letting them grow to maturity will further improve the deer herd by establishing a more natural sex ratio in the population.

Advertise with us

Historically, button bucks have accounted for 20-25 percent of the antlerless kill. Commission biologists had hoped that hunters would kill fewer button bucks during the two-week concurrent season, because they had more time to pick out a mature doe.

Bow hunters killed slightly fewer deer in 2003. The 2003-04 archery kill was 65,100 (30,880 bucks and 34,220 antlerless), compared to the 2002-03 archery take of 69,648 (33,476 bucks and 36,172 antlerless).

"The most notable change in the archery season was that bow hunters were taking more antlerless deer later in the season than in previous years," Alt said.

"Also, there was a decline in the archery buck harvest that can be attributed to the fact that hunters were required to adhere to new antler restrictions for the first time in special regulation areas, where archery hunters take their greatest number of deer, and an enlargement of the four-point area in the western part of the state."

The muzzleloader deer kill continued to increase, likely due to the growing popularity of the relatively new fall muzzleloader season for antlerless deer. Muzzleloader hunters killed 35,660 deer in 2003-04, a jump of more than 4,000 from the previous year.

Advertise with us

"Muzzleloader hunters really seem to be enjoying the opportunity to hunt for deer when the weather is warmer," Alt said. "And in so doing, they really have been helping with the deer program by harvesting antlerless deer earlier in the fall."

When pushing for the fall muzzleloader season several years ago, Alt explained that an earlier harvest of antlerless deer would save forage in the woods that surviving deer would need during the winter and would encourage more competition between bucks for breeding by removing does from the population before the November rut.