If there's a silver lining to the hard winter we've experienced, it's spring steelheading on Erie County streams.

"As soon as you get a lake shore thaw, warmer water and longer days, that triggers the spawn," said steelhead author and guide John Nagy of Brookline, whose revised and expanded "Steelhead Guide: Fly Fishing Techniques and Strategies for Lake Erie Steelhead" was published last fall.

"Once the ice is gone, especially at the mouths of the creeks, fresh fish can finally run into the tribs."

While some steelhead spawn in fall, the majority spawn in late winter or early spring. A mild winter encourages early spawning activity and periodic runs out of Lake Erie, but a harsh winter delays the spawn and the migration.

Advertise with us

March can be an interesting month, Nagy said, with its mixture of wintered-over pre-spawners, fresh-run pre-spawners, spawning fish and post-spawn (drop-down) steelhead. And there are different strains. Pennsylvania steelies are a mostly fall- and winter-run hodgepodge some anglers call "mutts," while Ohio streams yield the late winter- early spring-run Little Manistees.

Pre-spawning fish seek deep holding areas with current breaks and less light penetration, said Nagy. In water below 40 degrees, the classic winter dead-drift technique prevails. Because steelhead are lethargic in frigid temperatures, precise placement of the fly is required.

Derived from Pacific Northwest stock, Lake Erie steelhead are genetically programmed for rivers hundreds of miles long, which means, at least theoretically, they can stay in a stream for up to eight months without feeding, Nagy said. "You've got to drop the fly on their nose, which means fooling around adjusting your tippet and split shot. They like small flies -- nymphs and egg patterns -- and smaller presentations. Winter steelhead are easy to find, hard to catch."

Ninety percent of fish are in 10 percent of the water, Nagy said. "You've got to read the surface texture of the water which is a reflection of the bottom. You'll be able to determine where the current breaks are and thus where the steelhead are located."

Around January, bait anglers start using Lake Erie emerald shiners, an indication fly anglers should tie on a shiner pattern, too.

Advertise with us

When days grow longer and water warms above 40 degrees, steelhead go into spawning mode, seeking gravelly beds where the hens will dig a succession of redds and deposit eggs as they move upstream. Males will fight to fertilize redds and then guard them.

"You want to target the males, which will take a fly out of aggression," Nagy said. "If you catch the female, the males will scatter. If fish have been spooked, you can find them in the deeper holes adjacent to the spawning riffles."

The males are almost black, much darker than the females, and have a kipe, or hooked lower jaw. Those with the biggest kipes often dominate the spawning beds.

In his book, Nagy suggests an effective technique: Get directly above a redd and swing your streamer, such as a Brown Trout or a Frankie Shiner, back and forth. If the water is low, keep a low profile.

"Don't let your fly drop down into the redd," he said. "You're trying to swing it in front of their noses until they get agitated and strike out of aggression. Be patient. You might not think it will work, but it's deadly."

Advertise with us

After the spawn, the steelheads' metabolism changes again and they become ravenous. When active, steelhead can be fished by swinging flies downstream, a big-water technique ideally suited to Ohio's Conneaut and Grande rivers. It can work on Elk Creek in Pennsylvania, too, in late spring and early fall, though Pennsylvania tributaries are better for short-line nymphing presentations, such as bottom-bouncing or the right-angle floating indicator technique.

Nagy starts his spring steelheading in Pennsylvania then switches to Ohio in late March and early April.

"That's the peak run, when you get chrome fish, silver fish, a purer strain than Pennsylvania's mutts," he said. "In PA, the fish have been through the wars. They're beat up from the ice and snow, the high water and low water, the gauntlet of fishermen.

"Ohio's window of opportunity is smaller, but the fish are in better shape because they haven't wintered over. They're also bigger and stronger and at least a third to double the size of Pennsylvania steelhead."

Larger Pennsylvania fish are in the 8- to 12-pound range while larger Ohio fish are 10 to 15 pounds.

Because steelhead are a stocked fish in Pennsylvania and Ohio, where the percentage of returning fish is extremely low and the fishery relies on smolt stockings, Nagy said, the ethics of targeting spawning beds is not as much an issue as in Ontario, where 95 percent of the fish are wild or the Cattaraugus, where 30 percent are wild. In those areas, some of the tributaries are closed to protect spawning beds.