Stop in for a cyber-visit at the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources Web site and you may see a puzzling thing. Puzzling, that is, if you are from Pennsylvania and interested in hunting and fishing.
A banner proclaims "Top News Stories," above a revolving window highlighting upcoming events outdoors in the Mountain State. Watch the window for a few seconds and you'll learn about an upcoming celebration of bats and a fete called "Wildlife Diversity Day." A subsequent mouse click lets you in on the fact that on Wildlife Diversity Day the state capital lobby will be inhabited by DNR staffers alerting lawmakers, clerks and tourists to the importance of songbirds, snakes, wildflowers, butterflies, trout, deer and other species to life in West Virginia. At the revolving window you can also register for a "Becoming an Outdoors Woman" program, which introduces women to hunting, shooting, fishing and outdoor skills. You can also read about Gov. Bob Wise's Youth Wild Turkey and Bass Challenge, an essay contest for West Virginia youngsters.
If it hasn't yet struck you as to why this should all be puzzling -- it's this. West Virginia's hunting, fishing, non-game wildlife, state parks and outdoor education programs are all administered by one agency -- the Division of Natural Resources. West Virginia has the kind of setup that some in Pennsylvania claim would ruin hunting and fishing if established here.
Pennsylvania is the only state in the nation with separate agencies for fishing and hunting. The Fish and Boat Commission oversees fishing, boating, reptiles and amphibians. The Game Commission manages hunting, mammals and birds. Furthermore, state parks and state forests are managed by the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources. Each has its own law enforcement, educational programs, publications, regional offices and executive staff.
Claims that a more integrated structure would place low priority on hunting and fishing erupted soon after the Pennsylvania Legislature passed House Resolution 15 a year ago. HR 15 authorized a study of various alternatives for restructuring Pennsylvania's system of resource administration. The state's largest sportsmen's organization testified at a public hearing that HR 15 was "a dog that won't hunt." The Fish and Boat Commission told its readers in Pennsylvania Angler that "anglers and boaters deserve the best we have to offer. They will get less under the combined fish, wildlife and boating agency ..." Game Commission executive director Vern Ross wrote that merged agencies "would lead to a loss of essential services."
Legislators supporting the HR 15 study (199-1 vote) said it might be possible to find a new way of combining agencies to reduce duplication and provide more integrated management.
Opponents of HR 15 and any consolidation of agencies say that hunting and fishing would be overwhelmed by "non-game" wildlife and "non-consumptive" outdoor recreation. But these claims are not substantiated by the situation in West Virginia.
For its hunters, West Virginia maintains 26 shooting ranges, administers a system of wildlife management areas for hunting, shooting and wild life habitat, and runs mandatory check stations during deer season -- a program many Pennsylvania hunters have wanted for years. Sunday hunting is allowed in 14 counties where the issue has been approved by popular referendum.
DNR offers West Virginia fishermen a year-round trout season and stocks over 1 million trout annually in more than 200 streams and lakes. The state also has widespread public fishing opportunities for bass, walleye, muskie and sunfish.
Simultaneously, West Virginia is widely known as a destination for hikers, birdwatchers and whitewater boaters.
"When you have a limited resource and competitive users there is always potential for conflict," DNR director Ed Hamrick said. "But we work very well together in the agency to manage all that and cooperation is critical when you manage the state's natural resources."
The educational opportunities in DNR's state parks illustrate a philosophy that apparently has not infringed on Mountain State hunting and fishing. Parks list special lodging rates for hiking weekends and winter bird festivals while also tailoring packages for spring trout fishing and a program called "The School of the Longhunter." Later this year, parks will offer children's fishing clinics, The North American Bird Migration Count and West Virginia's celebration of National Hunting and Fishing Day.
The DNR also airs a television show, "West Virginia Wildlife." The show promotes wildlife not pursued by sportsmen while also giving non-hunters credible information about the positive side of hunting and fishing. "We place a great emphasis on the outreach programs," Hamrick said. "From becoming an outdoors woman, to field dressing a deer, fly fishing, bird watching and backpacking."
DNR's environmental resources section administers grants to local conservation groups for litter control, habitat improvement, cleaning streams and planting trees. Over 100,000 volunteers, including 70,000 youth in 800 organizations, take part.
Some Pennsylvania sportsmen fear that a consolidated resource agency would use hunting and fishing license dollars for other projects, but Hamrick said his agency was set up to protect those activities. "Our license dollars are dedicated by law and by the constitution of West Virginia to be used for hunting, fishing and wildlife conservation," Hamrick said. "We also have a conservation stamp purchased with every hunting or fishing license. We use those funds to acquire lands for hunting and fishing and for boating access sites."
Hamrick said the DNR does receive some general fund appropriations, a controversial topic in Pennsylvania. "Our general fund appropriation is used primarily for the state parks and for our law enforcement force," he explained.
"In West Virginia, our conservation officers not only enforce the fish and game laws but they carry on both hunter education and boating safety education, as well as enforce laws relating to littering, forestry, state parks, environmental/solid waste, pleasure boating and whitewater rafting. Here officers have full police powers and assist the state police.
Hunters and anglers in West Virginia are apparently unaware that their traditions are threatened by a consolidated resource agency. According to Elmo Wiles, president of the West Virginia Bowhunters Association, "The DNR serves hunters and fishermen very well. They are always looking out for the sportsman's best interest. I don't always agree with every detail, but you have that in any form of government. As a whole, they do a fantastic job."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.