The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission is asking trout anglers for their thoughts on a proposal as controversial as antler restrictions are for deer hunters.

Commissioners are getting mail, calls and e-mail on the matter, and they plan to schedule a round of public hearings sometime in the next six weeks. The Commission wants to know what trout enthusiasts think about a proposal to open Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only stream sections to bait fishing during the summer period, from mid-June to Labor Day, when trout may be creeled on these waters.

The proposal is being raised at the urging of the Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania, an organization that claims special regulations discriminate against bait anglers. Fine, but anglers and landowners of stream side property have told the Commission what they think of the DHALO program. They like it the way it is.

In 1991, the Commission contracted with the University of Pittsburgh Center for Social and Urban Research for a scientific telephone survey of trout fishermen. Researchers spoke with nearly 2,000 trout anglers in the state, asking a battery of questions to determine their attitudes and preferences in trout fishing. More than two-thirds (70 percent) indicated they wanted more delayed harvest projects established in the state. Surveyors described the rules of delayed harvest projects as they stood in 1991 to any angler who was not familiar with the program. So, respondents understood that the rules for delayed harvest projects did not allow bait.

Advertise with us

If anything, support for DHALO and DHFFO (fly-fishing) projects is even stronger than in 1991. That includes stream side landowners. At the October 2002 meeting of the Fish and Boat Commission, commissioners established three DHALO projects on Fishing Creek in Columbia County, Middle Creek in Snyder County and Bermudian Creek in Adams County. In all three cases. landowners either requested the DHALO designation or supported it when approached. Can any anglers -- bait, lure or fly -- expect to fish these streams again when the landowners post their property after the rules are changed and the stream banks are littered with bait containers, hook packs and fish entrails? Will the loss of those streams to everyone be worth the short-lived, new opportunities for those who refused to adapt their fishing technique to the original DHALO regulations?

Rick Hoopes, the Commission's Fisheries Bureau Director told commissioners that "by Mid-June, all-tackle [bait] activity on these areas should not be profound because many anglers are less inclined to go trout angling." That a surprisingly imprecise assessment of the impact on a highly popular and important program.

Contrary to Hoope's assurance, the Pitt survey revealed that anglers take more total trout fishing trips during the summer months than during the peak weeks of spring. Fishing activity is more intense in April and May, but the total number of outings is greater during the summer, exactly when trout can be creeled on DHALO projects. Surveyed anglers also told the researchers they would travel farther to fish delayed harvest streams than "regular" streams.

For those DHALO stream sections known to harbor wild, naturally reproducing trout, a rule change allowing bait would increase fishing pressure and certainly the mortality to the wild trout resource.

Contrary to TAP's claim, special regulations on trout streams discriminate against no one. DHALO streams account for less than 2 percent of stocked stream miles (90 miles out of 4,800) and every trout angler in the state has access to DHALO waters. No individuals are excluded or discriminated against. Only the types of angling methods are regulated to achieve and maintain a certain quality of fishing experience for all.

Advertise with us

The delayed harvest program is widely popular as it is. It allows any angler to fish in the absence of crowds, year-round, over reasonable numbers of trout. And judging from the support anglers gave the program in 1991, it is probably responsible for keeping thousands of Pennsylvania anglers within the license-buying ranks.

Changing the rules now is unnecessary and unwise, and there is far more to be lost than gained. Trout anglers who agree should contact the Commission soon and provide the public comment the agency is asking for ... again.

Write to the Commission at Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, P.O. Box 67000, Harrisburg, Pa., 17106, or call 717-705-7800. Or send an e-mail throught he PFBC Web site at www.fish.state.pa.us.