This week's Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission meeting is mostly about trout. Commissioners will decide whether to include the Camp Run watershed in Westmoreland County in its Wild Brook Trout Enhancement Program, which allows fishing year-round, with no tackle restrictions, but forbids the creeling of brook trout, Pennsylvania's only native salmonid.

Commissioners will also make their initial consideration of a proposal to allow bait to be used during the permissible summer "harvest period" on streams designated "Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only." If the measure is approved there will be a public comment period before the Board considers final approval in the spring. Their decisions will affect the trout fishing satisfaction of thousands of anglers in Pennsylvania, and will likely be based heavily on comments from fishermen.

Important as these issues are, there are others that can affect trout and trout fishing even more fundamentally than fishing regulations. Among those is water quality. Our state has a big problem with water quality that drags down our economy, environment and our image across the nation. Fortunately, in a growing number of places, watershed groups, fishing organizations and local governments are making some progress in the quest for cleaner water, and that means better fishing.

An example of a stream with improved water quality is Dunbar Creek in Fayette County. Graduate students and faculty at California University of Pennsylvania recently surveyed trout anglers on Dunbar Creek to assess their fishing experience and satisfaction. Graduate student David Bojtos and professor Dr. William Kimmel wanted to know if trout fishing had changed as a result of recent efforts to treat acid mine drainage in Glade Run, part of the Dunbar Creek headwaters. The stream restoration effort is a project led by the Chestnut Ridge Chapter of Trout Unlimited, supported by cooperative efforts from the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, Pennsylvania Game Commission, DEP, Fayette Conservation District, Dunbar Sportsman Club and the Wharton Township supervisors.

Advertise with us

Bojtos and Kimmel surveyed anglers along the stream, distributed questionnaires at club meetings and at DeFrank's Fly Shop and Guide Service in Chalk Hill (724-439-5770), and through an Internet web site.

Fifty-four percent of survey respondents said the trout fishing on Dunbar Creek had improved the past five years. Fifty-five percent said they had observed improved insect hatches on the stream and 76 percent reported catching brook trout they believed were "natives" spawned, not stocked, in the gravel of Dunbar Creek. Fifty-eight percent said that rainbow trout fishing had improved, which is significant since rainbow trout are more vulnerable to stream acidification than brook trout.

Nearly half the anglers had been fishing Dunbar Creek for more than 10 years, so their observations are indicative of change. Sixty-three percent were aware of the ongoing efforts to restore the watershed.

Those responses suggest a significant improvement in a stream where, only a few years ago, spring trout stockings were postponed due to high acid loads from abandoned mines.

But respondents also identified social problems that continue to degrade the fishing experience on Dunbar Creek, and probably on many streams.

Advertise with us

"Disregard of fishing regulations and outlaws. Poaching and foul hooking. Trash dumpers. All-terrain vehicles in stream. People swimming," and "Beer parties" were among the most frequent responses. Problems such as those will persist without consistent and cooperative vigilance from the municipality, Fish and Boat Commission officers, local magistrates, the state police and anglers who care enough to report behavior that is against the rules.

Better trout fishing, and all the environmental and economic benefits it can bring to Pennsylvania, faces many challenges. Hopefully, under new leadership, the Fish and Boat Commission will not only strive to fit the most appropriate fishing regulations to each stream, but also renew its efforts for improved water quality and a better stream environment.