When temperatures plummet, sauger fishing on the Monongahela River peaks.

"The best month is February," said D. R. Plants of Shad Lure Bait and Tackle in West Elizabeth. "Below those power plants with all them little gizzard shad and hickory shad? It's some kind of vision. It's just tough on the fishermen 'cause it's cold!"

Except for the sort of bitter cold that has pounded the area lately, die-hards say, it's worth braving the elements for the only game in town during long drawn-out Western Pennsylvania winters and, with high waters last spring wiping out much of the shad spawn, sauger are seeking other forage. Like its cousin the walleye, sauger are stacked up in deeper water and preparing to migrate to their usual spawning sites below dams and at gravelly shorelines, said walleye pro Keith Eshbaugh of West Alexander. Males will generally come in a week or two ahead of females and linger after the spawn, when females are gone.

"They're waiting for new girlfriends," Eshbaugh said. "And they're so aggressive they'll strike anything you put in front of them."

Advertise with us

Schooling sauger often can be found for a mile below the dams, where they are drawn to structure and good oxygenation, and to the shoreline opposite locks.

"Dams and the mouths of creeks are your best bets," Eshbaugh said. "Good fishermen know to fish the mouths of the creeks at dusk because fish are coming out of the deep holes to feed."

The warm water discharge of power plants such as Elrama and the Irwin Works are hot spots because they draw the prey fish that sauger and other game species follow.

The classic cold-water presentation is a jig and a minnow, though jigging spoons and blade baits are other options. Drop a quarter-ounce jig with minnow over the side of the boat until it hits bottom. Stay vertical, Eshbaugh said. "Just keep your line straight up and down. I use fluorescent fire line with monofilament leader because you can see the line, you can see where it is."

A jig-tipped minnow can be drifted downstream to cover water and locate fish. It should be kept just off the bottom and drifted with the current, touching bottom every now and then to control depth. Don't let out too much line or you'll snag.

Advertise with us

Eshbaugh and other seasoned river fishermen such as guide Mark Feldman of Jefferson also troll in winter.

"Ninety-nine percent of people think it's crazy. They think you need live bait in front of you this time of year, but you don't," said Eshbaugh, who likes wobbly crankbaits such as the Berkely Firestick in white or chartreuse in the same size as a Little Ripper. "Go smaller in winter. Just creep upstream until you find the prime spots."

Feldman may troll to locate fish and then switch to jigging or he'll keep trolling if fish are active. He discovered years ago that the Reef Runner, a high-vibration minnow-type lure that works on river muskie, catches sauger, too. "Down here on the Mon, that's a dynamite lure," he said. "I'll catch fish when no one else can."

With those techniques, the likelihood of a catch is high. "Sauger aren't shy about biting," said Feldman. But the operative word is slow.

Feldman likes Point Marion on the Pennsylvania state line above the Cheat River and Dunkard Creek, although water quality improves farther upstream. Point Marion is the first of six dams on the Pennsylvania side of the Monongahela River, which starts in Fairmont, W. Va., and flows northward to meet the Ohio. The Braddock Dam is now being replaced and the next one upstream, at Elizabeth, will eventually be removed, creating 23 miles of free-flowing water but depriving fish of a major oxygenation point.

Advertise with us

"Commercial enterprise won out," said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson, who had argued against the project.

Though sauger, whose night vision is keener than that of walleye, prefer the Monongahela's turbid water (the legacy of poor land-use practices and mine drainage), they have expanded their range to the middle Allegheny River, just as more walleye are moving into the Monongahela.

While the sauger-walleye ratio on the Monongahela River was 90-to-9 (with one percent saugeye) in 1992, two years ago, it was 65-30, said Lorson, whose survey included a 29-inch walleye in the Monongahela's Pittsburgh pool.

"That's a good sign, because walleye are less tolerant of pollution," Lorson said. All of which speaks to the Clean Water Act of 30 years ago, which spurred the river's transformation. The irony is that new threats of mine drainage all along the Monongahela River may undo whatever progress has been made. All of which concerns anglers who value the revitalized fishery.

Sauger and walleye are among the first river species to spawn, usually when water is 45 degrees. The season closes from March 14 to May 1.

Sauger are the smaller of the two and don't have the walleye's dark spot at the corner of the first dorsal fin or its white-tipped tail. They also have darker, saddle-like blotches. The two species can cross breed in the wild, though numbers of naturally produced saugeye are small, Lorson said.