Should delayed harvest sections of trout streams now restricted to artificial lures and flies be opened to bait fishing?
That's one of the issues the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission board will consider at its first quarterly meeting Jan. 26-27 in Harrisburg. It won't vote on the proposal, which is being spearheaded by the Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania, a bait-angling advocacy group, but it will decide whether to seek public comment on the prospect and schedule a vote for later this year.
"If you're harvesting fish on lures, why not bait?," said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick. "Dead is dead whether you're using a worm or a lure or a fly. The social status stuff, the class wars aside, we think there's enough merit from a biology standpoint to consider this proposal."
Tredinnick acknowledged that the issue could be a hot potato and enumerated the concerns: that opening delayed harvest areas to bait fishing will generate increased pressure and litter on streams and could eventually lead to more liberal regulations beyond the summer months and into the rest of the year. As it stands, anglers using artificials can creel trout from mid-June to September, when trout are more likely to succumb to warm water.
Four years old, the Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania is lobbying for the removal of restrictions on all trout waters, said spokesman Al Chislo of Tarentum, who wanted fly fishing-only streams made part of the current proposal. After a similar idea -- to open fly fishing only delayed harvest waters to artificials -- triggered protests by property owners and fly anglers three years ago, the Fish and Boat Commission limited its proposed change to artificials only sections, which would involve 57 streams and a total of 92.3 miles. Even so, two-thirds of anglers on delayed harvest artificials only streams are fly fishermen. The streams carry both stocked and wild trout.
"I have no problem with people fishing bait at the proper time and under the proper conditions, but areas where trout could be wiped out easily is another matter," said Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited southwestern regional vice president Joe Pugach. "Fly fishing preserves trout. It doesn't destroy them."
Released trout caught on bait have a 20 percent mortality rate, which is five times greater than those released on lures and 10 times greater than those released on flies, said Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson.
But Chislo claims that the rights of bait fishermen, the majority of the state's fishermen, are being violated by special regulations of any kind and has threatened that Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania may sue the Fish and Boat Commission.
"They've given the best streams to the fly fishermen. Why are they any better than I am? We pay the same fees for licenses, so why do they get preferential treatment? Because they have a very powerful organization behind them ... Trout Unlimited," Chislo said.
"I told Harrisburg, 'You want to raise our license fees? We'll favor the increase when we get all tackle on all streams.' "
Pugach questioned the Fish and Boat Commission's motive for considering even a part of Traditional Anglers of Pennsylvania's request. "They think pandering to these guys is the way to sell more licenses," he said. "That's a big mistake. It'll just lead to more problems down the road. More litter, more postings. Look what happened on Yellow Creek."
"You can get into a class warfare kind of thing," said Tredinnick, who remembers Yellow Creek in Bedford County, too, and the brouhaha raised when artificials were being considered for fly fishing streams. Property owners threatened to post their land. "Some people equate tackle choice with certain behaviors and with social status."
"There's no question the litter left lying on streams is from bait fishermen," Pugach said. "Fly fishermen don't leave half their lunch behind. They don't leave all those little Styrofoam bait cups lying around."
According to the most recent Trout Anglers Telephone Survey, taken in 1991, 78 percent of Pennsylvania fishermen use bait, though not exclusively, while 38 percent fished with lures and 28 percent with fly rods. Though license sales are down five percent since then, according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Survey, fly fishing is off by just one percent in the same period.
Brook Trout expansion plan
The board will vote next week on whether the new Wild Brook Trout Enhancement program implemented on Kettle Creek in Potter County this month should be expanded next year to include Camp Run in Westmoreland County and seven other streams statewide.
The streams were chosen not just for their wild brook trout populations but because they are on public land and offer anglers excellent access. The Wild Brook Trout Enhancement Program also allows for bait fishing, although all fish caught must be released year-round.
The catch and release aspect of the program is intended to offset the higher mortality associated with bait fishing, said Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson, who expects that the majority of anglers will not be bait fishermen.
Since 1999, the 4.1-mile Camp Run has been a selective harvest all tackle stream, which means two nine-inch or larger brook trout can be kept a day, opening day through Labor Day. The Camp Run watershed is exclusively wild brook trout. Other streams on the Brook Trout Enhancement agenda are Birch Run and Lyman Run in Potter County, Minister Creek in Forest and Warren counties, Jeans Run in Carbon County, Kistler Run and Wolf Swamp Run in Monroe County and Shaeffer Run in Perry County.
Other items
The board will decide whether to seek public comment on:
Removing Sugar Lake in Crawford County from the Warmwater/Coolwater Species Special Conservation Waters program and adding it to the Big Bass program with restrictions on muskie (one per day, 36 inch minimum). The lake is where the Fish and Boat Commission gets brood stock for hatching tiger muskie. Sugar Lake is a 90-acre glacial lake off Route 173 near Lake Tamarack. It has a bountiful largemouth bass population in which five pounders are common, plenty of panfish, including crappie, bluegill, perch and muskie.
The board will vote on:
Removing Northmoreland Lake in Westmoreland County from the Warmwater/Coolwater Species Special Conservation Waters program and maintaining it as a Big Bass lake and a Panfish Enhancement lake.
Adding Upper Twin Lake in Westmoreland County to the Select Trout Stocked Lake program, so the 20-acre impoundment near Greensburg can be fished in March when other trout waters are closed. It is scheduled for March angling this year.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.