Pennsylvania Game Commission deer biologist Gary Alt delivered the following message to nearly 500 people assembled in Harrisburg last week for a conference entitled "The Challenge of Overabundant Deer in Pennsylvania; A Call for Partnerships."
"We've got to do something to get these oak forests jump-started for the next generation. Otherwise these forests will disappear and Pennsylvania will be grossly changed forever."
The conference was sponsored by Pennsylvania Audubon and more than 80 other conservation groups, hunting organizations, state agencies and private businesses.
After a day of presentations about the impact of abundant deer on forests, agriculture and highway safety, participants picked failed forest regeneration as the most critical problem caused by a deer herd out of control for nearly eight decades.
Numerous research studies using deer "exclosures" to protect small plots of woodland have shown that over-browsing by deer is the one most important factor in the failure of oak forests to produce viable seedlings. The Game Commission estimates the state's deer herd at approximately 1.5 million animals.
Agency biologists maintain that despite more liberal hunting regulations, the statewide population has not been substantially reduced during the past five years. The damage caused by overabundant deer goes beyond the state's forests. Pennsylvania's Secretary of Agriculture Dennis Wolf told the conference that deer damage costs agriculture in the state somewhere between $75 million and $90 million every year. The average cost per farmer he said is about $9,000.
Some farmers say that these losses are enough to force them to consider selling their land to developers. Wolf, who is also a deer hunter and a dairy farmer, said he knew about deer damage from personal experience.
"You know you've got a deer problem when you walk into a field and the first 15 rows have no corn," he said.
Wolf said he felt a more streamlined Deer Management Assistance Program would help farmers deal with the problem. Many farmers have expressed dissatisfaction with the Game Commission's current DMAP program, calling for a less cumbersome DMAP license application procedure, which would allow them to issue tags to hunters directly.
Penn Dot Deputy Secretary Gary Hoffman said that deer collisions on highways cost drivers, insurance companies and the state more than $140 million annually. According to Hoffman, documented human fatalities in deer collisions increased from two in 1999 to 12 in 2002, and that there are about 700 fatalities each year in which there is no known reason for why the vehicle left the roadway.
"Some of these may be caused by deer," he said.
High deer numbers have also destroyed communities of forest wildflowers and have thinned brushy cover used by birds and small mammals in many parts of the state.
"The white-tailed deer is an efficient herbivore and it can, has and will destroy its own habitat," Alt said. "If we don't solve this problem the population will crash and there will be nothing we can do until we fix the habitat."
Jerry Cecil of the Fox Chapel Environmental Advisory Council described how deer had decimated wildflowers along the borough's popular Trillium Trail.
"We first tried to trap them," Cecil said. "But nobody would take the deer." Cecil said the borough then developed a program to direct bow hunters to properties where residents wanted deer removed.
Game Commission supervisor of deer research, Marrett Grund, described a Penn State research project that found that as much as one-half of the deer habitat in Pennsylvania's extensive north-central forests is never penetrated by hunters. He said the results showed that 73 percent of hunters in these areas did not venture more than one-third of a mile from a road.
"This raises the question of whether deer in these large forests are a manageable resource under the current regulations," Grund said.
Alt recognized the adjustments hunters have made to new hunting seasons and regulations.
Stating that her comments were her own and not necessarily those of the Game Commission, commissioner Roxane Palone said, "Hunter satisfaction is important to me because I'm a hunter too. The excitement I feel the opening day of deer season is equal to anyone's. Like most hunters, I love to see lots of deer. I am disappointed when I don't harvest one. My professional training, however, is in forest science and biology. The two hats are complementary.
"As a hunter and a forester, I see what many others see and have been seeing for some time. I see a forest that is stressed and changing for the worst. If we continue to let our forests degrade, they will not support adequate numbers of deer and other wildlife that we have come to expect.
"The Game Commission should not focus solely on the wishes of current hunters [for more deer]. There is very little it can provide in using short-term deer management, other than giving political victories to those who demand short-term solutions. Short-term and shortsighted solutions will only result in long-term failures," she added. "Our goal should be a sustainable deer herd for the generations that follow. It is morally unjust to borrow from the trust fund of our forests to give one or two generations unsustainable numbers of deer."
During a question and answer period, some those in attendance asked about deer contraception and re-introduction of large predators, such as cougars and wolves, to control the herd.
"I don't know any other way except hunting to do this on a landscape basis. We will do this with hunting everywhere we can," Alt said. "But I will say to hunters that it's obvious that we must step up to the plate or society will eventually find another way to control deer."
The Game Commission will propose deer hunting regulations for 2004 at its meeting in Harrisburg Jan. 25-27. Public comment from anyone interested in the 2004 hunting season is welcomed at the Jan. 25 session, which begins at 1 p.m.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.