No. 1: The large deer herds that hunters saw "up north" years ago were "normal" or "the way it should be."
Available evidence tells us that at no time during the 20,000 years since humans have hunted deer in what is now Pennsylvania did deer occur at the high densities seen in northern counties around the middle of the 20th century. Hunters who remember those years saw a brief span of abnormal abundance, widely perceived as the norm. There is no reason to expect that herds could have sustained those high numbers, even without the more aggressive deer management program in place today.
No. 2: Posted land is un-hunted land.
Hunters often assume that private land with posted signs is never hunted, and that such areas become sanctuaries for deer driven off nearby lands. But recent social research shows that landowners, their family and friends do hunt most posted properties, at times more intensely than public lands. And the same research revealed that a significant number of landowners are still willing to consider granting hunting privileges to hunters who show the courtesy to ask permission.
No. 3: Cutting timber always benefits deer.
Deer do find abundant browse in regenerating timber cuts -- if the cuts regenerate tree species that deer prefer as food. But oaks, our most important wildlife food tree, are not regenerating after cutting across large areas of Pennsylvania, on public and private land alike. Mature mast-producing oaks may be even more important in supporting along-term sustainable deer herd than the brushy clear cuts hunters like to see. Cuts that do regenerate attract deer from long distances, but eventually must grow through a multi-year "pole timber" stage where they provide neither browse nor mast.
No. 4: Pennsylvania has no way to implement deer management differently on public lands versus private lands.
The proportion of public lands was one of the criteria for setting the boundaries of the new Wildlife Management Units. Biologists can now allocate antlerless licenses differently for zones that are predominantly private land, and for those with high proportions of public land if and when a different allocation formula is warranted.
Additionally, the Pennsylvania Game Commission did not enroll one acre of state game lands in the DMAP (Deer Management Assistance Program), which distributes additional antlerless tags not calculated in the original WMU quota.
No. 5: Deer check stations would give us an accurate measurement of the deerkill.
Check stations, such as the report card system used in Pennsylvania, which depends on hunter cooperation and concern for deer and deer hunting (about one out of two successful deer hunters mail in their cards) is a human system. Therefore, they are not perfect. Even in states where check stations are mandatory, some hunters forget, ignore, or defy the rules. So, check station data is still an estimate -- an expensive and inconvenient estimate compared to our report card system that hunters can support by dropping a pre-stamped, pre-addressed card in a mailbox.
No. 6: Antlerless licenses are a money-making scheme for the Game Commission.
The cost of an antlerless license has not risen at the same rate as other licenses. During past license-increase negotiations, the Game Commission requested the state legislature not to raise the cost of an antlerless license. Simultaneously, the Commission's cost for printing and distributing antlerless licenses has gone up. Since allocations sell out quickly in all WMUs, the cost of an antlerless license is clearly lower than what hunters perceive as the "market value" of an antlerless tag. Certainly, the Commission gains revenue from the sale of antlerless licenses, but nowhere near the amount it could take in if dollars drove antlerless allocation system.
No. 7: Pennsylvania's deer management program caters to "special interests".
Referring to "special interests" in this context, hunters generally mean farmers, foresters, insurance companies and "environmentalists." But think about this issue from the perspective of a farmer or someone who is betting their retirement or their child's college fund on the health of a young stand of timber. These people are on the land every day. They work it, care for it and they pay tax on it. Their production feeds the deer, and deer damage costs them real money. We hunters want to drop in for a couple of days every fall to hunt, and we expect to see a lot of deer while we're there. From that viewpoint, just who is the special interest in deer management?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.