While some anglers give winter fishing the cold shoulder, others can't wait for the big chill and ice.
SAFETY TIPS
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission offers the following safety tips for ice fishing and much more at www.fish.state.pa.us:
Never fish on ice less than four inches thick.
Ice may not be the same thickness all over the surface of a lake.
Stay away from "stickups," such as logs, brush, plants and docks.
Avoid areas around feeder streams and underground springs.
Avoid dark, honeycombed or porous ice.
Stay away from multiple pressure cracks.
Spread out because crowds can put too much weight in the same area.
Dress warmly. Always wear picks of life and carry a coil of buoyant rope.
If there's a cure for cabin fever, it's fishing on ice -- one of the original extreme sports.
"We have more fun ice fishing than we do in the boat," said Carl Stoltz of Bradford, who caught a state-record northern pike -- a 35-pound, 48-inch behemoth -- on a nine-inch dead shiner on the ice at the Allegheny Reservoir last New Year's Day. "What I like about ice fishing, you never know what you're going to catch. When that flag goes up, it's a mystery."
And it's one best explored in the company of friends.
"This is the one type of fishing you want to do with other people because it's safer," said veteran fisherman Brian Selai of West Newton. "I always go with three to 10 people. We work as a team."
When they're after walleye, which peak early and late in the day, Selai and friends have two power augers going.
"We'll designate a large structured area and keep moving on it 'till we find them. We'll choose humps, sunken islands, bottlenecks, drop-offs and points. It's drill holes and fish, the run and gun approach. We'll drill up to 100 holes a day," he said.
To save time, Selai makes eight-inch, rather than the maximum allowable 10-inch, holes.
Trying to catch Panfish is more of a waiting game. If you find good deep structure, you'll usually get into crappie.
Selai has fished all over Western Pennsylvania and in Canada and never takes safety for granted. He wears a flotation suit and carries 100 feet of rescue rope made of polypropylene because it floats. He also carries picks of life around his neck that could be used to leverage himself out of water.
Under his survivor suit, he wears wind-stopper garments, and underwear and socks of perspiration-wicking materials. Weatherproof clothing enables him to be more mobile than if he pitched a tent, though shelters with heaters enable anglers to stay on the ice for long stretches of time.
In Western Pennsylvania, ice fishing usually gets underway just before Christmas, peaks in January and continues through March. First ice and last ice are considered the best fishing, but they also are the least safe.
"First ice that forms before snow is clear ice and gives you a great vision of what's going on under the surface. Fish have enough light to spot bait even at a distance. They're still feeding but they've had a break from angling pressure," said Ron Anderson of Appalachian Trails near Lake Arthur in Butler County. "Guys can get so excited they have a tendency to go out before good ice has formed."
Early in the season, the backs of bays freeze first and ice is thinner toward the center of the lake. Late in the season, as early spawners such as walleye and pike move toward the shallows, ice begins thawing closer to shore and the lake's overall surface loses integrity.
"All your senses may tell you that you need to get off the ice, it's cracking around you, but the fishing is so good guys will stay another hour or two and get their first exposure to falling in because they push it too far," Anderson said.
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission says four inches of solid ice is the safe minimum for one person. Ice can be weakened by rain, freeze-thaw cycles and other environmental occurrences. Always avoid dark, porous or honeycombed ice, and the areas around underground springs, feeder streams, stumps, bridge abutments and other structures.
Because of its elevation, Highpoint Lake is one of the first in the area to freeze and normally yields nice numbers of pike and perch. Presque Isle Bay's largemouth can't be beat and there are always steelhead. Good smallmouth come out of Conneaut Lake, one of the state's largest natural lakes, along with crappie, white bass and bluegill. Sandy Lake produces catfish and perch, and Lake Wilhelm has a variety of species.
"Wilhelm is one of those just before dark lakes," Selai said. "You get crappies by the dam, perch on the flats and really nice bass and walleye."
He fishes Pymatuning for walleye, Raccoon Lake for trout and panfish, Shenango Lake for crappie, Yellow Creek Lake for pike, bass and panfish, Woodcock Lake for panfish, bass and the occasional muskie, and Shawnee Reservoir for muskie.
"That lake has a lot of structure, which is what muskie like...vertical structure, big bluffs, big drop-offs through the ice," he said of Shawnee.
Selai likes to catch large fish, so he usually runs one jigging rod and four tip-ups, although two out of five devices can be jigging rods. The tip-ups with live bait are used for northern pike and bass, while the jigging rods with tear-drops, ice ants, small spoons or small jigging Rapalas and live bait work on walleye and panfish.
He also recommends a spinning reel with good drag.
"The cheap plastic ice reels are fine if you're not where there are many predators," he said. "But if you're fishing [Lake] Arthur for hybrid stripers or Presque Isle for steelhead, you'd better have something with drag."
When panfishing, he said, an effective pattern is to work two rods, three feet apart, with one on the bottom and one on top, so they eclipse each other until you get a strike. The bottom rod will have a maggot-tipped ice-ant and the top one, a minnow-tipped ice ant. "This is also an effective pattern on trout-stocked lakes because they can be anywhere in the water column," Selai said. "They're not structure related, they're looking for food."
When targeting largemouth on high-pressure lakes, he would rather use 20-pound fluorocarbon leader than wire. Toothy northerns require coated steel braided wire with live shiners. With lighter leader, larger hooks help minimize break-offs.
Stoltz caught his record-setting northern in three feet of water close to shore. "That's how you get the big ones. They'll pin the bait against the bank 'cause they don't like to chase it," he said. "I kill my bait before I use it."
Some anglers say walleye and panfish caught through ice taste better, or maybe it just seems that way after spending all day in the cold. But selective harvest is becoming more common, with big breeders and pre-spawning females going back into the water.
"We don't go out like it's a job," Stoltz said. "My favorite part of ice fishing is all the hunting stories we tell."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.