Though it was anything but unanimous, the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission executive board appointed an Illinois government worker as the agency's executive director Monday.

In a 5-4 vote, the board named Douglas J. Austen of Springfield, Ill., head of the Illinois Department of Natural Resources technical support section, to fill the position vacated by Pete Colangelo in May. Other finalists were John Arway, the Fish and Boat Commission's head of environmental services, and John Simmons, the commission's boating and education director.

Southwest Pennsylvania board member Ross Huhn of Saltsburg voted for Arway, the commission's representative to the Coldwater Heritage Partnership, a conservation alliance that includes Trout Unlimited and the Department of Conservation and Natural Resouces. Fish and Boat Commission board president Sam Concilla of Erie supported Austen, who, besides working for IDNR, is an adjunct professor at the University of Illinois.

"He's someone from the outside with no ties who owes nobody nothing, who can come in with an open mind and do what it takes to bring the agency forward in modern times," Concilla said. In Illinois, fishermen outnumber hunters almost three to one.

Advertise with us

"Our users have different needs now," Concilla said. "We're not a good old boys organization anymore. We've got to be a lean, mean machine that enhances fishing and boating opportunities for families."

Lean is the consequence of declining revenues and rising costs. The Fish and Boat Commission has a $50 million task in bringing the state's hatcheries up to specifications with fewer license holders to pick up the tab. That means finding outside funding sources.

There is also a possible merger of the Fish and Boat Commission and the Pennsylvania Game Commission -- the set-up in most other states, including Illinois, which is why some commissioners favored Austen.

"He can expound upon the pros and cons," Huhn said. "The impression, from what I could gather, was he opposes a merger, that one agency would get more than the other, game would get more than fish. I think that's why Sam [Concilla] liked him."

None of the board members, including Huhn, wants the agencies to merge. Concilla called a recent report by the state Legislative Budget and Finance Committee supporting the consolidation "shallow and incomplete."

Advertise with us

"Dr. Austen has that report," Concilla said. "He's requested a lot more information. He's very aware of the looming merger, which may or may not happen. And he welcomes the challenge."

In Illinois, as in 28 other states, fish and game are part of a much larger agency that also oversees forestry, mining and a host of other resources. That is something being considered for Pennsylvania, too.

Bruce Smith (R-York), chair of the House Game and Fisheries Committee, pushed the merger study, and Rep. Edward Staback (D-Lackawanna) has tasked the budget and finance committee with studying whether law enforcement for fish and game should be transferred to DCNR. Folding fish and game into a bigger agency would open up new funding, but with lawmakers holding the purse strings.

"Putting the management of wildlife into the hands of legislators not educated in wildlife management, it becomes [a matter of] who the strongest legislators are, which ones command the most say, and not necessarily what's best for the resource or the people," Concilla said.

In Illinois last year, fishing and hunting received $82 million out of a total IDNR budget of $753 million. About 55.2 percent was in taxpayer-supported general fund appropriations and 27.6 percent came from hunting and fishing licenses, stamps and other permits. The rest was derived from gas and oil leases on game lands, real estate transfer fees and federal funds (from taxes outdoors gear manufacturers pay). About 330,000 hunting licenses and 800,000 fishing licenses were sold.

Advertise with us

By contrast, Pennsylvania has about 1 million licensed hunters and 1.3 million fishermen. The Fish and Boat Commissio's fisheries fund collected $27.3 million, down $1 million from the previous year, and its boat fund collected $10.4 million, which has held steady in recent years, plus $8 million in federal tax-derived funds and liquid fuels tax revenues. The Game Commission took in $63.4 million (including $35.8 million in license sales, $12.3 million in timber sales, and $8 million in federal tax-derived funds), which also has held steady. The Fish and Boat Commission hasn't hiked license fees in seven years but plans to do so in 2005.

Concilla said he looks forward to Austen meeting with staff to map out goals and a direction. Austen won't come in "with a sword, slashing," said Concilla. "He's methodical."

Austen earned a doctorate from Iowa State University's Department of Animal Ecology in 1992 and a master of science degree with an emphasis on fisheries science from Virginia Tech. His bachelor of science in wildlife and fisheries science is from South Dakota State University. He is a certified fisheries professional with the American Fisheries Society.

He is expected to take over the Fish and Boat Commision job next month once paperwork is completed and to be paid in excess of $100,000.