The antler restrictions now in place in Pennsylvania were designed to let more bucks grow to maturity and to nudge the sex ratio of the population toward a higher proportion of males. Both objectives will take some time before hunters can readily see the results but another, less anticipated, benefit of antler restrictions is evident.
Pennsylvania hunters are learning more about deer than ever before. In the past it was customary, celebrated even, for hunters to kill the first buck they saw and with an antler minimum of one 3-inch spike there weren't many bucks off-limits.
After that kill the hunter was excluded from the woods until the 3-day doe season, which was generally a chaotic melee instead of a true hunt. There wasn't much opportunity to observe deer.
"Shoot a deer before someone else does" described the Pennsylvania approach to hunting. But antler restrictions have changed the ground rules.
Now hunters must devote more care and discretion to each shot, checking for the minimum number of points. In most encounters, we're required to let the buck pass, which has allowed hunters to see things they may have heard or read about but never witnessed for themselves.
One hunter told me that before last week he had never heard a buck grunt despite reading about this vocalization in countless magazine articles. This hunter said he was sitting on a rock overlooking a basin of open woods. He heard leaves rustling behind him and then a low grunting sound. Moments later six or seven does came bounding into sight with a small buck right behind them, grunting constantly.
Because the buck wasn't legal, the hunter watched him chase and harass the does for several minutes. None accepted the buck's advances but the hunter got a glimpse of deer behavior he never dreamed he would see.
Another hunter described how he had watched a buck -- also not legal -- scraping and rubbing his antlers near a buck scrape. Again, this was behavior the hunter had read about and seen on video but never observed in the woods.
I, too, witnessed something I had never before seen during the gun season. Two does threaded out of a grape and green briar thicket with a buck right behind them. From afar the buck looked like a "shooter," but as he approached it was clear that he carried only a perfectly matched set of "Ys"for a rack. The buck paid absolutely no attention to his surroundings. He was obsessed with the two does and blundered right into easy gun range.
The buck followed the exact path of the does, often lifting his head and curling back his upper lip toward his nostrils -- a behavior that biologists call "flehmen." A buck does this to capture and relish the scent of a doe, gauging his prospects for romantic success, so to speak.
The does were intent only on detecting danger. They came into the little clearing with ears, eyes and nose on full alert, stepping ahead with tentative caution. The buck plodded right behind them, oblivious to everything but the alluring scent. In the "old days" before antler restrictions, this buck would have been hanging from someone's meat pole in the early hours of the season. But I had the pleasure of watching his amorous exploration.
I was also reminded that the assumption that bucks are more wary than does is one of the great myths of outdoor lore. Hunters who are out in the woods in the archery season have watched these whitetail behaviors many times. But until now, the state's rifle hunters have had little chance to learn about whitetail behavior first hand.
As our deer managers have said, we may not keep the present antler restrictions in place permanently. But permanent or not, they have given us a better look into the life of the white-tailed deer. And if knowing more about the wildlife we hunt is a worthy aspiration, then antler restrictions have proved themselves a good move for Pennsylvania.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.