In Missouri, fishing and hunting always have been regulated by one agency under the conservation department. Besides license sales, funding comes from one-eighth of 1 percent of the state sales tax, an initiative that citizens enacted in 1976.
"The Department of Conservation has had no revenue problems since," said Robert Montgomery, conservation columnist for "Bassmaster" magazine and a Missouri resident. "That's allowed Missouri to become the envy of conservation departments across the nation."
For many years, much of the money was used to buy lands for public use, then the emphasis shifted to improving access and enhancing those lands, Montgomery said. "The DOC also publishes one of the best monthly wildlife magazines in the nation and it's free to all adult state residents."
And a basic fishing license is just $11 a year.
Sportsmen have been so pleased with the setup that when a few legislators tried to take away their dedicated funds to ease budget woes elsewhere, the public protest was so loud, Montgomery said, "the attempted money grab died a quick death."
The scenario in Pennsylvania couldn't be more different, with the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission desperate to find new funding sources in the wake of plummeting license sales, hatchery woes, impending license fee hikes and talk of a merger with the Game Commission, which neither agency nor many sportsmen want.
Pennsylvania is not the only state feeling a squeeze. In 2004, bass fishermen in Texas will begin paying $5 for a freshwater stamp to fund hatcheries that produce one-quarter of the state's bass. But Pennsylvania is the only state that doesn't combine fish and game, though, in a report released Thursday, the bi-partisan Legislative Budget and Finance Committee said a merger would be feasible, something it never found in previous studies.
"It always seemed a merger wasn't going to happen. This time, we were led to believe it was possible," said Phil Durgin, the committee's executive director. "So we came up with a vision."
In the picture are 71 job cuts, a streamlined executive office and a change in law enforcement that would eliminate 36 positions and have officers working only as police with none of the trout stocking, hunter safety training or wildlife management duties they have performed in the past.
In fact, the budget committee is studying whether law enforcement for fish and game should be made a separate bureau working out of the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources. Its findings are expected next spring. This would put more agency emphasis on resource management, Durgin said, and could pave the way for an eventual move to DCNR, something that makes anglers and hunters nervous.
"Sportsmen have always carried their weight," Game Commission executive director Vern Ross said of the agencies' user-pay setup. "And we want to keep it that way."
Reducing staff and trimming operations would save $5 million a year, the report indicated.
One executive director would oversee fish and game commissions, with deputies handling resource management, administration and law enforcement, unless that function is moved to DCNR, Durgin said.
"You can't have one person in charge of fish and game. It just wouldn't work," said Joe Pugach, a Trout Unlimited regional board member. "No matter how fair and equitable they'd try to be, there would always be competing interests.
"In New Jersey, where I come from, the hunters hold sway. Anglers get nothing of what they want. It's whichever makes the most money, and that's usually hunting."
Pennsylvania hunters have been more vocal than anglers in opposing a merger because they fear they have more to lose, including 1.4 million acres of state gamelands.
"I can absolutely, positively assure hunters that in a merger the gamelands would not be touched," said Rep. Bruce Smith, R-York, chairman of the House Game and Fisheries Committee that is pushing for a combined agency. The Game Commission profits from oil, gas and timber leases on its gamelands, which helps offset flat license sales. It also raised license fees four years ago and is considering another increase three years from now.
The Fish and Boat Commission hasn't restructured fees in seven years but is planning hikes for 2005. While it expects to make $5 million from new and higher fees, including a $2 junior license and a $10 steelhead stamp, it also is bracing for a marked drop in sales, something that always follows license fee increases. Sales fell by 7 percent in 1996 and never recovered. They were down this year by 3 percent, or double the usual decrease. If license fees go up at the same time a merger is unfolding, the Fish and Boat Commission will be in for even harder times.
One thing the report fails to address is the projected cost of a merger, which would be monumental, said Ross. "It would cost game $20 million alone. We'd be dealing with four unions, job buyouts, retraining personnel, employee morale. We'd have issues around that for the next 20 years.
"And even if the agencies were combined, would that solve the deficit problem?"
While the report acknowledges that new funding streams are needed, it doesn't identify what they might be.
Ross suggests a portion of the state sales tax on hunting and fishing gear. "Cabella's, located in Hamburg, Pa., generates $50 million in tax revenue each year," he said. "They're only here because of the outdoorsmen. What if they and other big stores gave fish and game just 1 percent? Think what that would do for their customers."
Tipping fee legislation has been reintroduced, though efforts to divert part of landfill operators' revenue from Growing Greener projects to fish and game have failed before. Bond funds are another possibility.
"One of the catch-22s is that you've got to keep up programs that keep folks fishing," said acting Fish and Boat Commission executive director Dennis Guise. "That takes money. It means raising licenses periodically. Yet, when you do that, you risk losing customers. Smaller numbers of anglers will be asked to pay more unless new funding sources are identified."
That, said Guise, is where legislators' efforts should be.
(Action on a merger could come as soon as next year. For information on the the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee report go to the Fish and Boat Commission site at www.fish.state.pa.us and look under news and updates. To voice your opinion on the merger, contact your state representative or members of the House Game and Fisheries Committee, including Rep. Bruce Smith, R-York, at 717-783-8783, or Rep. Edward Staback, D-Lackawanna, at 717-783-5043. )Report states feasibility of merging fish, game commissions




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.