It's wall-to-wall walleye on Western Pennsylvania's rivers with veteran anglers reporting the best bite in decades.

"It hasn't been this good since I opened my shop and that was 19 years ago," said Wayne Lykens of Island Firearms on the Ohio River.

That was Wednesday and a soft drizzle had lured die-hards to the back channel dam on Neville Island and the mouth of Montour Creek. "They've got it surrounded -- guys wading on one side and boats on the other."

Jay Hughes of Verona released a 31 1/2-inch, 13-pound walleye on an 8-inch sucker Oct. 24 and a 31 3/4-inch, 11-pounder the following Saturday. he caught both from shore at the Highland Park Dam.

Advertise with us

"This is probably the best year in 15 years there," said Hughes, who has fished at Highland Park and at Dashields Dam in Leetsdale on the Ohio since the early 1970s. "I'm getting them every day 23, 24, 25 inches. I'm having luck with the bigger fish."

Luck has little to do with it. Hughes fishes daily with creek bait, including big suckers and chubs. And nature has blessed anglers with a special set of conditions.

"We're reaping the harvest of the drought years when there was good reproduction and good survival of all species, including forage," said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson of the 6- to 12-year old trophies now putting on fat for winter.

Conversely, high water kept anglers off the rivers this past spring and summer, which means more fish are there for the catching. It also wiped out the shad spawn, depriving walleye of their main forage.

"Young of the year shad just aren't there," Lorson said. "So, walleye are more prone to take what's on your hook."

Advertise with us

"The skipjack herring and shad are both absent," said Hughes of the two related species. "When the baitfish aren't around, the walleye have got to search for them. They're active now. With winter coming, the big predators are more apt to come into the shallows for food."

It has meant an anglers' bounty in terms of both size and numbers. One recent night at Highland Park, Hughes landed 15 nice-size walleye by 9:30 p.m.

"It was awesome," he said. "That's not counting the ones that got off."

The day he caught his 31 3/4-incher he watched a friend bring a 26- and a 28-incher to shore.

While most anglers are using shiners, fatheads and Rapalas, Hughes fishes with suckers and chubs he seines out of Deer and Pine Creeks. "I'll use 'em both but I swear by the suckers," he said. "The chubs get a lot fatter. You can get big suckers, too. I'll fish with them 3 to 8 inches. But they're slender, so it seems they're easier going down."

Advertise with us

Walleye are more attracted to bait from their same water, said Hughes, and natural bait is livelier around predators than the farm-raised kind bought at bait shops.

Hughes used to catch suckers with hook and line. "It's the same kind of thing as fishing for trout," he said. "But it takes a while. Put a little piece of crawler or mealworm on a hook. Use light line. You'll catch a lot but you'll be there for a couple of hours."

He even traps under ice in the winter, augering holes to set the traps in the deeper pools, putting bread inside, and then letting them sit for several days. Otherwise, he'll walk a seining net upstream.

"Once it gets cold, it's harder during the day. The baitfish are hiding under rocks and coming out more at night. But I go when I can," he said.

Hughes learned to fish for walleye from a couple of old timers at Highland Park and is such a fixture other regulars call him "Everyday" Jay and seek his advice.

Advertise with us

"I fish 8-pound test, an 8 1/2-foot Ugly Stick and a number two or number four hook," he said. "Put a little weight on to get your bait to the bottom and then retrieve. It's a slow process. You need patience.

"Most people make the mistake of setting the hook as soon as they get the hard bite. When you're fishing big bait, you got to wait for the walleye to turn it around so he can swallow it headfirst."

"When I fished that 8-inch sucker, the fish hit hard the first time. I had my drag set real light. I opened the bale and let him run for a while. They'll grab the bait and run for 20 yards. When it stopped, I set the rod back down. Every so often, I'd see it tap, tap, tap. Remember, that sucker's moving, trying to get away.

"I'll bet I waited 20 minutes to set the hook. You just get a feel for it."

And you have to be willing to shrug off bad weather.

Advertise with us

"When rain's hitting the surface of the water, or snow, or the wind's putting a chop in the water, it gives walleye a type of cover and they'll get real active," Hughes said. "That's a good time to catch walleye."

The walleye's eye is structured so it can out-see preyfish in low light and after dark.

"Winter, they stay deep, though they come out of the depths at night," said Hughes, who fishes Leetsdale more than Highland Park in the coldest months because it is deeper water and the sandier bottom allows him to work his bait with fewer snags. "There aren't as many people fishing either."

Yet for bank anglers, fall and spring are ideal because walleye are cruising the shorelines for preyfish and feeding hard.

Three of the five largest walleye reported in the state last year were caught in spring and fall on the Allegheny River. The year before, three of the largest came out of the Allegheny in November and December. The sizes rival those being caught right now.