Another year of eating great food and meeting the people who make it is in the books, and in 2019, diners with heart, super fresh sushi, big sloppy sandwiches, red sauce Italian, and a whole lot of pizza made up Munch’s favorite meals ...

(Ain’t no sushi dope as this, it’s just) So Fresh, So Clean: Mola
With apologies to luminary hip-hop artists OutKast, their classic song is the first thing that comes to mind when eating at Mola in East Liberty because that’s exactly what the fantastic fare is: so fresh and so clean (clean).
As sushi has evolved from exotic delicacy to supermarket staple, having a top-quality offering reminds us of what makes it special. Mimi Lee and Alex Tang do that very well at Mola, not only because of the premium fish but also with a unique combination of ingredients.
To wit: the Japanese sea bream and black truffle pate, hand-rolled in crispy nori — a meaty, clean fish with a sharp, earthy complement ($9). Or the salmon belly with sun-dried tomato and garlic — a perfect pop of flavor with a silky texture.
Conversely, the Santa Barbara uni with blue crab hand roll was a delicious study in high-definition subtlety: The savory, velvety, nutty uni went perfectly with the sweet crab meat ($10) in an expression of exquisite understatement.
6018 Penn Ave., East Liberty; 412-365-6688; https://www.themolafish.com

Best Big Honkin’ Sammies: Duncan Street Sandwich Shop
It’s easily the size of a football, and after you unwrap the butcher paper holding the Nashville hot turkey sandwich, it expands like it’s spring loaded as crispy chopped turkey confit slathered with a nearly glowing spicy orange sauce spills out from between thick slabs of outstanding sourdough bread.
Additionally complemented by a roasted garlic aioli, sweet relish, romaine and onion, it is a big, honking, beautiful delicious mess of a sandwich at the Duncan Street Sandwich Shop, opened in September 2018 by chefs and co-owners Kendyl Ryan and Dan Rodriguez.
There’s a vegan roasted mushroom sandwich that my better half accurately described as “like eating a French onion soup sandwich,” and a roasted turkey breast sandwich that’s brined and seasoned with rosemary, brown sugar and black pepper and tastes like Thanksgiving, a happy accident that Mr. Rodriguez said he and Ms. Ryan discovered when they coated the turkey with pan drippings. It’s trimmed with a tomato honey, goat cheese, sweet onion and romaine, again between that killer sourdough.
They’re all $10, and it’s easy to pick which one is the best: the one that is in front of you.
543 North Ave., Millvale; 412-252-2940; http://duncanst.com

When Life Gives You Lemons, Make Limoncello: Garbarino’s Restaurant 4th Gen
“I never wanted an Italian restaurant.”
A graduate of the prestigious Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, N.Y., drawn to creating food that pushes boundaries, Andrew Garbarino’s sentiment made sense. But when the downstairs space of the Johnstown native’s ultra-luxe Twisted Frenchman restaurant in East Liberty — a casual French bistro — didn’t go over as planned, he returned to his roots and turned it into Garbarino’s Restaurant 4th Gen, serving classic Italian and Italian-American dishes. The name is an homage to Mr. Garbarino’s great-grandaunt Louisa, an immigrant from Genoa who in 1945 opened Garbarino’s Restaurant in Lynbrook on Long Island, N.Y., and ran it until it closed in 1996.
Fresh bread is served with sizzling butter and oil and roasted garlic cloves in a cast-iron pan; beans and greens ($13) are a top-notch interpretation of a Western Pennsylvania staple. Sweet and spicy pork sausage and cannellini beans are in a flavorful chicken stock made richer with the addition of butter and only a light smattering of escarole.
The Spaghetti Bolognese ($19) is a masterpiece. A base of rendered guanciale fat amps up the flavor of the ground prosciutto, beef and veal. Tomatoes and diced carrots give it a distinctive orange hue, and the housemade spaghetti is cut extra long so your forearms will feel like Popeye’s after fork-twirling it through the rich Bolognese sauce.
And be sure and grab a drink from bartender Troy Beck, whose sharp wit matches his skill behind the stick.
5925 Baum Blvd., East Liberty; 412-665-2880; http://garbarinos.com

No Phony Baloney: Pizzeria Davide
In a year that saw a raft of quality pizza shops open around Pittsburgh, Pizzeria Davide, the Strip District pizzeria from DiAnoia’s Eatery chef and co-owner Dave Anoia, had the highest expectations, and he delivered — even if he was full of baloney. Literally.
Mr. Anoia touts the signature pizzas as “Old World” style — no reference to Naples or Rome but rather Lebanon, Pa., where he grew up on Pete’s Pizza. The pies are layered with sliced sharp provolone and tangy red sauce and finished with basil, Parmesan and oregano. He adds another hometown favorite, Lebanon sweet bologna, along with a fresh hot pepper relish to create an absolute must-try pie that envelops every bud on the tongue.
It looks like salami, and when cooked up it takes on a nearly purple hue. That funky mix of flavors is perfect with the aforementioned base pie and is complemented by the aromatic heat of the pepper relish, the fragrant basil and a crispy thin crust.
We annihilated an entire pie ($25), and our group nearly arm-wrestled one another for the final piece.
2551 Penn Ave.; 412-904-4139; https://www.pizzeriadavide.com

Name of the Year: Crust Almighty
Over on the South Side, local restaurant veteran Mike Pappas opened in conjunction with Cupka’s Cafe a small pizza shop with a name so perfect it’s hard to believe it hasn’t been used before: Crust Almighty, with the slogan “The dough is risen.” (To boot, Mr. Pappas’ LLC is called Greek Unorthodox.)
The staff makes a solid pie with a crispy crust and tangy red sauce ($12.99 for a 12-cut large) with high-quality toppings, but the pizza isn’t even the best thing on the menu.
Their recent hot sausage hoagie was unequivocally the best I’ve ever had. A half-pound of housemade ground spicy hot sausage with sauteed sweet bell peppers, caramelized onions and provolone cheese on a fresh Mancini’s bun was excellent. That it could be enjoyed next door at Cupka’s with a cold Penn Pilsner is an almighty experience, indeed.
46 S. 27th St., South Side; 412-481-6262; https://www.facebook.com/pages/category/Pizza-Place/Crust-Almighty-Pizzeria-and-More-692347847807635.

Best cocktail in a Spam can: Soju
A particularly fun part of this job is that there’s seldom a shortage of new experiences. To wit: sitting at a stainless steel bar listening to Iggy Pop while looking at a piece of artwork featuring a day-glo yellow Lemmy Kilmister of Motorhead and drinking a smoky citrus cocktail out of a blue Spam can before mowing down a sweet-funky-peppery and crunchy bowl of kimchi fried rice.
That was a new one for me at Simon Chough’s Soju on Penn Avenue in Garfield, where they play good music and serve Korean and Korean-American specialties and craft cocktails in a riot of flavors, like the aforementioned Waikiki Spam Jam: a Spam-infused mix of mezcal and rum, falernum, and pineapple and lime juices.
4923 Penn Ave., Garfield; 412-956-7699; https://simonchough.wixsite.com/sojupgh

The Wilt Chamberlain Award for Best Rebounding: The Vault
The Vault Taproom, opened in late July on the South Side to quite a bit of fanfare because of its location — in the former home of iconic coffeeshop The Beehive — and for the novelty of incorporating an iPourIt self-service tap system for beer and wine.
Unfortunately, the menu was well-conceived, if poorly executed, with friendly but lackadaisical service. A few months later, the experience could not have been more different. And better. Credit is due to executive chef and U.S. Marine Corps veteran Todd Cassell and owner Kyle Wolfe. The pared-down menu was delicious, and the service was on point.
Try the 12-hour Smoked Brisket Reuben ($16) — a bomb of savory smoke, with tender peppered brisket, with gruyere, sauerkraut and housemade Russian dressing on toasted Mancini’s rye, with a side of perfectly creamy orecchiette mac and cheese topped with crunchy buttered panko crumbs.
And don’t skip on a drink from lead bartender Paige Barker, like the Pineapple Death Squad ($11). Made with Del Maguey Vida mezcal, house falernum, pineapple gum syrup and lime juice it was citrus forward and subtly smoky on the back end. A nicely balanced drink.
1327 E. Carson St., South Side Flats; 412-904-4462; https://www.thevaultpgh.com

Breakfast & Lunch with a side of Heart & Soul: Eggs & Moore, Love Rocks Cafe & Nancy’s Revival
The neighborhood diner is a vital part of the fabric of American life, as much for the meals offered as the company and gathering spaces provided. Arlington, McKees Rocks and Wilkinsburg — three neighborhoods that have at times struggled to tread water in postindustrial Pittsburgh — each has one that offers hearty fare at inexpensive prices along with a sense of community.
In Arlington, it is Eggs & Moore, opened in 2018 on the 2300 block of Arlington Ave., where sisters Amy and Marnie Moore, their cousin Lisa Duffy and longtime friend Matt Ansani whip up killer pancakes and deliver punchlines and quips at each other’s expense that are delivered in spades.
Over in McKees Rocks, Jackie Page-Heidelberg is a one-woman show at her Love Rocks Cafe, a cheery breakfast and lunch counter opened in March inside the Father Ryan Arts Center. She effortlessly pumps out orders while holding court with customers about anything and everything, often hilariously so.
Finally, a Wilkinsburg institution since 1976, Jordan Robarge and David McAlpin took over Nancy’s Diner and rechristened it Nancy’s Revival earlier this year. They have continued the spirit of Nancy’s as a community hub with affordable quality diner fare for breakfast and lunch, and they offer regular life, job and financial literacy skills classes as well. Framed photos of regulars line the walls, and the place positively hums on weekday and weekend mornings.
“We’re just working really hard with our community, and we’re extremely thankful for all the support,” Mr. Robarge said. “They keep pushing us.”
Eggs & Moore: 2332 Arlington Ave., Arlington; 412-863-7228; https://www.facebook.com/eggsandmoore
Love Rocks Cafe: 420 Chartiers Ave., McKees Rocks; 412-770-4642; https://www.facebook.com/LoveRocksCafe
Nancy’s Revival: 616 South Ave., Wilkinsburg; 412-242-3447; https://nancysrevival.com.

All Roads Lead to Roman Pizza: Romulus Pizza al Taglio
Rome wasn’t built in a day, and neither was Kevin Konn and Justin Balla’s pizza-making prowess, and they used their combined nearly three decades of experience to create some truly killer Roman-style pizza “al taglio” — by the cut — resulting in medium-depth rectangular slices with a super crispy exoskeleton and airy caverns of dough.
My dining partner even mused, “I don’t want to eat the last bite, because I don’t want it to end.”
Sadly, all good things do end — for now, anyway. Mr. Konn and Mr. Balla opted not to renew their lease on the upstairs floor of The Pennsylvania Market, in the Strip District, and are exploring options for a space of their own. This bite will have to live in the mind’s stomach until an anticipated announcement is made in 2020.
https://www.facebook.com/Romulus.Dante
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.