The “Three Day Blow” blew through town late last month, thanks in large part to the same fine folks who made Wigle Whiskey a reality in Pittsburgh. Named for the Ernest Hemingway story of the same title, this conference of food writers and culinary professionals was an excellent meeting of the minds and a terrific examination of how Pittsburgh’s food scene has evolved, where it is now and where it’s headed.
It was also an opportunity to talk shop and kvetch about the pros and cons of a generally choice gig, and included a conversation with a colleague about the most painfully overused and pretentious phrases in food writing.
These include, but are not limited to:
“Accessible” — a normal person can afford it.
“Artisanal” — likely made by someone with a mustache; doesn’t necessarily mean it’s good.
“Authentic” — likely made by someone with an accent; also doesn’t necessarily mean it’s good.
Read More
“Curated” — food that apparently belongs in a museum.
“Elevated comfort food” — normal-people food, but overpriced, and likely with added kale or pork belly (see also: peasant food, elevated).
“Go-to” — ostensibly a favorite, but often also the only thing that a writer has actually tried.
“Helm” or “Helming” — because apparently chefs and bartenders are also sea captains.
“Program” — known as a menu since the dawn of time, until that no longer sounded ambitious enough.
Some of these are ear-stabbingly grating and some are just cliche. But sometimes you're dead tired and on deadline and have an editor staring holes through you to finish and you quickly need a phrase that makes you sound smarter than you are (guilty!). Used altogether, you can form a patently ridiculous sentence like this: “The artisanal chipped ham program with Chef Milo McJag helming the kitchen is a go-to for accessible, authentic, yet elevated comfort food.”
I present this lengthy preamble because despite having heard nothing but good word of mouth about Troy Hill’s Scratch Food & Beverage, the restaurant uses more than a few of these words on its website, which gave me pause, as I imagined some precious place where line tattoos and Warby-Parkers must be visible for inspection prior to admission. That’s my loss for having preconceived notions, because I finally visited and loved both the place and the food.
Opening late last year in the former longtime home of Billy’s Bistro, owner Don Maheny along with chefs Matt Petruna and Stella Bauerle have created — wait for it — a program of accessible, artisanal elevated comfort food.
As indicated by the name, everything is made from scratch and locally sourced whenever possible. It also doesn’t cost a lot of “scratch” — the most expensive dish is $21, with 18 other items $12 and under.
A plate of charred Shishito peppers ($7), like all of the produce was off-the-vine fresh, an almost luminescent green and crisp with some oil and sea salt.
The “Chicken + Biscuit,” a confit and fried chicken breast with Pennsylvania maple syrup and house-baked biscuit ($9), was terrific. The chicken was juicy with a ton of flavor, the syrup subtly sweet, the biscuits perfect.
The “PA ’Shroom Crostini” with Pennsylvania button, crimini and oyster mushrooms, pesto, cream cheese on house-baked poppyseed bread was a thing of absolute beauty ($10), that could be the subject of a still life.
Despite being made with a house spaetzle, braised cabbage and onions and brown butter, the item I thought I would like the most but was unmoved by was the Haluski ($8). The care and quality was evident, but some things are simply better at family reunions and church fares.
The cocktail menu is a gas, with a few drinks making use of IC Light Mango (which is surprisingly not terrible) and a Salty Dog reimagined with Mezcal and dubbed the “Angry Chihuahua.”
I enjoyed it so much that I’m sure it will be a personal new ... go-to.
Scratch Food & Beverage: 1720 Lowrie St., Troy Hill; 412-251-0822; scratchfoodbev.com.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.