For the past few decades the conventional wisdom (at least among the hockey set) has suggested that if you’re making a call to Turtle Crick, the person of record to ask for is of course, one Arnold Slick.

But, with all due deference to legendary Penguins announcer Mike Lange, should you find yourself in the 15145, I suggest you make a point to seek out someone else altogether: Shelly Farren.

Though her surname doesn’t rhyme with the colloquial pronunciation of the borough named for a Monongahela tributary, she is the proprietor of the eponymous Shelly Pie Pizza and has created a buzz for a business born of experience, timing and a leap of faith.

A longtime employee of Vincent’s Pizza Park, Ms. Farren found herself out of work when that North Braddock institution of six decades abruptly closed in the spring of 2012. Around that same time, her old friends Mike Aiello and Jim Holland completed purchase of the former Turtle Creek VFW building with designs on turning it into storage units and a furniture store, but did a quick pivot when the idea of a pizza place — helmed by Ms. Farren — was broached. A year later, Shelly Pie Pizza was born.

Advertise with us

While the building resembles a yellow brick fortress, the inside is nothing but warmth and nostalgia, and you can smell the pizzas baking from the parking lot.

The walls are lined with black and white World War II era photos of neighborhood street scenes and trolleys and nearby St. Colman Church. In the lobby, a display case of VFW artifacts and a dedication to U.S. servicemen and servicewomen, past and present.

There is a full menu of red sauce favorites — chicken parm, cheese ravioli, stuffed shells — made to order in massive proportion ($10.95-$14.95). I enjoyed a particularly good piece of lasagna ($12.95). The size of a brick, it was covered in shredded cheeses and served with a meatball the size of a cue ball.

Meals come with a fresh spring greens salad or a perfect cup of wedding soup; bread and rolls are from Mancini’s; the BYOB corkage fee is $4 for wine and 50 cents for beer. Also available are a full compliment of hoagies, sandwiches and salads ($4.25-$11.50) and daily specials like stuffed green peppers or fried chicken.

Service was peerless both on a busy Saturday night and a Sunday evening before closing time, and delivered with that uniquely Western Pennsylvania affection that is both brusque yet backslapping at the same time.

Advertise with us

So, about that pizza.

It is huge. It is gorgeous. It is greasy. It is cheesy. And given its proximity and lineage, it will forever be compared to its forebear, the Vinnie Pie.

In the relatively short timeline since Vincent’s closed and reopened and the advent of Shelly Pie, a Mon Valley version of the Mineo’s-Aiello’s rift has emerged that divides households like modern day mozzarella-based border states.

An East McKeesport native brought up on Vinnie Pies, my girlfriend and her family can discuss the nuanced differences between the two — grease quotient, sauce ratio, cheese mass, crust density — on a near subatomic level, like highly trained sommeliers quaffing flavor notes from rare vintages, or arson dogs detecting accelerant particles after a four-alarm blaze.

Me, I’m a South Hills guy, and thus an easier sell, and I absolutely love it (as do they). This pizza is awesomely doughy, gooey and spicy. There is almost no dignified way to eat it, and one should not feel ashamed or effete breaking out the knife and fork. A medium ($12) is a huge 16-inch, 8-cut that could feed an ornery rugby team. A large could be mistaken for a small moon.

Advertise with us

Purists might deride it for being neither New York nor Chicago style. To them I say, “Well, guess where you aren’t?”

I recently saw graffiti scrawled on, of all places, a bar bathroom wall that read, “Pizza is life — Life is pizza.” Philosophy? Allegory? Analogy? Symbolism? Or possibly the author just came from Shelly Pie.

Shelly Pie Pizza, 912 Penn Ave., Turtle Creek; 412-646-2560 or shellypiepizza.com.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @gigs412.