A Greek priest and Munch walk into a Italian market. No, this isn't the start of an offensive joke, just a recent afternoon at Merante Brothers Market. The business, owned by the same Italian family for more than a century, now has a location in Canonsburg, right across from All Saints Greek Orthodox Church.

Munch has been to the new Merante's three times to visit each of the parts: the market-cum-deli, Cucina di Domenica restaurant and the Caffe d'Antonio coffee shop. Munch was suitably impressed by two out of the three. And very impressed (also intimidated) by Father George, with his flowing beard and long black robe, who regularly hosts pastoral meetings in the conference room above the market.

Merante Brother's Market is at 604 W. McMurray Road, Canonsburg; http://merantebrothersmarket.com/and 724-743-5900.

Although Munch never has been one for history (unless it's the history of ganache, with a tasting menu), the story behind Merante's is noteworthy. Pasquale Merante started in Pittsburgh in 1905 with a horse-drawn grocery wagon that would lead to three other stores throughout the city; the same family still runs the Groceria Merante on Bates Street in Oakland.

Advertise with us

The new market is truly a family affair; you can order a sandwich made with the sausage that one of Pasquale's sons, Salvatore, has been making for 57 years. Grandson Antonio had the idea for the coffee shop, and his wife, Domenica, cooks for the restaurant.

Munch always thought it ill-advised to work and live with the same people, but it seems to be a smooth operation. (If forced to cohabitate with Post-Gazette colleagues, Munch would form a close relationship with the Pittsburgh police.)

On the first trip to the market, Munch purchased a half-pound each of house-made provolone cheese and Boar's Head roast beef for around $7. Munch was a happy camper, both with the price and the food. The deli offerings are high-quality, and the market itself is full of deliciousness: chocolate ricotta cheese, fresh tagliatelli, and many-flavored flatbreads. Those who are looking to cook anywhere upward of a gallon of pasta sauce will find everything they need in bulk. The market also offers fresh produce -- enormous acid-green Hungarian hot peppers, seasonal fruit -- though the ripeness of all the fruit hovered around "dubious." The market undoubtedly will see a lot more of Munch, whether the Merante family likes it or not. So will the restaurant.

The dining room at Cucina di Domenica is not big and has only two long family-style tables. No one seemed to be sitting very close to one another. But the food is more than enough to take your mind off a neighbor's straying elbows. Plus, it's BYOB.

Aside from sandwiches and the obligatory spaghetti and meatballs, Cucina di Domenica offers up pasta for an entire family. Every weekday, Merante's also offers different special meals, most of which sound drool-worthy (Munch is looking at you, Friday's baked bechamel macaroni and cheese). But the family-style fare will leave your wallet lighter -- by $50 to $60 for six people and more than $100 for 12. With meals as basic as Monday's roasted chicken and potatoes and Thursday's Italian meatloaf, Munch would rather cook at home.

Advertise with us

Munch and Co. ordered a 10-inch wood-fired pizza with mushrooms and onions ($13.50), and two sandwiches: Uncle Sal's hot sausage sandwich with fresh mozzarella and the Three Brothers, a pile of roasted vegetables and feta cheese on focaccia ($10.99 each).

History Lover Friend of Munch went wild over the Three Brothers and kept asking, "What do they do to this? Why is it so smoky?" HLFOM was not crazy about the pizza, however, and thought that the sauce was far too sweet.

Faux Relative of Munch liked the pizza and raved about the thin, crispy crust. FROM found the hot sausage too hot, but conceded that it was flavorful.

Irreverent Friend of Munch liked absolutely everything, and argued that one cannot discriminate against a hot sausage for living up to its name. Having previously dined the night before at a nearby Italian eatery, IFOM announced that eating at Merante's was far preferable and that the food was above and beyond better.

The hot sausage surprised Munch in that it started out merely piquant and then smacked Munch over the head with astonishing back-burn that could have come from the mouth of a Game of Thrones dragon. Munch couldn't eat more than one little bite at a time, and that is not how a sandwich is meant to be eaten. Munch agreed with HLFOM that the roasted veggies on the Three Brothers sandwich were delicious: lightly dressed so they didn't turn the focaccia into a soggy mess, but could have been cooked a little less. Munch prefers crunch. The feta cheese topping was skimpy, but overall a quality sandwich.

Advertise with us

The next morning, Munch and Co. went to Caffe d'Antonio for a spot of caffeine. HLFOM declared her hot chocolate, "one of the best" she'd ever tasted, but the girl behind the counter got confused by Munch's medium-size bold coffee, instead proffering a small house. When the right coffee came, quickly and with an apology, it was far from bold. We passed on the pastries, which looked dejected, but while the coffee was brewing, our noses perked up as a breakfast pizza made its way into the cafe -- fried eggs and mozzarella on a crunchy crust.

Munch would also like someone to point out where this breakfast pizza is on the menu. Now. Or Sunday, preferably.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.