Kids dream about becoming lots of different things when they grow up — doctors, teachers, professional athletes, maybe even an astronaut if they’re good at math and science and can stay calm in stressful situations.

Liz Rullo, 26, set her sights on something a little more ... tasty.

When she was a little girl in Greensburg, her heart was set on someday hosting a TV show in which she would travel across the U.S. so she could try every french fry in America.

On Saturday, the University of Pittsburgh grad  — who instead became a nuclear submarine officer in the Navy — got a taste of what that life might have entailed as one of five contestants (and the sole female) in Kennywood Park’s first-ever Potato Patch french fry eating contest.

Advertise with us

The competition, which was staged in the shadow of the Thunderbolt on the Kennyville Stage, had a fairly straightforward goal: to see who could eat a regular order of the park’s iconic cheese-covered fries the fastest without throwing up.

Considering a serving of the fried potatoes weighs in at just a little over 2 pounds, and all the contestants were new to the sport of competitive eating, the circuitous affair was about getting to the finish without losing their lunches.

Rullo, who secured her seat at the table upon another entrant’s last-minute withdrawal, and her fellow contestants could eat the fries any way they wished. Most quickly put down the park-provided plastic fork in favor of using their fingers. They took sips of water between bites to make them easier to swallow; an ability to suppress their gag reflex also helped.

Greensburg native Liz Rullo, a Navy submarine officer stationed in Honolulu, Hawaii, looks up at her cheering family while competing in the Potato Patch Fries Eating Contest.(Sebastian Foltz/Post-Gazette)

Rules required the competitors, who signed up at the park that day, to swallow every fry, said senior entertainment and event supervisor Aliya Pimental as she prepared for the event. “So we’ll be watching mouths very closely and carefully” to see who can finish without heaving.

As show host Topher Ferry introduced the contestants to the crowd, a gust of wind from an approaching rainstorm blew napkins off the table, leading park employees to tape down the tablecloth. As they grabbed several plastic-lined vomit buckets to keep them from being swept away, he quipped: “The EMS crew is here. Contestants, are you ready?”

Advertise with us

Then “five, four, three, two, one, EAT,”  boomed over the microphone and those gathered for the show erupted in cheers.

A race to the finish

Matt Christy from Butler got off to an early lead as KC and the Sunshine Band’s “I’m Your Boogie Man” blared over the loudspeaker. But within minutes Dan Pyle, a bear of a man from Shanksville, Somerset County, was coming on strong.

“But Liz is not letting them get ahead. She is focused, ” Ferry shouted to the crowd.

Then, as he noticed the contestant from Rochester, N.Y., start to struggle, he added, “Make sure to chew properly here today at Kennywood. Don’t panic, just chew.”

All involved slowed down mid-race as the cheese started to cover their fingers in a blanket of gooey orange, prompting Ferry to quip, “Our vomit buckets are for the audience as well. If you feel a little sick here ... we’ve got you covered.”

Advertise with us

Pyle ended up winning the contest, closing out on his tray of fries in a neck-and-neck finish at 5 minutes flat, without a single sip of water. Rullo, who tied her hair up into a top knot to keep it out of her face and bounced along with the music as she ate (and ate and ate), followed a few minutes later after second-place winner Michael Annibaldi of Steubenville, Ohio.

“Did you see how big that guy is?” she said of the winner upon her third-place finish. Then Rullo gave her mother, Cherie, and brother, Jack, joyful hugs. “This is awesome!”

How awesome? “She already ate an order before the contest,” her mom pointed out with a laugh.

“And I hate cheese,” Rullo added. “I didn’t know it was going to be on it!”

Pyle, 47, walked away with two 2026 Gold Season Passes.

Advertise with us

“It was easy,” he said about winning his first-ever eating contest without a single wave of nausea. “I’m going to go ride the Phantom.”

Second-place finisher Annibaldi — who was on his 17th visit to the park this year and proposed to fiance Ashlei Solvey in front of the park’s iconic windmill on May 3 — received four “any day” tickets this year.

The Steubenville resident admits it was hard “trying to swallow” as he methodically shoveled fry after fry into his mouth with a plastic fork (He never raised his head off the table!) but when you love Potato Patch fries as much as he does, you get the job done.

“If he doesn’t get them [on a visit], he gets so upset!” said Solvey.

A longtime crowd favorite

The long, skinny fries hand-cut from premium Idaho potatoes have been a park favorite since their introduction more than 50 years ago. To put that into perspective: The Potato Patch is actually a year older than the park’s mascot Kenny Kangaroo, and also its first million-dollar ride, Log Jammer.

Advertise with us

Not that fries were new in 1973, when The Potato Patch made its debut, said Brian Butko, author of “Kennywood: Behind the Screams” and director of publications at the Sen. John Heinz History Center in the Strip District.

“They sold fries at the snack bar at the pool entrance until 1965,” before the refreshment stand that now houses The Golden Nugget was built.

The Potato Patch stands where a display case that held one of a British artist Rowland Emett’s kinetic sculptures once wowed park guests.

Ava Christy, 8, of Butler, center, and her family cheer on her father, Matt Christy, in the Potato Patch Fries Eating Contest.(Sebastian Foltz/Post-Gazette)

Known for his larger than life whimsical machines — he created the contraptions for the “Chitty Chitty Bang Bang” flying car — his sculpture was a big deal for the park, Butko said, until it wasn’t. So in 1972, park officials decided to turn it into a fried chicken stand. But somewhere along the way the idea came up that, because the snack stand that stood by the pool would be closing, it would be smarter to do french fries.

“And like a lot of Pittsburgh things, it was popular right away,  like Klondike bars, which you could only get at Isaly’s at first,” Butko said.

Advertise with us

Yet it wasn’t until the growing popularity of amusement park books in the ’90s and rise of the internet that Potato Patch fries achieved icon status.

These days, they’re so woven into the fabric of Pittsburgh that when the park tried to change the recipe for the melted cheese that sauces the legendary fries (on the DL) in May 2019, chaos ensued. Officials had to quickly backtrack with a statement on Twitter.

“Consider the YINZvestigation closed,” it read. “Kennywood’s Potato Patch will revert back to its traditional cheese sauce. Thank you for your feedback and passion; we wouldn’t be here without it.”

What makes them special, said Butko, is that they’re cut large, “so they rise beyond a quickie snack into almost a meal. It could be your lunch.... You tend to sit [to eat] because it’s hard to walk around with them.”

While officials did not disclose current numbers, in 2016 the park was using an average of 4 tons of potatoes per day, Butko said. They arrive on pallets at the park every day but Sunday.

Advertise with us

To beat the long lines that are inevitable on a busy day at Kennywood, he shares a secret: They’re also sold at a small stand in Lost Kennywood, “and they are usually just as good and there’s usually no line.”

As for the other contests that book-ended the Potato Patch throwdown? David Devin of McKees Rocks won the hot dog eating contest on Friday night, downing 12 dogs in 23 minutes. James Kimbrough took top honors in a funnel cake eating contest that followed on Sunday.