"Firesides of future generations are sure to be thrilled by grandfather's story of how his paternal ancestor 'just missed it.' " So proclaimed the Milwaukee Journal in April 1912 in an article recounting the providential events of some 3,482 Americans who had canceled or missed bookings on the ill-fated maiden voyage of the R.M.S. Titanic.

Whether it was due to injury, superstition or business delays, the so-called "Just Missed It Club" included many prominent Americans -- titans of the Gilded Age who were saved by serendipity.

Perhaps the earliest member of this elite club was Henry Clay Frick, the Pittsburgh coke and steel baron turned art collector. Frick and his wife, Adelaide, had been in Africa and Europe for some months touring, purchasing artwork and engaging staff members for their New York City mansion. The Fricks booked passage aboard Titanic, only to cancel in light of a minor injury: Mrs. Frick had sprained her ankle while on a cruise in southern Europe, causing the couple to remain in Europe to seek medical attention.

This "providential injury" not only rescued Mrs. Frick and her husband; it also saved perhaps the most famous French chef of the period, Joseph Donon. Mr. Frick had hired the chef as part of his household staff and had booked passage for him to return with the couple to the United States. Donon went on to be the celebrated chef to Florence Vanderbilt Twombly, a granddaughter of Cornelius Vanderbilt.

Advertise with us

The Fricks later sailed home aboard Lusitania, receiving congratulatory letters from friends such as former Attorney General Philander Knox on the "lucky circumstance that you gave up your sailing on the Titanic."

Indeed, the Fricks' suite, reported by some sources to have included rooms B-52, 54 and 56, appears to have been lucky: all individuals who booked it managed to survive the disaster. The suite, complete with private promenade, was situated on the port side of the ship. Some sources indicate that it had been designed especially for John Pierpont Morgan, the head of the International Mercantile Marine, parent company of White Star Line that owned Titanic.

Morgan, the financial mastermind behind the creation of General Electric and the U.S. Steel Corp., is said to have been the next individual to book suite B-52. Some biographers indicate that Morgan never planned to sail on Titanic's maiden voyage because of his distaste "for photographers and reporters who would swarm aboard at Southampton," but others insist that he took over Frick's original booking.

It is certain that he attended the launch in Belfast of Titanic in 1911 in his capacity as head of the IMM. Whether Morgan intended to sail aboard the ship or not, he was saved from a watery fate when the business of his art collection delayed him in Britain. Morgan had been abroad overseeing the moving of his vast collections of fine and decorative arts from Britain, where he had been storing them for tax reasons, to the United States. Morgan stayed behind when he was given the opportunity to view and purchase a rare set of medieval tapestries outside Chartres, France. He telegraphed, "Business will deny me the pleasure of being one of the first to cross on the finest vessel of the IMM."

Had Morgan used Titanic to ship his art treasures -- he insisted on using exclusively White Star Line ships for personal and business affairs -- the world could have been deprived of such masterworks as those in the Fragonard Room, now part of the Frick Collection in New York City.

Advertise with us

The twice-jilted suite B-52 was subsequently engaged by banker and Long Island beautification advocate J. Horace Harding and his wife, who had toured Egypt with the Fricks. The couple managed to book an earlier trip back to the U.S. aboard Mauretania. Harding, who was also a financier-turned-art collector, reported to The New York Herald that Mr. Frick had purchased "two important pictures, including two examples of Paolo Veronese" during their trip.

Some historians believe that the now-empty suite was finally occupied by J. Bruce Ismay, IMM president. Amid the chaos during Titanic's final hours, Ismay jumped into a lifeboat, surviving the disaster and arriving home to widespread public criticism. Ismay was villainized in the press ("J. Brute Ismay") on both sides of the Atlantic for depriving women and children of spaces on the few available lifeboats.

The tardiness of a colleague saved Robert Bacon, the American ambassador to France during the Taft administration. Bacon, who had assisted Morgan with the formation of U.S. Steel and the IMM, among other efforts, had resigned his ambassadorship to become a fellow of Harvard University. "The service of higher education must be honorable when it can tempt a man to exchange an American ambassadorship for a university trusteeship," the editors of The Harvard Crimson wrote in February 1912.

Lucky for Bacon, his successor, former Ohio Gov. Myron T. Herrick, arrived late in assuming his post. Bacon reluctantly canceled his passage aboard Titanic to assist in the transition to Herrick's ambassadorship. The cancellation saved not only Bacon's life, but that of his wife and daughter; the family sailed later that month on the maiden voyage of the S.S. France.

Late arrivals to the "Just Missed It Club" were George Washington Vanderbilt II, owner of the Biltmore Estate, and his wife, Edith Stuyvesant Vanderbilt, who were narrowly saved by pure superstition. News reports stated that Mrs. Vanderbilt's sister, Susan Dresser, vehemently opposed her sister and brother-in-law's trip aboard Titanic, declaring, "The first trip of any ship is dangerous." The Vanderbilts, whose luggage had already been stowed aboard in the care of their footman, Frederic Wheeler, canceled their tickets and rebooked for the Olympic. Their luggage was transferred, but tragically, the footman made the trip anyway, going down with the ship.

Advertise with us

Other contemporaries of the "Just Missed It Club" members were not as lucky. John Jacob Astor II, scion of the legendary furrier and real estate fortune, and Benjamin Guggenheim, brother of art collector Solomon R. Guggenheim, perished in the disaster. Though some wealthy businessmen and their families managed to escape the disaster, it did not prevent them from expressing their sorrow over the loss of life. Shortly after the news of Titanic's sinking broke, J.P. Morgan wired a friend, "... greatly upset by loss Titanic -- my heart ... very heavy."