Checking out an e-book from the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh is easy.

But the issues surrounding library e-books are anything but straightforward.

Two major publishers -- Simon & Schuster and Macmillan -- refuse to allow libraries to lend out e-books.

Publishing giant HarperCollins shocked the library world earlier this year when it announced that after 26 "check-outs" the library would have to purchase the book again. The policy applies to e-books purchased after March 7 of this year.

Advertise with us

The initial reaction was that the HarperCollins policy was "startling and alarming," said Sarah Beasley, coordinator, e-Resources for the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh.

Marilyn Jenkins, executive director of the Allegheny County Library Association, a consortium of 45 local libraries including the Carnegie, agreed.

"In our view, a book is a book is a book, whether it's in print or digital," she said. "When you purchase it, you should own it."

In an open letter to librarians last month, HarperCollins explained its new policy. "We have serious concerns that our previous e-book policy, selling e-books to libraries in perpetuity, if left unchanged, would undermine the emerging e-book eco-system, hurt the growing e-book channel, place additional pressure on physical bookstores, and in the end lead to a decrease in book sales and royalties paid to authors," said HarperCollins' president of sales, Josh Marwell.

In response, the American Library Association released a statement saying that the HarperCollins policy "threatens libraries' ability to provide their users with access to information."

Advertise with us

Other librarians called for a boycott of HarperCollins, with one library system -- Halifax, Nova Scotia -- refusing to buy new HarperCollins e-book licenses.

In theory, the 26 check-out policy for e-books mimics the wear and tear on physical books, which eventually need to be re-purchased and replaced.

"Twenty-six circulations can provide a year of availability for titles with the highest demand," said Mr. Marwell's letter, "and much longer for other titles and core backlist."

But Ms. Jenkins of the Allegheny County Library Association said, "We've had books in our collections for decades. That [26 weeks] seems arbitrary to us."

The Carnegie Library has offered some form of e-books since the early 2000s and downloadable audio and video books since 2005. But it was just in October that it made e-books that are compatible with e-readers (such as the Barnes and Noble Nook or the iPad) available. Library downloads are not compatible with the Kindle, but can be read on laptop and desktop computers and on smartphones.

Advertise with us

The Carnegie library now carries about 2,300 titles for e-readers. "It's just a remarkable growth period for e-books," Ms. Beasley said.

E-books can be checked out and downloaded from home, eliminating the need for a trip to the library. But because of the licensing agreements, e-books can only be checked out to one user at a time.

The Carnegie library will buy new licenses of HarperCollins books (which include bestsellers such as Sarah Palin's "America by Heart" and Justin Halpern's "Sh• t My Dad Says"), though none of the books have reached 26 check-outs yet, Ms. Beasley said.

Despite the negative reactions to the policy in the library world, Ms. Beasley is optimistic that something positive can come of the e-book lending discussions.

Perhaps the HarperCollins model will push the publishers who don't currently allow library e-book licenses to start doing so in some form, she said. And the issue has galvanized librarians in a positive way.

Advertise with us

"Libraries and librarians are really getting more active about having a say and being at the table, being involved in the conversation," she said.

The Carnegie Library offers several resources for people interested in using e-books, she said, including instructional classes and "Gadget Labs" to try out different e-readers.