Reviews are out of four stars.
'Brutal Legend'
3 stars = Good
Rated M for mature.
Jack Black is a metalhead, and no one can silence him.
The comic actor and voice of "Kung Fu Panda" and the legendary game writer/director Tim Schafer have teamed up to grace the Xbox 360 and PS3 with "Brutal Legend," a tribute to all things that make loud noises, create copious amounts of gore and rock out loud.
STORY: Black voices Eddie Riggs, the ultimate loyal roadie. When a freak accident at a concert leaks Eddie's blood into his belt buckle (just go with it), the set becomes violent and kills everyone at the concert. Eddie is then transported to a world where heavy metal is the way of life.
He meets dark-haired vixen Ophelia, her boyfriend Lars Halford, and his sister, Lita. They are fighting against the land's dictatorial ruler, Lord Doviculus (voice of Tim Curry), and his No. 1 minion, General Lionwhyte. Armed with an ax, a magic guitar, an awesome set of wheels (the Deuce) and an army of headbangers, the burden falls on Eddie to save the day and, judging by the commercials, get the girl.
PRESENTATION: The game is laugh-out-loud funny. Between Black's hilariously sarcastic voice performance and Schafer's simultaneous reverence toward and lampooning of metal culture, fans of this genre should be pleased.
You traverse a huge landscape, partake in missions and side missions, and even participate in a few races. Eddie can kill his foes with his ax, lightning or fire provided by his guitar, by running them over with the Deuce or teaming up with his allies, or he can play huge guitar riffs to summon new powers and weapons.
GAMEPLAY: While the core gameplay is fun, it's hampered by a few problems. The controls are sticky, especially when trying to create a mosh pit with your headbanger army. While the game is visually diverse and rich in detail, I'm not a huge fan of the art style. The humans look odd, especially Riggs and his ridiculously huge hands.
CONCLUSION: "Brutal Legend" is a worthy tribute to the metal gods it is trying to appease. Unfortunately, its small issues add up enough to stop this game from becoming an instant classic.
-- Josh Axelrod, for the Post-Gazette
'Saw'
1 star = Awful
Rated M (17 and older).
In 2007 a minor controversy broke out when games-ratings boards in the U.S. and Britain effectively banned the original version of the survival horror game "Manhunt 2." After diving into the gut bucket to examine depictions of human mutilation in "Manhunt 2" and the "Saw II" film, I found that the movie was far more realistic and disturbingly explicit.
Now comes the first "Saw" video game, released by Konami for the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 consoles. (A downloadable Windows version is slated for release later this month.) After spending more than 10 hours in perhaps the most depressing, least redeeming virtual environment I have ever visited, I can report that the "Saw" game proudly represents the franchise established by its big-screen predecessors.
STORY: If being tormented by a crazed killer named Jigsaw as you stumble around a dank, not-so-abandoned old insane asylum filled with freaks and shotgun traps is your idea of a good time, "Saw" is the game for you.
PRESENTATION: "Saw" is far more successful in conveying atmosphere than it is in delivering the intellectual and motor-response engagement of a fine game.
But does the game really qualify as "torture porn," the moniker attached to films such as "Hostel," "Saw" and their sequels? Not really. When it comes to watching people writhe and howl in agony as they die in gruesome ways, Hollywood special-effects wizards are still far more advanced than digital-game technologies.
Zombie Studios also seems to understand that with the power of interactivity comes responsibilities. As gory as it may be, the game seems to exhibit a modicum of restraint.
GAMEPLAY: From a game-play perspective "Saw" isn't horrible, but it is not particularly interesting in more than a few spots. There are a handful of puzzle types, like lock picking and circuit rewiring, that are repeated over and over. And how many shotgun traps must one man disarm? Dozens? Hundreds?
Moreover, there may not have been a clumsier, less-responsive combat system in a major game in the past year. Every swing of a baseball bat, pipe or mannequin arm feels as if it is being forced through molasses.
CONCLUSION: The "Saw" mythos is about being forced to choose among competing bleak alternatives. So it is fitting that this grimmest of games includes two endings. It is also fitting that neither is at all happy.
For some folks, that's entertainment.
-- Seth Schiesel, New York Times News Service
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.