Whether kids can get addicted to video games has been debated since Space Invaders first blipped its way into neighborhood arcades.
But a new national study has found that some kids do get addicted, and to the point that they can be classified as "pathological" gamers who display traits similar to those of gambling addicts.
The study of youngsters ages 8 to 18 by the National Institute on Media and the Family and Iowa State University shows that 8.5 percent of those surveyed were classified as "pathological" gamers. Among the common traits they described: lying to family and friends about their video game usage, using games as an escape from problems, skipping household chores or homework in order to play, restlessness or irritability when they stopped playing and poor performance at school.
The study defines addiction as more than repetitive behavior, as something that impairs or damages functioning on several levels, including family, school, socially and psychologically.
"While the medical community currently does not recognize video game addiction as a mental disorder, hopefully this study will be one of many that will allow us to have an educated conversation on the positive and negative effects of video games," said Douglas Gentile, an assistant professor of psychology at Iowa State and lead author of the study.
The nationwide survey included 1,178 children between the ages 8 and 18, using data collected in a 2007 Harris Interactive Poll.
David Walsh, president of the National Institute on Media and the Family, acknowledged that it's still a minority of kids who have problems.
"We're certainly not suggesting that all kids who play video games play too much," Dr. Walsh said. "Although it's less than one out of 10 kids, it's still a significant enough number that parents should be paying attention. There are kids whose game play becomes more than an enjoyable pastime."
The so-called pathological gamers spent 24.6 hours a week playing games. The less frequent gamers played 11.8 hours a week. Twice as many kids in the pathological group had been diagnosed with attention deficit or hyperactivity disorders. More of the frequent players had a game system in their bedrooms (64.4 percent, compared to 40.8 percent).
Walsh says parents can be the first line of defense. "Make sure that they have rules about how much kids can play before the problem gets out of hand."
Drew Davidson is director of the Entertainment Technology Center at Carnegie Mellon University, where graduate students create video games and other forms of digital entertainment. He says it's one of the more credible studies he's seen on the issue, since its aim is to point to the potential for addictive behavior among young game enthusiasts.
He says it's an issue that academics and game developers wrestle with, as much as concerned parents do.
"A really well designed game is created to be a compelling experience, just like when you get into a book that you like. The next thing you know it's 2 a.m. and you've got to get to the next chapter to find out what happens.
"Developers talk about it a lot in terms of ethics. As developers, it's our job to make a fun game. If we make a really fun game that's a 100 hours long, if you get engrossed in that, it can lead to lots of time.
"It's a business. You need it to make a profit, but at the same time you want to make something that's not having negative effects," Dr. Davidson said.
"What's nice about this is it opens up opportunity to discuss and raise awareness, as opposed to overreacting."
There have been other studies on games and addictive behavior, although the National Institute of Media study is described as the first to draw on a national sample of respondents. Others have explored whether violent games cause violent behavior, and whether they encourage anti-social behavior.
One study released in September 2008 challenged the latter assumption. A Pew Internet & American Life Project survey of a similar group (1,100 kids age 7- 17) found that those who played frequently were as socially engaged as less active gamers, and found that many games promote positive social behavior.
Like the Pew study, this one challenges the stereotype of the lone gamer shut in his or her room, isolated from others and obsessed with game play. The problem of addictive play was more common among online gamers, who play with others, often in competitive teams. "The team mission becomes very important. Those games never end. They're always going on," Walsh said. "They're much more likely to lose track of time."
The National Institute on Media and the Family was founded to monitor the effects of media on children's health and development. The organization is also offering a parents guide on its Web site that outlines symptoms of video game addiction and prevention.
The bottom line, said Dr. Davidson, is balance.
When Super Mario creator Shigeru Miyamoto would give a talk to groups of kids, he would end this way: "Go outside and play."
Dr. Davidson says that's the healthy approach: "Video games are great, and you should also do other stuff, too."
The National Institute of Mediastudy will be published in the May issue of Psychological Science, which is the journal of the Association for Psychological Science. To read the full study, go to drdouglas.org.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.