Reviews are out of four stars.
'MLB 09: The Show'
3 1/2 stars = Very good
Dustin Pedroia, last year's American League MVP, gets called "scrappy" a lot, meaning he's the kind of player who's always hustling. He's an appropriate cover boy for Sony's baseball franchise, which has scrambled for respect but emerged last year as the best in the game.
Sony hasn't made any substantial changes with this year's model, opting mainly to tweak last year's successful production. Graphically, "The Show" (Sony, for the PlayStation 3, $59.99; PlayStation Portable, $39.99; PlayStation 2, $29.99) keeps edging closer to broadcast quality, with realistic lighting, accurate player models and even dancing mascots. And gameplay is just a bit more lifelike; computer-controlled fielders, for example, aren't quite as perfect as they once were.
Away from the pennant race, the main addition is a training mode that lets you work on your batting and base-running skills. The drills are part of "Road to the Show," in which you build a player from scratch and work your way up from single-A to the majors. It remains the most addictive career mode of any sports game -- in many ways, more satisfying than the team game.
'Major League Baseball 2K9'
1 star = Awful
Cy Young winner Tim Lincecum is on the cover of "2K9" (2K Sports, for the Xbox 360, $59.99; Nintendo Wii, $49.99; PlayStation Portable, $29.99; PlayStation 2, $19.99), but the game itself is a balk. It feels incomplete, probably because a different studio has taken over development of the franchise since the poorly received "2K8."
The most noticeable issue is its flaky artificial intelligence; computer-controlled fielders show laughably bad judgment. Hitting homers is much too easy, with games usually devolving into double-digit slugfests. It's fun for casual play, but real baseball fans will get bored.
Graphics and audio feel unfinished as well. Most of the players look like partially melted dolls, and the soundtrack is just awful. Could we please have a moratorium on the Romantics' "What I Like About You"?
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.