Valentine's Day is supposed to be about love, although you might not find it through the price-gouging by florists, cloying commercials for diamonds and jam-packed restaurants that form the hallmarks of the holiday.

You might find it, instead, in a place where you wouldn't think to look: the death notices.

Those involved with hospices, funerals and burial can see true love in something that happens surprisingly often: One member of a longtime couple dies, to be followed almost immediately by the other.

Just recently, Victor E. Satter, 78, of Library, purchased a Valentine's Day card for his 79-year-old wife, Dorothy.

Advertise with us

That card sits undelivered. Early Sunday morning, less than two days after Dorothy died at their home after complications from a stroke, Mr. Satter passed away in his sleep.

Mr. Satter had been diagnosed with colon cancer less than two weeks ago, and doctors had said he had about six months to live.

But for his family, the timing of his death brought to mind words that he said as he cared for his wife of 57 years after multiple strokes.

"My dad had always said when he was taking care of mom that he wanted to live one day longer than she did," said Victor P. Satter, of South Park, oldest of the Satters' six children.

The belief that some couples are so close that their deaths coincide has not been borne out in the few scientific studies conducted on the subject. But cases of long-married couples who die within hours or days of each other are not hard to find.

Advertise with us

"I would say it probably happens more than one might imagine," said Allegheny Cemetery President Tom Roberts, who estimated that he sees families in which two members have died in close proximity several times a year.

"We've had occasions where we've been notified of a death, then within a day or two, we get notice that spouse has died, whether because of trauma or something else that triggers it," he said. Another fairly common scenario is the death of an elderly parent immediately after the death of an adult child.

Several funeral directors gave the same story, and a review of Pittsburgh Post-Gazette death notices and obituaries indicates there are several cases every year.

Just after Valentine's Day last year, Regis and Anna Mae Kroll died the same day after 63 years of marriage.

Anna Mae, 84, had been diagnosed with lung cancer; Regis, 87, had been healthy until he came down with the flu shortly after his wife began receiving hospice services. On Feb. 18, they both died at home.

Advertise with us

Bonnie Tolan, then a visiting nurse for Heartland Hospice in Green Tree, was struck by the couple immediately upon meeting them.

"She was a sweet lady. And you could tell he was just totally crazy about her," she said. "The family said he must have died of a broken heart, as soon as he knew she wasn't doing very well."

In 1996, Betty Mihalyi died of cancer in her Bridgeville home June 5. Her husband, Ernest, died the next day of congestive heart failure, also in the home they'd shared for the 45 years of their marriage.

"I remember it was less than 24 hours," said Mark Bronczyk, supervisor at Laughlin Memorial Chapel in Castle Shannon. "I went to pick up his wife. I shook his hand and everything. When I got the call the next morning, I was very surprised. I just feel he died of a broken heart."

There is no research to support the idea that a person could in some way control the timing of his or her death and thus "choose" to die after a beloved partner or other family member does.

Advertise with us

The authors of a review of research on the question of whether people can hasten or delay their deaths said that while there were some "tantalizing possibilities" raised by some studies, there was no solid evidence.

"In hospitals and many places where death is not uncommon, it's not unusual for family and staff to hold these types of beliefs," said Kenneth E. Freedland, professor of psychiatry at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis and co-author of "Death Takes a Raincheck," an article in Psychosomatic Medicine. "They believe that people die in twos, or threes. When a fourth death comes along, they say, 'We're starting a new cycle.' "

Similarly, people ignore the many long-married couples who do not die at the same time and focus on those who do.

"I've worked in hospitals since I was about 16 years old, and I've seen that people in medicine have a lot of very strongly held beliefs, like the idea that certain people hang on," said Judith A. Skala, a research instructor in psychiatry at Washington University and lead author of the article. "But none of the studies have convincingly established that the time of death can be postponed through force of will or hastened by loss of the desire to live."

Dr. Freedland does not discount the possibility that there is something more than coincidence at work. He simply doesn't think there is scientific evidence for it. He has been working on a long-term study of the impact of depression on the life expectancy of heart disease patients, where a strong correlation has been found.

Advertise with us

The answer to the question of "whether there are psychological or psychiatric factors that are risk factors for mortality" seems to be yes, he said.

"If you have major depression after a heart attack, your risk of dying within the next couple of years is higher," he said. The fact that depression can clearly affect mortality makes him open to the idea that the shock of a death could hasten death.

Further, new research on the effect of sudden shocks on the hearts of some patients suggests that the impact of the death of a beloved partner could trigger a life-ending sequence of events.

Researchers at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine this month published results of a study that indicated that a sudden shock can unleash a flood of adrenaline and other stress hormones that can stun the heart, causing a life-threatening spasm in some.

This "stress cardiomyopathy" described in the New England Journal of Medicine resembles a classic heart attack and probably often is mistaken for one, the researchers said.

Advertise with us

Ilan Wittstein, a cardiologist and assistant professor of medicine at Johns Hopkins, studied patients with no history of heart problems who had experienced shocks that ranged from the death of a family member to a surprise party.

When he compared them with heart attack victims, he found they had healthy, unclogged arteries but that levels of stress hormones in their blood, such as adrenaline, were two to three times higher than in the heart attack victims, and 34 times higher than normal. Dr. Wittstein concluded that the massive amounts of stress hormones go right to the heart and stun it, causing a temporary dysfunction that resembles a heart attack.

"I think this ties in" to the phenomenon of spouses or family members dying within short periods of time, Dr. Wittstein said.

Dr. Wittstein believes stress hormones may play a role in deaths that occur weeks or months after the death of a loved one as well as those that occur immediately. Since grief also results in stress, the hormones continue to be released.

"Cortisol, another stress hormone, has a suppressive effect on the immune system." That could make the system more prone to arrhythmias and real heart attacks, he said.

Advertise with us

Other than such a heart event resulting from shock, it's not clear how the death of a beloved partner could affect timing of death.

"There's nothing in the literature showing actual research on it. It's hard, therefore, to draw any strong conclusion," said Dana Cable, a professor of psychology at Hood College, which offers one of the nation's few master's degree programs in thanatology, the study of death and bereavement. "Frequently, you hear a person say, 'I won't live if anything happens to him or her.' And frequently, that happens. Several times a year, we see couples who die within a short time of one another. Some couples are so interdependent."