Punch works year round — milk punch in the summer, sangria in the spring — but for my money, it works best in those cold-weather months. Holidays mean entertaining, and what’s more entertaining than a communal punch bowl, spiked with booze?

Well, maybe Ali-Frazier I. I’m told that was very entertaining. But in the realm of spirited drinks, you have to hand it to a well-crafted punch. Like seemingly all historic imbibing trends, punch is seeing something of a revival these days, partly because art-house tippling spots with elaborate mise en place systems have discovered that pre-made, large-batch punches save time when the bartenders are otherwise tied up making 10-minute mixed drinks. (It’s the same thinking behind the barreled cocktail, the draft cocktail, the pre-bottled cocktail, and whatever other iterations might next emerge out of the fashionable Portland and New York bar scenes.)

And yet when compared to your garden-variety pre-made cocktail, punch is something different, something with real-time craftsmanship, something more regal. Pittsburgh-born spirits historian David Wondrich, in his 2010 book “Punch: The Delights (and Dangers) of the Flowing Bowl” (Perigree Trade, 320 pages), calls punch “the monarch of mixed drinks,” tracing its lineage back to perhaps the 1600s, perhaps before, because who really knows with these things?

“Nobody can say precisely when, where or by whom punch was invented,” Mr. Wondrich writes. “That is in fact the default position for popular mixed drinks in general; few of them indeed can produce their birth certificates.”

Advertise with us

True enough, though we know that English sailors were drinking punch five centuries ago. Beer spoiled on months-long seafaring voyages, and so the English made do with ingredients they could salvage from India and Indonesia, allowing them to stretch their rum rations. The word punch is said to have Indian roots: The Hindi word for five, panch, eventually became “punch,” so named because punch was meant to be a blend of five ingredients: tea, water, sugar, lemon juice and spiced arrack (a dark rum-like spirit made from palm sap). More broadly, every punch needs five essential tastes — strong, weak, bitter, sour and sweet.

Or, perhaps not: There’s also the possibility that “punch” came from“puncheon,” a barrel or cask meant for holding liquids, from the Old French ponchon (“wine vessel”), which dates to the 1200s and would precede punch as we know it by a few hundred years.

Well, whatever. Are we here to talk etymology or talk punch? More and more bars are adding “punch programs” (I know, I know — it sounds even sillier than a “cocktail program,” but these are the times we are living in), and you know a potion’s moment has arrived when there is a bar dedicated to it: In Chicago, they’ve just opened the Punch House, with eight or nine punches on the menu regularly. New York City of course boasts several, including Death & Company (East Village) and The Clover Club.  And on San Francisco’s neo-vintage Haight Street, Hobson’s Choice advertises itself as a “Victorian punch house.”

Interestingly (if you’ve made it this far), Mr. Wondrich would argue that punch was passe by the Victorian era. The Queen thought getting smashed on punch (and wine, and anything else) wasn’t gentlemanly business, and frowned upon the practice. The industrial age was by then underway, long hours were the norm, and Britain was a place of refined, conservative sensibilities and, sadly, increasing temperance.

“Punch was fading,” he said in a phone interview last month. But from “the 1680s to the 1830s, it was the king of drinks. After dinner, the punch would come out,” and the party would begin.

Advertise with us

Punch and cocktails are different animals, with the former not intended to be a full-strength drink. “The classic punches were about the strength of sherry,” and very much meant to be served in those small punch glasses, so as to avoid (or at least delay) inebriation, and to encourage refills.

The result is “this crowd around the punch bowl, flowing in and out ... it becomes very jolly,” and it helps explain why punch parties were so popular for so long. Today, certainly among cocktail fiends, a punch party might seem somewhat anachronistic, even inhospitable, in that you’re telling guests that your home bar — where you keep all the nice bourbons and Scotches — is off limits. But eventually, Mr. Wondrich said, it becomes a “communal experience.”

And it’s why cocktail bars are reexamining the punch. Some states allow an entire punch bowl to be brought to your table, others (such as Pennsylvania) ladle out individual servings upon request. “Large parties are a problem for the modern cocktail bar,” Mr. Wondrich said, because craft cocktails take so long to make. Punches are an ideal way of satisfying those big bar crowds, and are more pleasing to the eye than pre-bottled or pre-barreled cocktails.

“I always find those a little disappointing,” he said. “I want to see the bartender make my drink.”

Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625 and on Twitter @btoland_PG.

Advertise with us

Fish House punch

Also called Philadelphia Fish House punch. It’s an American classic, said to be a favorite of George Washington, and said to have originated at a social and angling club called State in Schuylkill Fishing Corporation. Nickname: The Fish House. 

750-milliliter bottle chilled dark rum

750-milliliter bottle chilled light rum

750-milliter bottle chilled brandy

Advertise with us

8 ounces peach brandy

6 ounces simple syrup

24 ounces fresh lemon juice

1 large block ice

2 liters club soda

Advertise with us

Garnishes: 1 orange, sliced; 1 lemon, sliced; 4 to 6 mint sprigs

Pour all the liquid ingredients into a punch bowl, except for the club soda. Just before serving, add the block of ice and pour in the club soda. Float the citrus slices and mint sprigs on top.

— “The Ultimate Bar Book” by Mittie Hellmich (Chronicle, 2006)

■

Eggnog

Advertise with us

PG tested

Also historically known as the “egg milk punch,” according to Mr. Wondrich. I’ve seen this version called “South American” eggnog, because of the lime zest and the rum (rather than bourbon or brandy) as a base spirit. This recipe comes by way of Acacia, the cocktail house in Pittsburgh’s South Side.  

12 eggs, beaten

6 12-ounce cans evaporated milk

3 14-ounce cans sweetened condensed milk

Advertise with us

Zest of 2 limes

1 grated nutmeg

1 liter gold rum

1 block ice

After beating the eggs, mix eggs, evaporated milk and condensed milk into the punch bowl. Top with lime zest and nutmeg and then, before serving, add rum and the ice block. Tip: If you can’t find a whole nutmeg, 1 grated nutmeg is equal to 2 or 3 teaspoons of powdered nutmeg spice.

Advertise with us

— Acacia

■

Bombay government punch

This recipe comes from Mr. Wondrich’s punch book: “For a more stimulating concoction,” he says, use 2 quarts of cold black or green tea in place of the 2 quarts of water, which would require about 8 tea bags. He recommends a rum that is “rich and funky, not smooth and clean.”

2 cups turbinado (raw) sugar

Advertise with us

1 cup water

12 limes

2 750-milliliter bottles Smith & Cross Jamaican Rum (available at PLCB stores)

2 quarts water

Block of ice

Advertise with us

Grated nutmeg

In a pot, stir the sugar into the 1 cup of water over a low stovetop flame until the sugar has dissolved, which takes 5 minutes or so. This creates simple syrup; let it cool. Squeeze 12 limes and combine the juice in a large punch bowl with 12 ounces of the simple syrup, and stir. Add 2 750-milliliter bottles of rum, and top off with 2 quarts water (or the tea). Stir again and refrigerate. Half an hour before serving, add a large block of ice and grate nutmeg over the top. Taste and adjust for sweetness, if necessary, with the additional syrup, Mr. Wondrich says. Serves 20.

— “Punch: The Delights (and Dangers) of the Flowing Bowl” by David Wondrich (Perigee, 2010)

Cranberry Rum Punch

PG tested 

Advertise with us

All great punches, says Will Duncan, beverage manager at Punch House in Chicago, begin with the oleo saccharum, a Latin phrase meaning the “oily sugar.” “Every historic punch recipe begins this way. It's combining sugar with citrus peels,” he told SeriousEats.com last year. That’s where this next spicy autumn punch starts, too. The original Food Network recipe calls for chopped ginger in the syrup, but we've left that out in this version.

4 small “cutie” clementine oranges, zested

4 cinnamon sticks

10 whole cloves

2/3 cup water

Advertise with us

2/3 cup sugar

A few shakes of nutmeg

12-ounce bag fresh cranberries

25 ounces sparkling cider or apple cider, chilled

8 cups cranberry juice cocktail, chilled

Advertise with us

1-liter bottle club soda

4 to 6 cups spiced rum

Zest the clementine rinds, then set the oranges aside. Bring the zest, cinnamon sticks, cloves, water, sugar and nutmeg to a boil in a saucepan. Keep stirring until the sugar has dissolved. Reduce the heat and then simmer, covered, 5 minutes. Remove from the heat and let steep, uncovered, for up to an hour, creating a syrup. (If you already have simple syrup on hand, just use a cup or so of that in place of the water and sugar.) While that's steeping, puncture some holes in the zested oranges and stick whole cloves into the holes. Put the clove-studded oranges and the cranberries in a punch bowl.

After the syrup has steeped, either strain it through a fine-mesh sieve into a bowl, discarding the solids, or pour the pan, cloves and all, into a punch bowl. If you're putting whole cloves into the punch, be sure to warn guests. Combine the remaining ingredients with the spiced syrup in a punch bowl and stir. Add a block of ice before serving. The cranberries and oranges should float to the top of the bowl.

— The Food Network 

Advertise with us

Garrick Club Punch 

Another historic punch, and a gin punch to boot — so it’s no surprise that the recipe is sourced to London’s exclusive Garrick Club, which dates to 1831 and still exists today in the city’s West End. The recipe dates to 1835. 

4 lemons

1/2 cup superfine sugar

1 cup fresh lemon juice, strained

750-milliliter bottle gin

4 ounces Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur or Grand Marnier

24 ounces seltzer water or club soda, chilled

Peel the lemons with a vegetable peeler, avoiding the white pith. Muddle the peels with the sugar in a  punch bowl and let stand for 30 minutes. Add the lemon juice and stir until the sugar has dissolved. Add the gin and Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur or Grand Marnier, and stir. Fill the pitcher or bowl halfway with ice and add the seltzer or club soda. Stir again and serve in individual punch or highball glasses. Note: Several recipes call for an old-style gin. In Pennsylvania, that limits you to Hayman’s Old Tom Gin or Tanqueray Old Tom Gin. You may also want to try a Dutch-style gin, such as Wigle’s organic ginever.

— Garrick Club