The Wine Spectator, America's top-ranked magazine for wine and wine culture, annually produces a list of its top 100 wines released that year.
In a year, the editors typically blind-taste more than 16,000 new releases. To create their Top 100 list, they eliminate any wine scoring less than 90 on a 100-point scale. That leaves more than 5,000 labels that are awarded 90 to 100 points.
To further narrow the list, those editors give points for quality (the numerical score originally awarded the wine), value based on price, availability and what they call the X-factor -- "excitement."
My primary interest in this list is to find which of these wines are available through our archaic state store system in Allegheny County. Of 100 possibilities, seven are stocked in premium stores and six more are available through online ordering or as a special liquor order.
Several others from the list have PLCB codes and are in the system, but are not available in Western Pennsylvania. Others are in PLCB stores in a different vintage or from a different parcel or vineyard.
Other fascinating details for me are the price/quality ratios. The highest scoring wine on the list is Peter Michael's Les Pavots 2008, a Napa Meritage with a price of $175 that fetches 98 points. But price doesn't seem to be totally determined by points. There are five 97-point bottles ranging in price from $45 for Denner, a Rhone-style blend of 95 percent Syrah and 5 percent Viognier from Paso Robles, to $125 for Domaine Serene, an Oregon state Pinot Noir. At 96 points, the prices go from $50 to $150 and, at 95 points, from $35 to $80. What has happened to, "You get what you pay for"?
Wine Spectator Top 100 wines now in our county are:
• No. 32: Andrew Will, Sorella Horse Heaven Hills, 2008, Washington state.
PLCB No. 28214, $59.99, 95 points.
A blend of 80 percent Cabernet Sauvignon with Cabernet Franc and Merlot providing the remaining grapes.
• No. 36: Terrabianca Tuscana Campaccio, 2007, Italy.
PLCB No. 38009, $28.99, 93 points.
Made from 70 percent Sangiovese and 30 percent Cabernet Sauvignon that were grown in Chianti and the Maremma districts of Tuscany.
• No. 62: Quinto do Crasto Douro Reserva Old Vines, 2008, Portugal.
PLCB No. 17789, $41.49, 93 points.
A blend of up to 30 grape varieties grown on estate vineyards with vines at least 70 years old. There are only 12 bottles in the county and all are in Robinson.
• No. 65: Shafer Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch, 2009, Napa.
PLCB No. 23369, $48.99, 93 points.
This vineyard gets its name from the hawk species that protects the grapes from pests.
• No. 78: Markus Molitor Riesling Spatlese, 2009, Mosel, Germany.
PLCB No. 24379, $36.99, 93 points.
A top site in Wehlener Sonnenuhr, this winery has been in the family for eight generations. Some vines in these vineyards are 80 years old and ungrafted.
• No. 82: Margerum Sauvignon Blanc, 2010, Santa Barbara, Calif.
PLCB No. 18555, $21.99, 91 points.
A small and new viticultural region (AVA) named Happy Canyon is producing a stylish Sauvignon Blanc.
• No. 88: Nicolis Amarone, 2004, Valpolicella, Italy.
PLCB No. 24489, $47.99, 94 points.
Seventy percent Corvina and 20 percent Rondinella and Croatina grapes go into this rich red made from the ripasso technique, which dries some of the grapes before fermentation.
Wines available by special liquor order are:
• No. 4: Campogiovanni Brunello di Montalcino, 2006, Tuscany, Italy.
PLCB No. 71019, $53.99, 96 points.
Aged three years in large oak barrels and one year in bottle before release.
• No. 40: Beringer Chardonnay Private Reserve, 2009, Napa, Calif.
PLCB No. 514251, $36.49, 93 points.
Long recognized as an outstanding California Chardonnay, following the model of white Burgundies that are barrel-fermented.
• No. 41: L'Ecole No. 41 Cabernet Sauvignon, 2008, Washington state.
PLCB No. 514251, $36.49, 93 points.
An entry-level Cabernet from a great vintage is impressive and densely layered.
• No. 58: Catena Zapato Malbec, 2009, Mendoza, Argentina.
PLCB No. 515016, $24.99, 91 points.
This is another entry-level red, scoring high points for a rich expression of Malbec character.
• No. 60: Allegrini Veronese, 2008, Veneto, Italy.
PLCB No. 517517, $21.99, 90 points.
A blend of 70 percent Corvina and 25 percent Rondinella grapes, with a dash of Sangiovese, this wine is distinctive in that a third of the grapes were dried before pressing and fermentation gave added intensity and complexity to the wine.
• No. 93: Domaine Monardiere Chenin Blanc, 2009, South Africa.
PLCB No. 515423, $27.39, 91 points.
An intense chenin that was fermented in oak barrels with ambient yeasts and aged in oak for nine months.
The next Tastings column will look at which of the Wine Spectator's 100 Outstanding Values of the Year are available in our region.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.