If you've ever purchased an item with a serial number on it, did you check to see if it matched the serial number of the container it came in?
Me neither.
Marian Rock said it's a good idea to do so.
Rock, a native of Meyersdale in southern Somerset County, received a Samsung digital camera for her 45th birthday on March 9. Her father, Leonard Rock, a retired physician, bought it at the Wal-Mart store in Somerset and delivered it to her home in Westhampton, N.J., about halfway between Philadelphia and Atlantic City.
Unfortunately, the $150 camera didn't work.
Couldn't even be turned on.
Her husband, Arthur Pershing, tried new batteries. The camera still didn't work. He called Samsung. A customer service representative suggested some trouble-shooting techniques. Pershing tried them. No luck.
He was told to take it back to any Wal-Mart.
The couple drove to the closest one, a new Super Wal-Mart a few minutes away in Delran, N.J.
A clerk said he couldn't take the camera back because the serial numbers didn't match. He also noted the camera hadn't been purchased there.
Pershing said Samsung had told him it would accept it.
The clerk refused to accept the camera and give them a refund.
When Rock and Pershing drove to Meyersdale for Easter, they went to the Wal-Mart store where the camera had been purchased.
"I don't return anything without my husband because they give me the 'dumb-stupid-woman routine,' " Rock said.
She went to the camera department and asked for the manager. A clerk said he wasn't available. When she insisted on speaking to him, she was told he wasn't in the store.
She asked for the store manager. Not available, the clerk said.
Rock explained the camera's shortcoming. The clerk said she would have to take it back to where it was purchased. Rock showed him the receipt to confirm it had been bought at the Somerset store.
Then he didn't want to accept the camera because the serial numbers didn't match.
"I told him it was obvious the camera had been purchased at the store," she said. "I was losing my patience and I was getting louder and louder."
Suddenly, a man arrived, identified himself as a manager and said the store no longer handles that model of Samsung camera.
"I told him that wasn't my problem," Rock said.
The manager suggested a "comparable" camera.
"I told him I wanted my money back," she said.
When the manager realized she wasn't going to leave the store without a refund, he gave it to her.
Robert Metheney, the manager of the camera department, said Rock shouldn't have had a problem returning the camera to any Wal-Mart as long as she had the receipt and the box it came in and brought it back within 90 days of purchase.
He said the company that made the software for the Samsung camera she returned has gone out of business. "I yanked all of those cameras off the shelf," he said.
Rock said she will compare serial numbers on items and the containers they come in from now on. "I also will save those containers for a while, along with the receipts, in case something has to be returned," she said.
"It seems clear to me that someone, somewhere, didn't check to see that the serial numbers on the camera and the box matched. Consumers shouldn't have to check such things, but they'd better if they don't want to go through what we've gone through.
"We will never go back to Wal-Mart," she said.
Power outage update -- Duquesne Light Co. yesterday said at least two Carnegie Mellon University buildings, including Mudge Hall on Morewood Avenue, a residence for graduate students, have been affected by extensive power outages that have plagued nine apartment and condominium buildings on Fifth Avenue on the border of Oakland and Shadyside for more than a year.
Student housing representatives have been invited to attend a meeting at 7 p.m. Wednesday at Rodef Shalom Temple on Fifth Avenue, where Duquesne Light officials will discuss the problem with the affected residents. The company said it needs to shut off the power for up to 16 hours to make repairs and wants customer input on what day to do it.
For more information about the meeting, call 412-393-1502.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.