Camille and Kipp Madison were pretty sure they’d become city folk when they sold the house they’d built in Seven Fields as a young married couple in the mid-1990s. With their two kids grown, they no longer needed four bedrooms in the suburbs.

“We wanted the urban feel,” says Mr. Madison, who also wanted to be closer to his job as a graphic designer in the South Side.

But the Pittsburgh houses they saw didn’t appeal to them. The living spaces were small, most had no yards and they wanted a garage.

Somehow they ended up looking at houses in North Hills Estates in Ross, a leafy community of homes built in the 1930s and ’40s to entice Pittsburghers to ride the “magic carpet of McKnight Road” to suburbia.

Advertise with us

One in particular caught their eye in the summer of 2018: an 85-year-old brick Tudor with elegant stonework and a slate roof that begged for a little TLC.

“We just thought this is the house,” says Ms. Madison.

The couple ended up doing a complete top-to-bottom renovation before moving in last December. But the most dramatic change was the kitchen; the skillful blend of original charm with clean, modern touches made the Madisons and designer Kad Favorite winners of the small category of the 2019 Renovation Inspiration Contest, which is judged by staffers of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Construction Junction.

Built in 1935, the house was dark and dreary when they purchased it in July 2018. Small windows afforded little natural light, and the dark kitchen was woefully outdated and cramped.

To make it the open-concept living space they’d set their hearts on, Ms. Favorite suggested removing walls that separated the dining room, kitchen and living room, adding windows and making the entire first floor one large, sun-filled space.

Advertise with us

Mr. Madison admits the open kitchen concept was a bit daring for a traditional Tudor. Yet he and his wife love its clean lines and original elements, including leaded-glass corner cabinets that were relocated and painted white.

“We wanted to keep anything that was beautiful and historic, so long as it was open, with good gathering spaces,” he says.

The natural focal point is a new 6-by-4-foot center island that’s as functional as it is pretty. Painted a soothing dove gray with bright white quartzite counter tops, it features three modern bar stools from West Elm on one side and a Sharp microwave drawer on the other.  The island was custom crafted by Stone Connection Granite & Cabinetry on Neville Island.

Mr. Madison is “anti-chain,” so the light above the table, discovered on the Sea Gull Lighting website, hangs from sleek steel tubing. The seeded glass cone pendants over the island are from Home Depot.

“I’m a very ‘match’ sort of guy, so I think it mixes well,” he says.

Advertise with us

The original red oak floors were dark and dirty when the couple moved in, and very, very orange. Now freshly sanded to the color of melted caramel, they were sealed with several coats of polyurethane.

“They creak but they look good,” Mr. Madison says.

Mike Sante made the custom poplar dining table with iron legs that mirror the diamond pattern of the window in the arched front door. Mr. Madison admits the Lucite ghost chairs around it aren’t particularly comfortable, but they shake up the room’s style in a very midcentury way.

The wood-burning fireplace next to the front door wasn’t an easy fix. After cleaning years of black soot and nastiness off the stone surround, it was converted into a vented gas fireplace.

There are new Marvin windows throughout the house, including narrow, black-framed casement windows in the dining room and kitchen. Rather than window treatments, the couple rely on the yard’s lush vegetation to keep things private.

Advertise with us

Ms. Favorite also repurposed a dead space beside the kitchen into a mud room with a built-in pantry and a quiet office area.

The couple acknowledges the renovation was a bigger project than they had anticipated, but other than tearing out part of one wall — a restoration project requiring the skills of Bobby Owens —  there were no catastrophes. Mr. Owens did the tiling, painting, cabinetry and floor refinishing. Paul Favorite, the designer’s brother, did carpentry, trim and doors and helped with the cabinets.

Ms. Favorite credits her clients for buying into her dramatic reimagining of a traditional space. “They have a wonderful eye for design, and good taste.”

“We just love it so much,” says Mr. Madison. “It was such a change.”

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.