Michael Smith has been designing the stores that sell American Eagle’s cool-casual clothing for more than two decades. So it’s no surprise that the house he shares with husband Thom McDonell in the South Side Slopes is funky and fabulous.

An undated photo showing Engine House No. 22 while it was in use. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Even cooler, it’s a 125-year-old firehouse that once served the city’s Arlington Heights neighborhood. You still can climb all the way up into its hose tower for a panoramic view of the city or to party on its rooftop deck.

After a careful three-year makeover, the couple entered this year’s Renovation Inspiration Contest and were named winners of the large residential category. The contest is judged and sponsored by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Construction Junction. The house is also one of several that will be open from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. May 19 for the 28th annual South Side Home Tour.

28th annual South Side Home Tour

Advertise with us

Where: Check-in at Brew House Lofts, 711 S. 21st St., 15203.

When: 11 a.m.-4 p.m. May 19.

Tickets: $18 through May 18 at www.showclix.com/event/sshometour19; $20 day of tour. Proceeds benefit South Side Community Council.

Visitors get a glimpse early on of Mr. Smith’s design philosophy. “Long live fun!” shouts a giant board on the steel staircase that defines the first-floor space. Like many of the accents in the house, it was repurposed from American Eagle, in this case its 77 Kids program.

Engine House No. 22 was built in the Italianate style in 1894, supposedly on a pile of fill dug out from in front of the Allegheny County Courthouse in Downtown. It served the city’s residents well for almost 90 years, and a log of fire calls remains with the house. After the fire station was decommissioned — the new No. 22 stands on nearby Arlington Avenue — an architect acquired it from the city in 1983. He stripped away much of the building’s original interior, and the next owner made few changes.

Advertise with us

By the time Mr. Smith bought the property in 2006, the only thing that set it apart — other than its unique history — was its cramped and quirky layout. He was living in a loft in Uptown then and hadn’t lived in a “normal” house since he was a kid in Brockway, Jefferson County.

Michael Smith, left, and Thom McDonell in the living room of the former Engine House No. 22, a Pittsburgh fire station in the South Side Slopes. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“It just felt right here,” he said.

A complete restoration wasn’t economically feasible, so for the next nine years, Mr. Smith, who studied architecture at Carnegie Mellon University, had to settle for adding pizzazz with paint,  cool design elements and interesting decor, like a glass table with an industrial base that came out of a store in Chicago.

When Mr. McDonell moved in in 2012, the couple decided it was time to update, starting with a new oven. That quickly mushroomed into an entire gut job of the first floor and mezzanine in 2015. Mr. McDonell, an agent with Howard Hanna Real Estate Services, said it was time to put their own stamp on the place.

The goal was to open up the space and make it more utilitarian while respecting the building’s history. Changes included painted wainscoting in the living room to match original boards in the garage, shiplap siding in the enlarged kitchen, and a cool industrial railing made from steel pipe for the new staircase.

Advertise with us
The kitchen features Carrara marble counter tops and walls covered with shiplap siding and subway tile. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Smith designed the Shaker-style cabinets, which were made by Creekside Cabinets. Painted peppercorn gray, they complement the kitchen’s white subway tile walls  and stainless-steel KitchenAid appliances. Framed cookie cutters and wooden spoons add a touch of whimsy.  The Carrara marble counters are gorgeous but vulnerable to stains, he said. They also added central air conditioning, a new garage door and vintage cast-iron ornaments to the house’s exterior.

The following summer, the couple restored all the original red window frames and painted the exterior trim. In 2017, they rebuilt the 25-foot-tall hose tower and redid the rooftop deck, which offers views of the neighborhood with PPG Place’s glass spires Downtown in the distance.

The hose tower, which was plagued by birds, wasps and other bugs, proved especially difficult. But it also provided a surprise: They found remnants of the original boxcar siding under more modern tin sheathing. They repurposed what could be salvaged on the tower’s ceiling and lovingly restored the original hose pulley and hooks where firemen dried their canvas hoses so long ago.

“It’s so special and unique because it’s all original,” said Mr. McDonell.

The family room is in a former bunk room for firemen. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A postage stamp-sized courtyard off the back door still needs major work, but the couple were married there anyway last July under the scaffolding.

Advertise with us

What’s especially charming about this firehouse-turned-home is its unique decorations. There’s a child-sized fire engine in the third-floor living room along with Thai statues and a stack of vintage trunks and suitcases.

On a desk is the log containing hand-written call reports from 1927, including gas tank explosions and five-alarm fires. Several rooms display Mr. Smith’s framed anatomical drawings.

Mr. McDonell is amazed at the result — and that his husband used all of the furniture, accents and objets d'art he had been storing in the basement.

“I thought I married a hoarder!” he said, laughing.

“It has been a labor of love, but it is our hope that we are helping to preserve a special part of Pittsburgh history,” said Mr. Smith.

Advertise with us

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.