After 18 years in a Peters Township subdivision, no one could fault Robin Zoufalik and his wife, Katie, for wanting to downsize on the North Side.
Empty nesters often trade their big suburban homes for snug city dwellings once the kids grow up and move out. Three years ago, the couple was more than ready to swap yard work and always driving somewhere for the convenience and excitement of urban living.
The 19th-century townhouse they bought on Beech Avenue would take 18 long months to renovate. But when the dust finally cleared, it was such a showpiece that it was chosen as a finalist in the Post-Gazette’s 2017-18 Renovation Inspiration Contest in the large residential category (over $50,000). It’s also one of six historic properties on next weekend’s A Tour and Tasting in Old Allegheny, which offers wine and hors d’oeuvres at each stop of a home and garden tour.
The walking tour on June 22-23 offers a peek at some of the neighborhood’s most lavishly landscaped and decorated spaces and features wines from California’s Paso Robles region, along with food pairings.
A Tour & Tasting in Old Allegheny
When: 5-9 p.m. June 22, 1-5 p.m. and 5-9 p.m. June 23.
Tickets: $75 at http://alleghenywest.org/tour/a-tour-tasting-in-old-allegheny/
On Sept. 15, the Allegheny West Civic Council will host a second, more intimate “Ground to Glass” event at Holmes Hall, a restored Italianate mansion and former home for boys on Brighton Road. Hosted by Deb Mortillaro of Dreadnought Wines, the event will feature four select wines with food pairings from California’s Eberle Winery. Vintner and owner Gary Eberle is a Coraopolis native and Penn State alum who co-founded the Paso Robles appellation in the Napa Valley in 1983.
Allegheny West, which is bounded by Brighton Road and Allegheny, West North and Ridge avenues, is Pittsburgh’s smallest neighborhood and has been a national historic district since 1978.
When the Zoufaliks decided to downsize to the North Side in 2014, he tried to steer his wife toward a loft with a balcony in a chic industrial building. She wouldn’t hear of it. If they were going to pack up their old life for a new one in smaller quarters, it had to be in an old home full of history and character, with a small side yard. It also had to be within walking distance of Downtown or a T-stop, so they could enjoy all the city has to offer.
The two-story townhouse was built in the Italianate style in 1874, perhaps by Prussian engineer John Endre, who designed the Monongahela Incline. It was in good shape structurally, with period details like original interior wood shutters on tall, single-pane windows, high ceilings and old wood floors. But it lacked the open concept they desired. Enter Maryanne Liddle, the architectural designer who helped come up with a plan to create the large, light and airy spaces they loved without compromising the character of the original property.
With three bedrooms and 3½ baths, it was a little larger than they wanted. But its location on a flat, leafy street reminded the couple of a 1914 farmhouse they’d lived in, and loved, long ago in Gaithersburg, Md.
Kenny Simmons of K. Simmons Remodeling & Plastering removed a wall that connected the dining room and kitchen, restored the trim in the family room and re-opened a boarded-up staircase and hidden fireplaces. Another contractor renovated a mudroom off the kitchen and refashioned a carport into into an inviting outdoor space. A to Zito Custom Hardwood Floors restored the century-old oak floors to their original luster.
The Zoufaliks, who also redid all three bathrooms with new fixtures, flooring and cabinets, originally planned to do the renovation slowly, in three stages, but wound up combining projects. Mr. Zoufalik, a supply management and business development professional, used one of the bedrooms as his home office.
The new kitchen is a cook’s dream. White oak floors from Emlenton’s Allegheny Mountain Hardwood Flooring mimic the originals with an intricate inlay. The custom maple cabinets with seeded glass doors are by Amish craftsman David K. Mast of Countryside Woodworks in New Wilmington. He also recreated missing parts of the crown and shoe molding to blend with original woodwork. A small window over the previous location of the kitchen sink was replaced with a sunlight-loving French door.
Handy with a skillet, Mr. Zoufalik has no problem whipping up the Texas fajitas of his youth on the six-burner Capital range with a built-in grill. A pair of 48-inch ovens and a wall-mounted pot filler make for super-easy pasta. The shiny white subway tile backsplash contrasts beautifully with the leather-finish Absolute Black granite counter tops from Armina Stone in Cheswick.
A former den is now the dining room. Quietly understated, it features a wall of windows overlooking the side yard that shine light on Mrs. Zoufalik’s collection of family antiques. A back staircase leads to a guest bedroom with a decorative fireplace and remodeled bath with aqua walls. The walk-in shower is in a former chimney and has frameless glass doors from Rex Glass, white subway tile walls and a basketweave tile floor. It easily fits two.
The marble master bath is even more spectacular, outfitted with a large BainUltra air-jet tub and a walk-in shower with period fixtures.
To return to the 19th century, you have to head back downstairs. In the foyer, leather-stamped walls greet visitors and the living room boasts a century-old marble fireplace.
“The house is very livable and easy to entertain in, which we both like to do,” says Mr. Zoufalik, adding that the the porte cochere and summer outdoor room earned an Allegheny West preservation award.
“We are proud of the work we have done and want others to be inspired as we were by other homes we have seen on past tours.’
The neighborhood, says Mrs. Zoufalik, is very social, but not overly so.
“It’s so quiet here,” she says. “We never expected it.”
Tour tickets cost $75 and include wine and hors d’oeuvres. It runs from 5- 9 p.m. June 22 and 1-5 p.m. or 5-9 p.m. June 23. From 7-9:30 p.m. Sept. 15, the “Ground to Glass” showcase features Eberle Wines at Holmes Hall. Tickets are limited and cost $150. Information: 1-888-718-4253 or http://alleghenywest.org/tour/a-tour-tasting-in-old-allegheny/.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.