No one knows what brought J.H. Williams of Brownsville and H.N. Dunbar of Pittsburgh to the Titlow Hotel in downtown Uniontown in June 1910. The two businessmen paid about $1.50 to spend the night in rooms 422 and 407, respectively, according to the hotel register.

But it’s not hard to guess why someone would want to live in the old hotel today. Its rooms are being turned into some of the nicest apartments in Fayette County’s biggest city.

Rents for the eight occupied units range from $750 to $1,250 for fully furnished studio, one- or two-bedroom apartments with 650 to 1,000 square feet, internet and Direct TV. The old parlors where guests warmed themselves by gas fireplaces have been turned into studio apartments and the subway-tiled bathrooms that used to serve adjoining rooms now add vintage charm to large apartments.

Exposed brick walls with gleaming electrical conduit give a modern vibe to grand old spaces with 12-foot ceilings and tall, narrow windows.

Advertise with us

“We kept the 84- by 36-inch window openings,” said Jeff DiMaio, owner of what’s now known as the Titlow Tavern & Grille (www.titlowtavern.net or 724-437-6749). “We replaced over 100 windows.”

His eight tenants range in age from 25 to 48 and include a software developer, sommelier and other professionals.

Steve Neubauer, owner of nearby Neubauer's Flowers, has two two-bedroom apartments above his shop. Rent for their fully furnished 1,100 square feet of space is $1,250 including utilities. They’re occupied by a schoolteacher in her 20s and a Marcellus Shale fracking manager in his 30s.

Several years ago, Mr. Neubauer bought a nearby century-old building that was first the Ella Peach School and later Uniontown School District’s administration building. He’s considering turning it into 16 apartments.

“I’m a believer in the area,” said the Waynesburg native who moved to Uniontown nearly 35 years ago to run his 95-year-old family business.

Advertise with us

He actually lived in one of the apartments he now rents when he was in his 20s. He says Pittsburgh’s Downtown isn’t the only one attracting millennials.

“People say no one wants to live downtown. I don’t believe that to be the case. There are more bars and restaurants catering to people under 30.”

When Mr. DiMaio was in his 20s, he was booking rock and jazz bands in hopes of luring young crowds to his father’s bar and restaurant in the old hotel. Charles May (he Anglicized the family name) bought the landmark with the caved-in roof in 1970. By the early ’80s, its upper three floors had become a “welfare hotel” whose tenants paid $162 a month, Mr. DiMaio said.

He was a cook for 15 years before deciding that hiring real chefs would be money well spent. In 1978, he took over the hotel with three bars, a restaurant and a 1912 dining room. He has been renovating the building since the early ’80s and started on the second-floor apartments four years ago. He and his contractors turned 22 of the hotel’s original 64 rooms into eight luxury apartments. By the end of 2017, he hopes to finish turning 21 third-floor rooms into eight lofts with long-term leases and storage units on the fourth floor.

Mr. DiMaio also has rehabbed the second and third floors of the 1920s building next door into commercial space. He may expand his restaurant into its first floor.

Advertise with us

The lifelong Uniontown resident can remember the 1960s, when Main Street’s sidewalks were so packed with shoppers, diners and others that you had to walk in the street, dodging traffic. Then he watched a long slow decline as local mills, stores and other businesses shut their doors. By the 1980s, he said the Titlow, Neubauer’s Flowers and a couple banks were about the only businesses left downtown.

Uniontown’s revival has been as slow as its decline, he said. The upper stories of old buildings like his are once again filling with residents, just as they were in their heyday.

“Main street is turning back into their front yard,” Mr. DiMaio said.

“That’s how you turn around these small towns. You get people living down there.”

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.

Advertise with us