On a street filled with houses at least 150 years old, Robert Shaposka had his eye on only one. Having grown up near Brownsville, he had heard that the owners of 322 Front St. had passed away.

“I kinda geared up for it and sold my condo in Mt. Lebanon. Basically, I stalked this house,” he said, laughing.

In September 2011, he bought the three-story stone building whose front features stucco, old wooden windows with wavy glass and one more thing: a Pennsylvania historic marker identifying the house, built in 1816, as the birthplace of Philander C. Knox, U.S. attorney general for Presidents McKinley and Theodore Roosevelt, secretary of state for President Taft and a two-term U.S. senator.

Now this three-bedroom, 1 ½-bath piece of history is on the market for $124,900 (MLS No.1228528) through Doug Burig of Keller Williams Real Estate Professionals (412-997-3249 or http://theburigteam.com/).

Advertise with us

Why so little? Well, Brownsville is not a hot real estate market. Many of its downtown storefronts are vacant and the average sales price of the 80 properties now on the market is $81,142.

Six years ago, Mr. Burig had a listing for a much larger nearby house of about the same age. Its starting price was $375,000 but it ended up selling in 2010 for just under $130,000. Flippers clearly aren’t flocking to Brownsville.

“The people who buy these houses come looking for historic homes,” Mr. Burig said. “This is a one-of-a-kind street. There’s nothing like it in the area.”

Another house in the same block of Front Street is one of 13 stops on the Brownsville Ghost Walk on Aug. 6 (see related story). Its owner will dress as a Civil War soldier to tell tour-goers about the spectral soldier he has seen there.

Mr. Shaposka doesn’t have any stories like that, but he loves this house as much as any antique he has hunted down. The 24-by- 8-foot foyer features a gaming table once owned by the Knox family. A friend bought it at auction and gave it to him.

Advertise with us

On the left is a 29- by- 16-foot living room with his office at one end. The gas-burning fireplace set on an angle in the middle of one wall suggests this was once two rooms, but the old hardwood floor with square nails gives no clues. It was apparently laid after the wall came down. Mr. Shaposka discovered old horsehair plaster while removing wallpaper in the living room and front hall.

Beyond it is a 16- by- 15-foot dining room that the owner believes was added after 1816, but not too much after because the stone on its exterior closely matches that of the original house.

A side porch in the rear was probably closed in much more recently (it has drywall and newer windows). The adjacent galley kitchen measures 11 by 8 feet and was updated by the previous owners, he said.

In the basement is an old coal cellar and a large open fireplace that Mr. Shaposka believes was used to cook in the original kitchen. He closed its flue to reduce heat loss and added a new gas-burning, forced-air furnace and central air conditioning.

The landing halfway up the original front staircase gives another hint that this house was built in stages. A small casement window that once probably overlooked the backyard now offers access to one of three attic spaces. The two second-floor bedrooms measure 16 by 15 feet and 14 by 13 feet. The one used as a master has all modern furniture but the other contains an heirloom antique bed, its original decorative fireplace and crown molding.

Advertise with us

The third bedroom on the third floor measures 23 by 10 feet and has an exposed brick chimney, tiny windows with deep sills and knotty-pine paneling installed by the previous owners. Mr. Shaposka has added modern furniture and an old Westinghouse radio that he inherited from his grandparents, who also lived in Brownsville. An open house will be held from 1 to 3 p.m. Aug. 7.

Since he works in Downtown Pittsburgh -- a one-hour commute -- he plans to move closer to the city. But he will miss this Fayette County town that boomed two centuries ago at the junction of the National Road and Monongahela River and later gave birth to a lawyer who hobnobbed with three presidents, Henry Clay Frick and Andrew Mellon.

“This place is deep with history,” he said. “Everyone asks me about ghosts, but I’ve never seen anything, never gotten a bad feeling in this house.”

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.

*****

Advertise with us

Brownsville at a glance

Website: http://brownsvilleborough.com/home/

Size: 1 square mile

Population: 2,239

School District: Brownsville Area

Advertise with us

Enrollment: 1,797 students

Average SAT scores: Math 510, Reading 520, Writing 490

Inside out: In 1740, Delaware Indian chief Nemacolin cut a path through the Laurel Highlands that was later used by early white settlers. Parts of Nemacolin’s Trail became the National Road, this country's first federally funded and built road. In Brownsville, Front Street was laid on a section of the trail. Fort Burd, also known as Redstone Old Fort, was built in 1759 by Col. James Burd. Thomas Brown, the borough’s namesake, laid out the town in 1785. Ten years later, Jacob Bowman became Brownsville’s first postmaster. His house, also known as Nemacolin Castle, still overlooks the Monongahela River.

Many of the vacant storefronts in Brownsville’s downtown were among more than 100 buildings purchased in the early 1990s by Ernest and Marilyn Liggett of Churchill in hopes of turning the borough into a tourist destination. When that didn’t happen, the Fayette County Redevelopment Authority sued the Liggetts for back taxes and other violations and seized some of the properties in hopes of attracting new businesses.

Total taxes on 322 Front St. (assessed $63,500): $1,757.25

Advertise with us

School: (18.18 mills) $1,154

Borough: (5 mills) $317.50

County: (4.5 mills) $285.75

— Kevin Kirkland, Post-Gazette