As the whitetail deer population of Western Pennsylvania continues to rise, control of this pest has become one of the biggest challenges for home gardeners.

Deer feast on vegetable gardens, flower beds, shrubs and trees. They will graze on leaves, grass, bark, acorns, fruits, nuts, berries, lichens and fungi. On average a single deer can consume 5 to 10 pounds of plant material a day. They are efficient and clever at accessing food sources. Some of their favorites include apples, yews, rhododendrons, roses and hostas.

Deer tend to feed at night and usually remain awake until dawn. When confronted, deer will typically bolt if they sense danger. However, they can grow at ease with people, pets and cars that appear as nonthreatening. And as land development increases, deer are becoming more common in densely populated areas.

Deer resistant annuals

Advertise with us

No plant is deer-proof, but there are definitely annuals that are less palatable to deer. The following list was compiled after 20 years of experience selecting and growing annuals in the demonstration gardens at North and South parks. We use this list as a guideline when choosing plants to grow in the trial gardens.

• Agastache spp. (hyssop)

• Ageratum houstonianum (floss flower)

• Anagallis hybrid (pimpernal)

• Angelonia angustifolia (Summer snapdragon)

Advertise with us

• Antirrhinum majus (snapdragon)

• Asclepias curassavica (annual butterfly weed)

• Bidens ferulifolia (bur marigold)

• Bracteantha bracteata (strawflower)

• Calendula officinalis (pot marigold)

Advertise with us

• Capsicum annuum (ornamental pepper)

• Catharanthus roseus (periwinkle)

• Chrysocephalum apiculatum (yellow buttons)

• Cleome spp. (spider flower)

• Cosmos spp. (cosmos)

Advertise with us

• Diascia hybrid (twinspur)

• Gomphrena spp. (globe amaranth)

• Lantana camara (lantana)

• Lobelia spp. (edging lobelia)

• Lobularia maritima (sweet alyssum)

Advertise with us

• Melampodium paludosum (medallion flower)

• Nemesia fruticans (nemesia)

• Nierembergia scoparia (cup flower)

• Osteospermum hybrid (African daisy)

• Pennisetum glaucum (ornamental millet)

Advertise with us

• Pennisetum setaceum 'Rubrum' (purple fountain grass)

• Plumbago auriculata (cape leadwort)

• Salvia spp. (ornamental sage)

• Tagetes spp. (marigold)

• Verbena spp. (verbena)

Advertise with us

• Zinnia spp. (zinnia)

Gardeners resort to various methods to keep deer from decimating the landscape. Fences are among the most effective deterrents. Deer can jump over an 8-foot barrier, so non-electrified fences will need to be at least that high.

One product, developed by a veterinarian in 1996, is the wireless deer fence. This system uses posts that are placed around plants that deer like to eat. They are attracted by a sweet smell given off by the posts. When they touch the posts, they receive a harmless shock that frightens them and trains them never to return. It is a safe and nontoxic product.

Other products on the market include deer-repellent sprays and granules. Those available at most garden centers use natural ingredients that are offensive to the deer's sense of smell and taste. They are often safe to use on shrubs and flowers when applied according to label instructions.

For food crops, be sure to purchase a product that is labeled safe for use on fruits and vegetables. Many products claim to not wash off after rainstorms. Rotate the use of the various repellents for maximum protection.

Advertise with us

Some gardeners find the use of Milorganite, which has a strong odor, effective for repelling deer. Milorganite is a fertilizer made from a byproduct of wastewater treatment. A number of researchers have found it to be effective when broadcast around plants every two weeks in the summer. It is not as effective in the winter when other food sources are scarce and deer become ravenous.

Other somewhat unorthodox treatments include spreading human urine or coyote urine around the base of plants or leaving human hair clippings, blood meal or moth balls around plants. Highly scented deer-resistant plants, including boxwood, rosemary and lemon thyme, can be planted among plants deer like.

Other deterrents include a homemade spray made of a beaten egg, garlic powder, cayenne pepper, dish soap and cooking oil mixed in water. The foliage of the plants must be sprayed every couple of weeks, and, if it rains, the substance must be reapplied.

There are always plants that deer generally do not eat. Try planting annuals such as marigolds, sweet alyssum, angelonia, or zinnias. (See the list at left of "deer resistant" annuals that the Penn State Master Gardeners recommend based on the trials at the demonstration gardens.)

Perennials that deer tend not to eat include: daffodils, hyacinths, columbine, ferns, epimedium, yarrow, monkshood, foxglove, lavender, peonies and iris. Trees and shrubs that deer usually avoid include: bottlebrush buckeye, sweetshrub, Virginia sweetspire, Japanese kerria and rugosa rose.

Advertise with us

Of course, almost all flower and vegetable plants can fall prey to deer. Whether or not a particular plant species will be eaten depends on the deer's previous experience, nutritional needs, plant palatability, seasonal factors, weather conditions, and the availability of alternative foods. Deer are creatures of habit, and they have good memories and learn from each other. Their movement patterns and prior foraging can predict where damage may occur.

By carefully planning your garden, selecting those plants least desirable to deer and the use of physical deterrents, you can enjoy your garden along with the deer that inhabit the area.

On Aug. 20, Penn State Master Gardeners of Allegheny will host Garden in the Park field day at the demonstration gardens in North and South Parks. This free event includes tours of the trial beds highlighting the deer-resistant annuals that were successfully grown in the gardens this summer. For more information, call 412-473-2540 or visit www.extension.psu.edu/allegheny.